ThinkProgress Logo

LGBT

NEWS FLASH

Phoenix Mayor Lays Groundwork For LGBT Protections | Phoenix, Arizona Mayor Greg Stanton has convened a group of attorneys to draft ordinances that would protect the LGBT community from discrimination. Under current law, victims of such discrimination do not even have the opportunity to file complaints with the city’s Equal Opportunity Department. This became a problem in February when the Sheraton Phoenix Downtown Hotel ejected a lesbian couple for hugging and kissing in the hotel’s restaurant and the couple had no legal recourse for the unfair treatment. The City Council may resist the effort, due to reports that its members have privately shared their opposition to LGBT issues.

Alyssa

‘Smash,’ ‘Revenge,’ and ‘Mad Men’s Sneaky Bisexuals and Bitchy Blondes

I was hatewatching Smash this morning, and I realized the show is managing to be the second example for two mini-trends that have been bouncing around episodes in recent weeks—the sneaky bisexual, and the blonde being abused by her creator.

The fairly clear implication of last night’s episode was that assistant-turned-wannabe-producer Ellis was willing to sleep with a star’s agent to get her to consider playing Marilyn more seriously than she had previously, even though we know he has what appears to be a serious, live-in girlfriend. Much like Revenge‘s bisexual, loner tech billionaire Nolan, Ellis’s sexuality is presented less as a means of personal expression and more of a strategic tool. Ellis is one of the most irritating characters on television, a relentless climber without an iota of personal attachment, whether it’s to another human being, to ideas of merit and talent, or to the work and the subject matter itself. If Smash has been successful at anything, it’s managed to communicate the other characters’ investment in musical theater. Ellis just seems to want power because it’s there. And perhaps its best scene was a fight between Tom and Derek that turned into a sophisticated debate between how gay men and straight men see Marilyn Monroe and the theater. So it’s particularly disappointing that the show defaulted back to the old stereotype of the Evil Bisexual.

Nolan’s portrayal on Revenge has been more nuanced: he’s clearly very personally invested in helping Amanda/Emily at minimum in memory of her father (thought it would be nice if the show spent some time articulating how Nolan and David Clark got so close in the first place). He’s got an actual attachment to the cause at hand. And when he seduces Tyler, the unstable imposter who’s insinuated himself in wealthy scion Daniel Grayson’s life, Nolan appears to feel at least some sense of sympathy with the other man—there’s an actual frisson of attraction there, not merely convenience. But it’s true that Nolan doesn’t appear to have much of a life of his own, at least in the slice of time we’re seeing him. He’s not allowed genuine romantic attachment, or even business moves that don’t serve Emily/Amanda’s interests. His whole life, not just his sexuality, are at her disposal, though the show has clearly demonstrated the limited scope in which that arrangement can remain comfortable.

Smash is also in company with Mad Men in taking out some nastier emotions on its signature blondes. As much as I think that what Mad Men is doing to Betty Draper, turning her fat and even more miserable than usual, has some basis in Matt Weiner’s distate for the character, I also think it makes sense as an arc. The woman who had, as the only tool at her disposal, beauty, finds it can’t bring her happiness, and then loses her power. There’s an un-vindictive plot available in there if this means that Betty ends up forced to address some deeper issues. Only time will tell if the show avails itself of that option.

By contrast, Smash is being just nasty to Ivy, and that nastiness comes from a profoundly illogical place. Prednisone does have side effects, but the show seemed to take a real leap in turning its most professional and disciplined character into a pill-popping, drunk, show-flubbing hot mess. More to the point, turning Ivy into a joke minimizes her disappointment in a way I think is unfortunate: she’s legitimately heartbroken at the loss of her first big chance. If the show wants this to be an even fight between Karen and Ivy, which is the sense I’ve gotten from the show’s renewal and the dismissal of its showrunner, it’s got to make Karen more legitimately compelling, not undermine Ivy in a way that denies her character consistency.

Anti-Gay New York Senator Volunteers As Spokesperson For NOM’s Race-Baiting

Díaz walking arm-in-arm with NOM President Brian Brown.

It seems the National Organization for Marriage believes that if it simply redoubles its race-baiting tactics as if they are not problematic and offensive, then the controversy over its now-known intention to do so will somehow be overlooked. New York state Senator Rev. Rubén Díaz (D) has unsurprisingly volunteered to be the anti-equality group’s latest token to help “drive a wedge between gays and blacks” and “make opposition to gay marriage an identity marker” for young Latinos:

DÍAZ: Brian Brown and NOM have done something, that no one has been able to do before: they have helped Black and Hispanic people throughout the nation to find our voice when everyone else rejected us and excluded us from the debate.

You should know that NOM has not divided us, it has brought us unity; NOM has given a voice to the voiceless on the marriage issue, and shown us respect for our core, and sacred values on marriage—a respect the mainstream media has consistently denied us.

No New York Times editorial, nor anyone else will be able to sow seeds of dissension between us and NOM in this great effort to protect marriage.

The New York Times had condemned NOM for its “poisonous political approach,” an approach Díaz is all too happy to help bring to fruition. His polarizing language suggests that all people of color believe together as one block and attempts to paint NOM as an ally to their communities. But as the Southern Poverty Law Center pointed out, NOM is simply using these groups for its own insidious purposes, and surely the group hopes that Díaz’s comments will provide another opportunity to take false umbrage when his offensive views are called out.

Díaz’s anti-gay antagonism is about as harmful as a state senator’s can be. In the lead-up to the passage of marriage equality in New York last year, he held a rally that featured religious leaders who said gay people are “worthy of death.” He lied about the religious exemptions in the bill to make his case for opposing it, and his own lesbian granddaughter even rebuked his “love” for her. Following the bill’s massage, Díaz declared “Today we start the battle! Today we start the war!” For him to claim his own anti-gay hatred as representative of people of color is affront to the diversity of those communities, including the many people who experience oppression both for their sexual orientation and the color of their skin.

NOM is free to highlight as many black and Latino spokespeople as it would like, but every time it does with such obvious malicious intent, it proves how little it actually cares about any group but itself.

NEWS FLASH

Four Former DNC Chairs Support Adding Marriage Equality To Democratic Platform | “Four former chairs of the Democratic National Committee called on the party on Wednesday to embrace marriage equality in the 2012 Democratic platform,” the Huffington Post’s Amanda Terkel reports. “We are proud that the Democratic Party fights for working families, economic justice, and equal opportunity for all,” said Howard Dean, Donald Fowler, Steve Grossman and David Wilhelm in a joint statement. “Times change but our principles must always remain strong. That is why, as former chairs of the Democratic National Committee, we stand with Freedom to Marry, 22 Democratic senators, Leader Nancy Pelosi, and more than 35,000 Americans in urging the Party to include a freedom to marry plank in the platform that is ratified at the Democratic National Convention in Charlotte this September.” The Obama campaign has not said if it supports the campaign, initiated by Freedom To Marry, to add the equality language to the platform, while at least 22 senators and seven co-chairs of Obama’s re-election bid have publicly embraced the concept.

Justice

Anti-Evolution ‘Monkey Bill’ Poised To Become Law In Tennessee

Tennessee Gov. Bill Haslam (R) announced yesterday that he will “probably” sign a bill that attacks the teaching of “biological evolution, the chemical origins of life, global warming, and human cloning” by giving broad new legal immunities to teachers who question evolution and other widely accepted scientific theories. Under the bill, which passed the state legislature last month:

Neither the state board of education, nor any public elementary or secondary school governing authority, director of schools, school system administrator, or any public elementary or secondary school principal or administrator shall prohibit any teacher in a public school system of this state from helping students understand, analyze, critique, and review in an objective manner the scientific strengths and scientific weaknesses of existing scientific theories covered in the course being taught.

Although the bill is written to seem benign, as it neither specifically authorizes the teaching of creationism nor permits teachers to do more than criticize scientific theories “in an objective matter,” the practical impact of this bill will be to intimidate all but the heartiest of school administrators against disciplining teachers who preach the most outlandish junk science in their classrooms. Because the bill provides little guidance as to what constitutes an “objective” criticism of a scientific theory, any principal who reigns in teachers who force creationism or Pastafarianism upon their students risks finding themselves on the wrong side of the law.

In reality, of course, there are few, if any, “objectively” valid objections to the theory of evolution (or, for that matter, to global warming). Rather, as Travis Waldron explained when this bill passed a legislative committee nearly a year ago, “Scientists have reached a consensus that evolution is ‘one of the most robust and widely accepted principles of modern science,’ and as such, it is ‘a core element in science education.’”

NEWS FLASH

David Cameron: Marriage Equality Can Co-Exist With ‘The Values Of Christianity’ | Conservative British Prime Minister David Cameron tried to convince religious groups to back his push for civil same-sex marriage during an Easter reception yesterday. Cameron emphasized that “change [is] what happens in a register office, not what happens in a church” and stressed that houses of worship would not be required to perform unions that violate their faiths. The Prime Minister also reassured the groups that marriage equality can co-exist in the public square with religion: “I think there’s something of a fightback going on, and we should welcome that,” he added. “The values of the Bible, the values of Christianity are the values that we need.”

NEWS FLASH

Gay Muslim Scholar: Muhammad Would Support Marriage Equality | The first French man to marry his same-sex partner in an Islamic religious ceremony has written a new book called The Quran and The Flesh, which argues that the Quran does not condemn homosexuality. In the book, Ludovic-Mohamed Zahed claims that “there is nothing about homosexuality that ‘goes against nature,’ according to one interpretation of Islam. Quite the opposite.” He also suggests that the prophet Muhammad would support same-sex marriage, pointing out, “He defended men who were effeminate and who were not attracted to women. He banned any violence against them.”

Top Romney Surrogate Donald Trump Offers To Expose His ‘Very Very’ Impressive Genitals

Politico’s Mike Allen reported last month that reality star/businessman/attention seeker Donald Trump is building his political stature as a top surrogate for Mitt Romney. The controversial figure is supposedly “gaining juice and respectability in national politics,” Allen reports, has recorded robo-calls ahead of key primary battles and participated in “a ton of talk radio for Romney in Michigan, Arizona and Ohio.” The Donald even received personal “thank you” shout outs from Ann Romney during multiple campaign victory speeches.

It’a curious relationship and one that may prove dangerous for the Massachusetts governor, as he courts independent voters ahead of the general election. Trump is a shameless and at times unpredictable self-promoter whose history of misogyny will do little to help Romney’s low standing with women voters. After all, this is the same guy who described Rosie O’Donnell as a “very unattractive woman both inside and out” and a “fat slob,” allegedly required Miss USA pageant contestant to parade in front of him “so he could separate out those he found sexually appealing from those he did not,” and suggested that he would be dating his daughter and her “very nice figure” if he were not her father. Just yesterday, Trump inserted himself into the controversy surrounding a transgender contestant who had been disqualified from participating in his Miss Universe competition by offering to show his penis:

Donald Trump is confident … attorney Gloria Allred would be blown away by his man junk.

The Donald called in to TMZ Live moments ago, claiming, “I think Gloria would be very very impressed with [my penis].”

Donald’s genitals became a topic of contention earlier today during Gloria’s news conference with transgender beauty queen Jenna Talackova — when Gloria said, Jenna “didn’t ask Mr. Trump to prove he’s a naturally born man, or see photos of his birth, or to view his anatomy … It made no difference to her.”

But it makes a difference to Donald, who said he’d be willing to show what he’s got … if Gloria’s willing to pay the right price.

Donald also said he wouldn’t apologize for disqualifying Jenna last week from the Miss Universe pageant on the basis of her birth gender — even though he later reversed his position — and added, he “couldn’t care less” if Jenna even competes.

Romney courted Trump’s endorsement and even appeared alongside him to accept his support. And while one can’t ascribe Trump’s sexist comments to Romney, it’s a wonder that he feels so comfortable with Trump representing his candidacy to voters.

NEWS FLASH

Louisiana Considers Protecting Charter Schools’ Anti-Gay Discrimination | A Louisiana Senate committee advanced a bill last week (SB 217) seeking to prevent executive branch departments from implementing non-discrimination protections beyond what is mandated by law. The effect of the bill would be that charter schools could discriminate on the basis of sexual orientation, ability to speak English, or a host of other factors. Ironically — and perhaps unsurprisingly — conservatives in the state are also pushing legislation to implement school vouchers, which could take money away from local public schools to support private schools not open to all students.

NEWS FLASH

Santorum Backers Hit Romney With Anti-Gay Robo-Calls Ahead Of Wisconsin Primary | MSNBC’s Rachel Maddow reported Tuesday night that an outside group ran anti-gay robo-calls ahead of Wisconsin’s primary accusing Mitt Romney of spreading “homosexuality” and urging voters in that sate’s primary — which Romney ultimately won — to support Rick Santorum, “the only candidate who can be trusted to uphold traditional marriage, a straight military, and the rights of American children to have both a mother and a father.” Very similar call ran in Ohio, which Romney also won. Listen to the call:

(HT: JoeMyGod)

Rep. Steve King Proposes A Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell Approach To Gays In The Workplace

LE MARS, Iowa — To Rep. Steve King (R-IA), the problem is not that it’s legal for employers to fire an employee for being gay. It’s that the employee made his sexual orientation publicly known in the first place.

ThinkProgress spoke with the Iowa congressman Monday about whether it should be legal for businesses to discriminate in their hiring and firing decisions. King said that “they shouldn’t be able to do that [to] a private business” because “they need to have freedom to operate.”

We asked if this meant that he opposed the idea of forbidding businesses from firing an employee because of her sexual orientation. “How do you know someone’s sexual orientation?” he countered, before proposing an idea similar to the recently repealed “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy regarding gays in the military. “I would think that unless someone makes their sexuality public, it’s not anybody’s business, so neither is it our business to tell an employer who to hire.”

KEYES: Would that encompass, for instance, the government being able to tell businesses who they can hire and fire?

KING: Yeah, they shouldn’t be able to do that [to] a private business.

KEYES: Even if those were to be regulations say on a matter of sexual orientation or gender or other stuff like that?

KING: How do you know someone’s sexual orientation? I don’t know how you discriminate against someone because of their sexual orientation. That’s their business.

KEYES: I guess if it became public knowledge that an employee were lesbian or gay.

KING: You have private sector businesses here and they need to have freedom to operate. In the first place, I would think that unless someone makes their sexuality public, it’s not anybody’s business, so neither is it our business to tell an employer who to hire. He won’t know who to discriminate against in the first place.

Watch it:

Nobody should have to hide who they are for fear of losing their job. Gay and lesbian people, like everyone, ought to be able to be themselves and be free from employment discrimination. Unfortunately, in King’s world, it’s an either-or proposition.

  • Comment Icon

NEWS FLASH

LGBT Protections Measure Fails In Alaska | Voters in Alaska’s largest city of Anchorage appear to have rejected Proposition 5, which would have “added protections for people regardless of ‘sexual orientation or transgender identity’ to the city’s civil rights laws,” the New York Times reports. With 97.5 percent of the precincts reporting — and a “surprisingly strong turnout” that overwhelmed some polling stations — the measure failed 58 percent to 42 percent. Prior to the election, polls showed Proposition 5 winning with 50-41 support from voters, but an ugly campaign led by an Anchorage megachurch known as Anchorage Baptist Temple may have taken its toll. Opponents claimed that there’s no evidence of “widespread discrimination” in Anchorage and ran ads portraying transgender people in incredibly negative ways. One ad called trans people “transvestites” who are somehow a threat to children while another showed a cross-dressing man using a women’s locker room to the detriment of a gym owner’s business.

NEWS FLASH

Ohio Marriage Amendment Clears First Hurdle | Freedom to Marry’s campaign to repeal Ohio’s discriminatory constitutional amendment prohibiting same-sex marriage cleared a key hurdle on Tuesday, as Attorney General Mike DeWine certified the group’s new amendment summary as “fair and truthful.” The coalition is hoping to place a ballot initiative before voters in November 2013, which would strike down the state’s 2004 constitutional amendment recognizing marriages as a union between a man and a woman. The Ohio Ballot Board will now review the proposal “before the group can begin gathering the roughly 385,000 signatures needed to put the measure before voters.” DeWine had rejected an earlier draft of the group’s provision. Here is the approved language:

The Morning Pride: April 4, 2012

Welcome to The Morning Pride, ThinkProgress LGBT’s daily round-up of the latest in LGBT policy, politics, and some culture too! Here’s what we’re reading this morning, but please let us know what stories you’re following as well. Follow us all day on Twitter at @TPEquality.

- Today, the First Circuit Court of Appeals will hear two challenges of the Defense of Marriage Act out of Massachusetts, Gill v. Office of Personnel Management and Massachusetts v. United States. Meet plaintiff Dean Hara, who is suing for the pension of his late partner Rep. Gerry Studds (D-MA).

- A Senate bill to extend healthcare and retirement benefits to the same-sex domestic partners of federal employees continues to gain traction.

- The Greater Durham Chamber of Commerce and, surprisingly, many conservatives, have come out against North Carolina’s discriminatory Amendment One.

- An Ohio high school student is suing for the right to wear a “Jesus Is Not a Homophobe” t-shirt on the Day of Silence.

- A Minnesota Catholic School’s discussion about same-sex marriage — including comparisons to bestiality — did not go over well with the students.

- Local officials from across Michigan are calling for the state’s civil rights act to include LGBT protections.

- Bowie State University in Bowie, MD has become the first historically black college to open an LGBTQI and Allies Resource Center.

- How is the debate on LGBT rights impacting life on Catholic university campuses?

- Frank Schubert, the National Organization for Marriage’s go-to ad man, has left Schubert Flint Public Affairs to start his own social conservative consulting company.

- A New York lesbian chef has won $1.6 million in a lawsuit against her restaurant owner for his prayer meetings in which he prayed to cure her homosexuality.

- Linda Harvey of Mission America and Barb Anderson of the Parents Action League — both hate groups — have decried advances in Anoka-Hennepin School District as “advocating going into this [homosexual] lifestyle.”

- A Turkish mayor hopes “there won’t be any gays in our Turkey and there shouldn’t be.”

- Comedy Central takes on NOM’s race-baiting.

- An essay about Christian views on homosexuality gave a 15-year-old the courage to come out to his mother and completely change her perspective.

- In this fantastic lipdub one-take, Cypress Ranch High School in Cypress, TX makes it clear that bullying is not welcome in their hallways, but lots of fun antics are:

  • Comment Icon

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up