ThinkProgress Logo

LGBT

NEWS FLASH

Poll: 54 Percent of North Carolinians Oppose Amendment One | Fifty-four of North Carolinians surveyed are opposed to Amendement One, an amendment banning same-sex marriages, civil unions and domestic partnerships, according to a nonpartisan poll released today by Elon University. The percentage of those in oppostion to the ban jumped to 57 percent when asked whether they would support an amendment “that would prevent civil unions and domestic partnerships for same-sex couples,” with 34 percent expressing strong opposition, up from 22 percent in February 2011. Given Amendment One does, in fact, ban civil unions and domestic partnerships, this speaks to the importance of educating voters about the measure before May 8. Around 38 percent of those polled were supportive of the amendment, compared to polling three months ago where 58 percent of voters said they would vote for the bill in May. These results show momentum against the discriminatory amendment, but reveal that voters still do not understand the full implication of the legislation. — Fatima Najiy

NEWS FLASH

Missouri House Advances Nondiscrimination Protections — For Gun Owners | The state of Missouri has no laws that protect LGBT people from employment or housing discrimination, but yesterday the Missouri House advanced a new nondiscrimination bill that protects gun owners. Were the law to pass, it would ensure that anyone who legally carries a firearm cannot be fired, denied benefits, or otherwise discriminated against for that choice. Rep. Mike Colona (D), who is openly gay, pointed out that “what this body has done is put protecting gun ownership above discriminating against somebody because of their sexual orientation, and I just don’t think that’s right.”

Meet Washington State’s Anti-Equality Signatories

Opponents of equality are currently collecting signatures in an attempt to challenge Washington state’s new marriage equality law at the ballot through Referendum 74. But Washington conservatives have pushed back on same-sex couples’ recognition before, through 2009′s failed Referendum 71, a challenge to the state’s “everything but marriage” domestic partnerships. Despite attempts to keep the signatories of that campaign hidden, they are now publicly available at whosigned.org, and one activist is attempting to reach out to all of them.

So far, Paul Thomasson has emailed almost 2,000 of the R71 signers, identifying himself as a gay veteran and encouraging them not to sign R74. So far, he has received 60 email responses, all of which he has published on his webpage. Many, if not most, of those who reply take time to explain why they oppose same-sex marriage and reaffirm their Christian beliefs, like this prototypical example:

The reason I did, and will again, is simple. The family is the foundation of our country. Relationships have been created and defined by God. When you start to redefine and do things outside of that, it is destructive. I am not a hater of homosexuals. I have good friends that struggle with it. I will not endorse the practice though. It is a counterfeit love that comes from pain/woundings. It is no different than the sins I struggle with. I don’t seperate you from me. We both fall short. And we both have a Savior who paid the price for our sins. I love you and hope GOD’s will for your life. Thanks for the email

A few respondents have actually had a change of heart or at least agreed to reconsider their position, like this couple:

Dear Paul,

Thank you for sharing your life story. Don’t worry, we will not support R 74. Good luck to you and your life partner.

Mike & [wife's unusual name redacted]

But many of the respondents are concerned that their information is publicly available. They believe that even though they signed a legal document to impact the legislative process, their identities should remain completely anonymous, like the author of this reply:

Dear Paul: I appreciate your activism. I routinely sign petitions because I believe that people should have a more direct say in the laws that govern them. However, I also strongly believe that voting and petition signing should be by secret ballot. I therefore consider the listing of petitioner’s names, irregardless of the court’s ruling on the matter, an anti-democratic invasion of my privacy and a subversion of people’s freedom. It is the sort of thing I would expect from a dictatorial form of government. I think you should consider this aspect of using the list that was made public over the petitioner’s objections before you use it. Thank You for taking time to hear my views on this. Sincerely, Cal [last name redacted]

Paul Thomasson’s email is anything but threatening, but replies like Cal’s are proving to be quite common in his project. It’s an odd perspective that these individuals expect to have the power to impact the law without having to be held accountable for playing that role. At the foundation of democracy is ensuring that lawmakers are accountable to voters, but many of these signatories seem to believe they have rights that circumvent that principle. Of course, these are also individuals seeking to roll back rights the legislature has advanced — an undemocratic notion— so perhaps it sensibly follows they also feel they should bear no responsibility for the consequences.

Nevertheless, Thomasson’s effort could make a significant difference in how many Washington voters think about Referendum 74 this year, which is crucial given how they are currently split. Plus, their replies provide a compelling glimpse into the opposition’s beliefs.

NEWS FLASH

Minnesota Campaign Finance To Investigate Anti-Gay Groups Pushing Marriage Amendment | Minnesota’s Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board has launched an investigation into groups heavily involved in promoting a proposed constitutional amendment to outlaw marriage equality in Minnesota. The coalition pushing for the amendment, Minnesota for Marriage, and one of its strongest arms, the Minnesota Family Council, are under investigation for failure to disclose the names of donors whose contributions totaled hundreds of thousands of dollars. In early February, ThinkProgress noted a discrepancy in the groups’ tax filings. Minnesotans are nearly evenly split on the amendment, which will be on the ballot in November of this year.

Newly Designated Anti-Gay Hate Groups Earned That Distinction

Sons of Thundr ad "All homos are: sick, brain damaged perverts!"

Image from the website of anti-gay hate group Sons of Thundr

Yesterday, ThinkProgress LGBT noted that a new report by the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) identifies 27 active anti-gay hate groups, up from 17 in 2010. Sadly, the 11 groups new to this list from last year richly deserved the dubious honor.

They are:

  • United Families International (Gilbert, AZ): This group backed the sodomy laws ruled unconstitutional in the Lawrence v. Texas case and has argued “No one is ‘born that way.’ Policies that would normalize homosexuality by equating homosexual behavior with innate characteristics such as race or ethnicity should be opposed.”
  • Save California (Sacramento, CA): The group is leading the charge to repeal California’s FAIR Education Act, hoping to stop teachers from “kidnapping the brains of kids” by teaching about the contributions of LGBT Americans. Save California’s head, Randy Thomasson, blamed a bullied and murdered gay teen for his own death.
  • Sons of Thundr (Faith Baptist Church) (Luthersville, GA): The church’s website feautures a “sodomites can be saved” section which claims “ALL HOMOS ARE: SICK, BRAIN DAMAGED, PERVERTS!”
  • You Can Run, But You Cannot Hide (Annandale, MN). Bradlee Dean, the group’s president and CEO, has said, “The gay ‘movement’ is part of a sexual revolution that has stripped sexuality of all moral significance for an entire generation. We cannot accept the physical prosecution of homosexuals and we cannot accept the proposal that homosexuality is either private or moral,” but notes he is opposed to actually executing LGBT citizens.
  • Parents Action League (Champlin, MN): A small group of parents in the bullying-riddled Anoka-Hennepin School District want to require schools to teach that AIDS is a gay disease and to promote harmful and ineffective ex-gay therapy.
  • Jewish Political Action Committee (Brooklyn, NY): This group claims that marriage equality in New York State has created a “surge” of child molestation and distributes signs that say “G-d sent AIDS to punish male gays.”
  • Mission: America (Columbus, OH): Lead by Linda Harvey, who has been dubbed “the most homophobic woman in America,” this group has discouraged the hiring of gay and lesbian employees and claimed that “there is no proof” that gay, lesbian or bisexual or transgendered people even exist.
  • Windsor Hills Baptist Church (Oklahoma City, OK): The church’s pastor, Tom Vineyard, argued against an employment non-discrimination proposal by making the bizarre claim that half of all murders in large cities are by gay people.
  • True Light Pentecost Church (Spartanburg, SC): On the church’s blog, it warns that “The sub-human culture created by the anti-christ and magnified by the Sodomite/Lesbian movement,” has “brought end-time prophecy to a final state,” and encourages followers to “fight the great sodomite/lesbian army.”
  • Tom Brown Ministries (El Paso, TX): Pastor and exorcist Tom Brown led the charge in El Paso to rescind an employment non-discrimination law he felt was “condoning immorality.” He also preaches that “homosexuality is actually an emotional, psychological disorder brought on early in childhood.”
  • Public Advocate of the United States (Falls Church, VA): Run by Loudoun County, Virginia Supervisor Eugene Delguaido (R), this group is infamous for its over-the-top anti-gay fundraising letters, including comments like, “As homosexuals die off due to AIDS, the remaining AIDS carriers prey on children to replenish the ‘Homosexual Community.’”

The SPLC observed that the advances of the LGBT equality movement “seemed to set off a furious rage on the religious right, with renewed efforts to ban or repeal marriage equality and what seemed to be an intensification of anti-gay propaganda in certain quarters.” These hate groups clearly are among those quarters.

NEWS FLASH

NOM Partner Calls Gay Community ‘Filth And Degradation’ | At NOM Exposed, Jeremy Hooper points out that the National Organization for Marriage has partnered with a conservative Orthodox Jewish group called Jews for Morality to campaign for Republican David Storobin, who is running for the New York Senate. NOM has lifted language directly from Jews for Morality’s anti-gay letters opposing Democrat Lewis Fidler for his support of LGBT rights, which call homosexuality a “disgusting ‘lifestyle’” and warn of the “filth and degradation” that can result:

Iowa School Accidentally Invites Anti-Gay Hate Group For Assembly

Dunkerton High School in Iowa thought it was providing students with a positive message about provocative lyrics in music, but the You Can Run But You Cannot Hide Ministry used its invitation yesterday to promote anti-gay and anti-choice messages with the students. Superintendent Jim Stanton then called a second assembly to apologize to the students, admitting he was wrong to bring the group to the district. He owned his mistake in an interview with KWWL:

STANTON: Where did that come from? That’s not what we were anticipating, and when we called the other schools where they had been… why wasn’t that mentioned? [...] To not take that responsibility, what is that teaching our children? We made a decision. It was a poor decision. And you know what? We’re going to suffer the consequences of that decision. We’re going to continue to do what we can to make it right.

Had the district researched the ministry, it would have quickly found the vile anti-gay rhetoric of its founder, Bradlee Dean. Dean has supported the criminalization, incarceration, and execution of gays through his radio show, which makes it no surprise that the Southern Poverty Law Center has designated his ministry a “hate group.” He also has close ties to Rep. Michele Bachmann (R-MN) and has defended the efforts of the Parents Action League — also now a designated “hate group” — to maintain an anti-LGBT atmosphere in Minnesota’s Anoka-Hennepin School District.

Watch KWWL’s report of the assembly gone awry, featuring reactions from students and parents.

NEWS FLASH

Equality Opponents Coerce North Carolina Children With Free Candy | Opponents of marriage equality are trying to drum up support for Amendment One with a bus tour around North Carolina. At one stop, the Vote for Marriage NC Values Bus (a project of the Family Research Council, an anti-gay hate group), distributed “free gifts and candy” to young kids:

These anti-gay groups claim that homosexuality is somehow a threat to children, but they are the ones trying to indoctrinate intolerance into young people. (HT: Pam’s House Blend.)

Health

HIV Infection Rate For African-American Women Five Times Higher Than Average In Some U.S. Cities

In some “hot spot” U.S. cities, the HIV infection rate for African-American women is five times higher than the national rate — close to the rate in some African countries.

Researchers who conducted the study expected the rate to be higher in these urban areas, but after one year, 0.24 percent of the women in the study tested positive for HIV. That’s five times higher than the Centers for Disease Control’s previous estimate for African-American women. And the rate for African-American women surprised researchers in a field that focuses more on African-American and gay men.
The study showed that the annual rate of infection was 24 per 10,000 African-American women in six cities: Baltimore; Atlanta; Newark, New Jersey; New York City; Raleigh-Durham, North Carolina; and Washington, D.C. Nationally, African-American women’s rate is 5 per 10,000. In the Congo, it is 28 per 10,000.

“This disease is alive and well in this country,” said Dr. Carlos Del Rio, principal investigator for the Atlanta area of the study. “But this epidemic is the face of the forgotten people.” And the cities highlighted by the 2009 study, which included 88 percent African-American women and 12 percent Latina women, have high poverty rates:

“Along with the results, a lot of other statistics came out of this study,” said Dr. Sally Hodder, lead author of the study and professor of medicine at New Jersey Medical School in Newark. “Slightly more than 40 percent of the women did not know the HIV status of their last sexual partner. And more than 40 percent of our participants had an annual household income of $10,000 or less.”

And out of all the women enrolled, after a one-year follow-up, 10 had died of reasons unrelated to HIV.

“This just goes to show that women don’t just have HIV risk to worry about in these areas of the country,” Del Rio said. “I’ve had women look at me and say, ‘OK, I’m at high risk for HIV, but I’m also at high risk of getting shot.’”

Del Rio pointed out that other factors such as poverty, food insecurity, and substance abuse also increase the HIV risk. Rather than only offering information about AIDS, he said these cities also need better access to medical care for HIV screenings, substance abuse treatment, education, and job availability to lower the risk.

Dr. Patrick Chaulk, Baltimore’s assistant commissioner for HIV and STD services in the Health Department, said the city is targeting all high-risk groups in its plan to cut the HIV infection rate by 25 percent by 2015. He said much of the city’s resources go toward men because they account for two-thirds of new cases. Nationally, the CDC reports that men make up three-quarters of new cases.

NEWS FLASH

Pope: Marriage Equality Bears ‘Immense Human And Economic Cost’ | Pope Benedict XVI has again spoken out against same-sex marriage, and he continues to use bizarre hyperbole to describe its supposed consequences. In an address to U.S. bishops, he said that marriage and family must be defended “from every possible misrepresentation of their true nature,” adding that “the contemporary crisis of marriage and the family… has led to grave societal problems bearing an immense human and economic cost.” In January, Benedict similarly described marriage equality as a threat to the “future of humanity itself.” Such comments continue the effort by leaders of the Catholic Church to foster a universe that does not recognize same-sex couples of any kind.

Justice

Reagan-Appointed Appeals Judge Suggests Sheriff Arpaio’s Pink Underwear Is Unconstitutional

The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit handed down an opinion in a truly tragic case yesterday involving a mentally ill man named Eric Vogel who broke into another person’s home and yelled at police to kill him while also demanding to speak with the President of the United States. Vogel was tossed in a jail run by Sheriff Joe Arpaio, the Arizona sheriff currently under DOJ investigation for widespread legal violations, where he was ordered to wear the pink underwear Arpaio routinely requires inmates to don. After Vogel refused to do so, he was held down by four officers while a fifth stripped him naked and forced the pink undergarments on him. Vogel died about a week later, allegedly because the stress caused by this incident and his schizophrenia caused his heart to give out.

In an opinion by Reagan-appointed Judge John Noonan, the Ninth Circuit did not simply revive a lawsuit brought by Vogel’s survivors against Arpaio, it also suggested that Arpaio’s policy of choosing underwear intended to demean his inmates violates the Constitution:

When a color of such symbolic significance is selected for jail underwear, it is difficult to believe that the choice of color was random. The County offers no penalogical reason, indeed no explanation whatsoever for its jail’s odd choice. Given the cultural context, it is a fair inference that the color is chosen to symbolize a loss of masculine identity and power, to stigmatize the male prisoners as feminine. . . .

As the Supreme Court has explained:

if a particular condition or restriction of pretrial detention is reasonably related to a legitimate governmental objective, it does not, without more, amount to “punishment.” Conversely, if a restriction or condition is not reasonably related to a legitimate goal—if it is arbitrary or purposeless—a court permissibly may infer that the purpose of the governmental action is punishment that may not constitutionally be inflicted upon detainees qua detainees.

Unexplained and undefended, the dress-out in pink appears to be punishment without legal justification.

Because the question of the underwear’s constitutionality was not raised in the trial court, the Ninth Circuit did not hold outright that the pink garments are illegal. Nevertheless, they strongly hinted that the lower court should do so when it takes up the case again.

  • Comment Icon

NEWS FLASH

Omaha Nondiscrimination Protections Face Proposed Limitations | As the City Council of Omaha, Nebraska, continues to deliberate establishing non-discrimination protections based on sexual orientation and gender identity, one council member is trying to limit the scope of the proposal. Rather than create city-wide employment and public accommodations protections as proposed by council member Ben Gray, council member Garry Gernandt wants to limit the policy only to employment and only to city hiring. Gernandt, who has opposed non-discrimination protections in the past, expressed concern that “blanketing the city with this, I’m just not sure that’s the right thing to do at this moment.”

Meanwhile, University of Nebraska-Lincoln Chancellor Harvey Perlman has clarified that Husker football assistant Ron Brown was not speaking on behalf of the university when he publicly opposed Omaha’s effort to protect LGBT residents.

Update

Watch a round-up of testimony against the bill via aksarbent:

Maryland Governor: Voters Will Side With ‘Human Dignity’ On Marriage Equality

Maryland Gov. Martin O’Malley (D) told Rachel Maddow last night that while he does expect marriage equality to be challenged at the ballot, he believes voters will side with “human dignity”:

O’MALLEY: There has been a conversation that has been taking place among our elected representatives over the last year, and the fruit of that conversation was that together, we concluded, that in fact we could pass a law that protects religious freedom and the rights of individuals equally, and to do that at the same time. In the end, we concluded that human dignity —the dignity of every person, the dignity of every child’s home — was the principle where we could come together. And I think that’s what people are going to do now as they talk around their own kitchen tables, in their family living rooms, and at work. So if there’s a referendum, I believe that the people of our state will once again side on the side of human dignity.

O’Malley also said that regardless of the outcome, Maryland will continue “the march of human understanding” toward marriage equality. Watch it:

A new poll released yesterday found that 52 percent of Maryland voters would “definitely” or “probably” vote to uphold the marriage equality law.

  • Comment Icon

Focus On The Family’s Most Pathetic Argument Against Same-Sex Adoption

Focus on the Family (and vicariously the National Organization for Marriage) has revealed just how inane their arguments against same-sex adoption are. In a post at CitizenLink this week, FOTF’s director of family formation studies, Glenn T. Stanton, tries to make the case that children of same-sex couples are “not problem-free” because girls are more likely to consider a same-sex encounter:

According to a study published late last year in the Archive of Sexual Behavior, girls raised by lesbian mothers are seven times more likely to consider a same-sex encounter, and twice as likely to identify as lesbian or bisexual than those raised by heterosexual parents. They are also seven times more likely to use “the “morning after” pill.

“We already know that girls who grow up without fathers are more likely to be sexually adventurous, and it has a lot to do with being fatherless,” Stanton explained. “Two lesbians can be the most loving moms in the world, but they can’t give a girl the kind of positive attention and other-gendered affirmation she needs from a dad.”

Not only is he regurgitating the debunked “fatherless” meme, he’s relying on a self-reinforcing argument. Stanton opposes same-sex couples having families because it might lead to more same-sex couples having families, and somehow that’s a “problem.” He seems to think it’s downright shocking that a child might grow up exposed to a loving and committed same-sex couple and actually feel comfortable considering such a possibility for herself, even though she’s no more likely to be gay than a child of opposite-sex parents. In fact, Stanton is contributing to the stigma that is actually the only thing that sets apart the life experiences of children raised by same-sex couples.

FOTF seems to rely on a shared assumption that anything gay is bad, but with a growing majority supporting marriage equality nationwide, this notion is quickly evaporating. Not only are these anti-gay conservatives admitting pure animus against LGBT people, they’re conceding that they don’t have any better arguments than archaic gender norms and petulant objection. Of course, they never did.

  • Comment Icon

The Morning Pride: March 9, 2012

Welcome to The Morning Pride, ThinkProgress LGBT’s daily round-up of the latest in LGBT policy, politics, and some culture too! Here’s what we’re reading this morning, but please let us know what stories you’re following as well. Follow us all day on Twitter at @TPEquality.

- Openly gay Facebook co-founder Chris Hughes has purchased The New Republic. NPR and The New York Times talked to Hughes about the decision this morning.

- A coalition of 70 organizations is calling on President Obama to endorse the Student Non-Discrimination Act (SNDA) as proof of his commitment to protecting LGBT youth from bullying.

- It’s been nine years since Lawrence v. Texas overturned sodomy laws as unconstitutional, but they’re still on the books in 14 states.

- HRC is petitioning Mitt Romney to fire his National Finance Chair, Frank VanderSloot, for being “one of the most ruthlessly anti-gay businessmen in the nation.”

- If you’re in or near North Carolina, consider attending a training about how to speak out against Amendment One.

- As the final hours of the legislative session approach, Indiana lawmakers are attempting another last-ditch effort to ban the license plates that support LGBT youth.

- Utah state Rep. Carol Spackman Moss (D) is calling on Gov. Gary Herbert (R) to veto HB363, which makes sex-ed classes optional, but bans all teaching about contraception, safe sex, and homosexuality.

- President Obama’s former nanny has been overwhelmed by recent media attention, but she hopes her story might “open people’s eyes” to transgender issues.

- Actor Colin Farrell is helping find anti-gay bullying in Ireland.

- Catholic leadership apparently does push polls on same-sex marriage in the UK just like it does in the U.S.

- The NFL’s bounty scandal includes former New Orleans Saints defensive coordinator Gregg Williams’ history of anti-gay language, including language like “You went in the wrong hole… We’re not running an AIDS convention here.”

- Country musician Chely Wright is helping open an LGBT community center in Kansas City, Missouri, this weekend.

- The Onion profiles seventh-grader and closeted homosexual Ben McElroy, who looks forward to the 30 minutes every day when he eats lunch on a staircase by himself:

McElroy, who has revealed his sexual orientation to no one but is unceasingly ridiculed by his peers for perceived feminine qualities in his voice, dress, and gait, confirmed that he enjoys his solitary meal on the staircase far more than the bus ride to school, the walk from the bus to homeroom, finding an unobtrusive seat in the back of every class and hoping he doesn’t get called on, receiving anonymous text messages from classmates telling him to kill himself, and every other moment of his day.[...]

McElroy, who sources reported has been called ”faggot” on 43 separate occasions in the past month, confirmed his favorite lunch spot is strategically located on the exact opposite end of the building from both the gymnasium and the hall most frequented by the school’s eighth-graders.

  • Comment Icon

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up