ThinkProgress Logo

LGBT

Media

Sunday Shows Use Easter To Promote Fictitious ‘War On Religion’

Easter morning is arguably a fair time for the Sunday morning political shows to host conversations about religion, but every single network offered only one perspective: there is a “war on religion.” CNN, ABC, NBC, CBS, and FOX limited their religious guests to Catholic and evangelical Christian leaders, all of whom parroted conservative talking points about the role of faith in society and how liberal policies somehow infringe on “religious liberty.” Absent from the discussions were any progressive people of faith, non-Christians, or non-believers.

An overarching theme of the discussions, as explicitly stated by both Rick Warren on ABC and Cardinal Timothy Dolan on CBS, was the suggestion that “a separation of church and state does not mean a separation of faith and politics.” This elides the issue and cause of the current controversy, which is that they and the other guests are advocating for policy positions based on sectarian religious viewpoints which are not held by many members of the same faiths, members of other faiths, or individuals of no faith at all. The issue is also the impact these policies would have on women’s ability to access contraception, and on the civil rights of LGBT Americans. For example, individuals like Warren, Dolan, Baltimore Archbishop William Lori, Anne Graham Lotz, and Newt Gingrich all strongly oppose offering same-sex couples the freedom to marry, but none offer consideration for the many churches that do support marriage equality.

Watch a compilation of yesterday’s one-sided discussions on State of the Union, This Week, Meet The Press, Face The Nation, and Fox News Sunday:

Religion is not under attack in the United States. In fact, it enjoys as much influence in schools, government, and the media as it ever has. To limit the discussion of its influence to the narrow self-serving objections of one handful of loudmouth conservatives is poor journalism and a disservice to the broad diversity of worldviews that truly defines the American experience.

Maine Equality Opponents Distribute ‘Sodomy Based Marriage’ Truth Pledge

(Click on the image to read the pledge in its entirety.)

This November, Maine residents will have the first-ever opportunity to vote for marriage equality at the ballot, and though polling is strong and steady for the measure, opponents are just beginning to ramp up their own efforts. Anti-gay conservatives Paul Madore and Mike Heath — activists whose heated rhetoric has been squelched in past campaigns — have launched the “No Special Rights PAC” to oppose the referendum. Today, they took their first action, interrupting the beginning of Pride Week at the University of Maine to distribute a “truth pledge,” which refers to the ballot initiative as promoting “Sodomy Based Marriage.” Individuals who take the pledge are encouraged to refer to the freedom to marry as a “special right,” a “hellish” and “evil” doctrine, and an “attack by demonic forces.” Here are some excerpts:

I pledge that I will:

1. Go to the polls and vote NO on Sodomy Based Marriage in November.

3. Use the term “Sodomy Based Marriage” and avoid the deceptive terms “same sex or gay  marriage.”

4. Inform my friends and neighbors that the term “same sex marriage” contains two contradictory terms, and is therefore, illogical, false, and absurd.

5. Marriage is a Covenant that is entered into between two people and is based on a  difference in gender; and there can be no moral or legal right to a practice which defies logic, common sense, and the Natural Law itself.

9. Reaffirm the Christian Church’s teaching that a child must never be denied the right to have both a mother and a father. Oppose the hellish doctrine that parents of the same sex make better parents than parents of the opposite sex, an evil doctrine which is now being advanced by the homosexual rights movement.

11. Pray that God will deliver our State and Country from this attack by demonic force, and that marriage between man and woman will be restored to its rightful place of honor, to the glory of Almighty God.

The pledge also refers to marriage equality as “an attack on the religious freedom of all Christian men and women” that oppresses, silences, and persecutes “those who hold religious or moral objections to homosexuality” and seeks to introduce “homosexual indoctrination into the curricula of our schools.” Madore also told reporters that homosexuality represents a “culture of death.”

Madore and Heath’s rhetoric is unabashedly anti-gay, but it’s important to note that all of the rhetoric fits the models offered by groups that use tamer language, like the National Organization for Marriage and Catholic Church. By framing the effort around so-called “religious freedom” and protecting children, No Special Rights PAC is fighting with fear and trying to erase same-sex families and the many faith communities that support them.

Alyssa

Why Thomas Kinkaide Matters For Everyone Who Cares About Pop Culture

When I read over the weekend that Thomas Kinkaide had died at the age of 54, I immediately thought of Susan Orlean’s 2001 profile of the painter, who rejected critical opinion of his work as schmaltzy and sold his work as part of the extremely lucrative collectibles market. Orlean points out of Kinkaide’s life story, in which he grew up poor and fatherless, left a Christian school for a secular art school before having a powerful conversion experience that lead him to dedicate himself to optimism in art, “It’s as good a story as you could hope for,” she wrote, “if you want to make a point about perseverance and pulling yourself up by your bootstraps and appreciating life’s bounty; even the bad parts of the story are good, because it’s easier not to begrudge Kinkade his fortune when you are reminded that he was a poor kid who had to struggle, who rejected the smarty-pants liberal establishment to follow his heart, and who is proud of having earned his way into the ultimate American aristocracy of successful entrepreneurs.”

Lots of folks have jumped on the subsequent pieces about Kinkaide that suggested the real story was less than flattering, involving everything from sexual harassment, to defraudment of the franchisees who ran Kinkaide’s galleries, to public urination. While I think it’s fine to debunk the narrative, it’s also worth getting at precisely why that narrative, and Kinkaide’s paintings, were so compelling to so many people, especially if you get frustrated with what seems like the perpetual American default to simplistic popular culture when more complex and interesting alternatives are available. Orlean wrote:

“I created a system of marketing compatible with American art,” Kinkade said to me recently. “I believe in ‘aspire to’ art. I want my work to be available but not common. I want it to be a dignified component of everyday life. It’s good to dream about things. It’s like dreaming of owning a Rolex ~n instead, you dream about owning a seventy-five-thousand-dollar print.” In fact, a lot of limited- edition art is about dreaming; so many of the paintings portray wistful images of a noble and romantic past that never was, or the anti-intellectual innocence of fairies and animals, or mythical heroes who can never fail and never fade…

“I have this certain ability to have in my mind an image that means something to real people,” he said, sitting on a sofa across the room from the easels. “The No. 1 quote critics give me is ‘Thom, your work is irrelevant.’ Now, that’s a fascinating, fascinating comment. Yes, irrelevant to the little subculture, this microculture, of modern art. But here’s the point: My art is relevant because it’s relevant to ten million people. That makes me the most relevant artist in this culture, not the least. Because I’m relevant to real people.” He sat up and started to laugh. “I remember that quote, man! It was a great quote! It was ‘The Louvre is full of dead pictures by dead artists.’ And you know, that’s the dead art we don’t want anything to do with!” He laughed again and slapped his thighs. “We’re the art of life, man! We’re bringing the life back to art!”

Nostalgia is a powerful thing, whether it’s an old-fashioned fantasy of a multi-ethnic army coming to rescue us from the newfangled threat of giant robots, or the promise of escape to a non-existent bucolic paradise. When it comes to pop culture, the comfortable are deeply averse to being disturbed. It’s the rare pop culture engine that can get huge numbers of people voluntarily invested in something that will be profoundly disruptive. That’s not a reason to think less of people who like Thomas Kinkaide, or Two and a Half Men—just to think harder about how we can build those engines, and to recognize the magnitude of the challenge.

Huckabee Urges GOP Nominee To Attack Obama For Abandoning Defense Of Marriage Act

Mike Huckabee urged the GOP presidential nominee to challenge President Obama over the alleged inconsistency of defending the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act while failing to uphold the 1996 Defense of Marriage Act, which defines marriage as a union between one man and one woman. “Regardless of your views on marriage, what this reveals is a very interesting approach that President Obama seems to take to court decisions,” the former Arkansas governor and Republican presidential contender said during the inaugural broadcast of The Mike Huckabee Show:

HUCKABEE: If they agree with his particular legislative package, he thinks the court should be obeyed explicitly. But when they disagree with him, he thinks they ought to be ignored. So I think that’s one of the real questions that hopefully whoever the Republican nominee is…that we’re going to find a very important part of the process of this presidential campaign.

Listen:

Lost in Huckabee’s parallel however, is the fact that DOMA is unconstitutional because it violates the Constitution’s equal protection clause by denying benefits to gay and lesbian couples, while the Affordable Care Act regulates the kind of economic commerce that is encompassed by the Constitution’s commerce clause. Huckabee is more than happy to draw similarities that reflect poorly on Obama, but one wonders if he would argue that a Republican president should defend the constitutionality of health reform if he also stands by DOMA.

NEWS FLASH

White House Has No Response For Gay Couple Seeking Employment Protections | White House Press Secretary Jay Carney refused to comment on whether President Obama would issue an executive order prohibiting federal contractors from discriminating in the workplace based on sexual orientation or gender identity, continuing the administration’s policy of silence on the matter. “I don’t have any updates for you on possible or proposed executive orders,” Carney said in response to a question about a same-sex couple who attended that morning’s Easter Egg Role at the White House to pressure President Obama to act. The Labor and Justice Departments have reportedly approved the order.

Obama Campaign Opposes Minnesota’s Marriage Discrimination Amendment

President Obama’s campaign in Minnesota has issued a statement opposing the state’s proposed constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage:

“While the President does not weigh in on every single ballot measure in every state, the record is clear that the President has long opposed divisive and discriminatory efforts to deny rights and benefits to same sex couples,” said Kristen Sosanie, spokeswoman for the Obama for America – Minnesota campaign. “That’s what the Minnesota ballot initiative would do – it would single out and discriminate against committed gay and lesbian couples – and that’s why the President does not support it.”

The Obama campaign offered the same statement in opposition to North Carolina’s Amendment One, and the Catholic bishops responded that his position was “a grave disappointment.” Though the President’s position on same-sex marriage is still “evolving,” he opposes state-level attempts to discriminate against same-sex couples.

NEWS FLASH

Liberian Government Says It Will Defend Gays | The Liberian government issued a statement last week promising to prosecute members of an anti-LGBT group who threatened activists with death. In the statement, the government said it “supports the rights of any of its citizens to hold dear their traditional values, [but] it will neither countenance nor condone any form of intolerance whose objective is to stifle the exercise of individual freedoms and the advance of civil liberties.” The statement also said that security agencies would investigate the threats and arrest anyone threatening gay rights advocates. The group, the Movement Against Gays In Liberia, issued a “hit list” of LGBT rights supporters last week, promising “to go after them using all means in life.”

-Zachary Bernstein

NEWS FLASH

Washington Equality Opponents Slow To Gather Repeal Signatures | After nearly a month of outreach, opponents of Washington state’s new marriage equality law have only gathered 5,681 of the 120,577 signatures necessary (and 150,000 goal) to repeal the law at the ballot through Referendum 74. They have only two months left to collect the rest, as the law is set to take effect on June 6. The Seattle Times notes that Preserve Marriage Washington, a campaign funded by the race-baiting National Organization for Marriage, has not yet utilized paid signature collectors and the totals do not seem to reflect the outreach to 1,500 churches with 50,000 completed petitions the group has boasted.

Gay Couple Makes Case For Nondiscrimination Order At White House Egg Roll

Jarrod Scarbrough and Les Sewell — the gay couple urging President Obama to sign an LGBT-inclusive executive order at this morning’s Egg Roll at the White House — told MSNBC’s Thomas Roberts this morning that the measure could shield their family from anti-gay discrimination. The decree, which would prohibit federal contractors from discriminating in the workplace based on sexual orientation or gender identity, has been rubber stamped by the Labor and Justice Departments and is now awaiting approval from the White House.

“Jarrod works for a company that the government contracts through, and we live in New Mexico — we’re actually protected, we don’t have to worry too much about being discriminated against. However, in June we’re moving to Florida where that protection, we’ll no longer have that,” Sewell said. “Without this administrative action, Jarrod could lose his job and then where would this family be?” Watch it:

Last week, a group of 72 lawmakers led by Rep. Frank Pallone (D-NJ) called on Obama to sign the measure. “This order would extend important workplace protections to millions of Americans, while at the same time laying the groundwork for Congressional passage of the Employment Non-Discrimination Act (ENDA), a goal that we share with you,” the lawmakers wrote, noting that the initiative would also build on President Johnson’s Executive order “prohibiting federal contractors from discriminating against employees based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin.”

As a candidate in 2008, Obama committed to supporting a “formal written policy of non-discrimination that includes sexual orientation and gender identity or expression … for all Federal contractors.” Meanwhile, over 100,000 have signed a Freedom To Work Change.org petition urging the President to take action.

NEWS FLASH

Missouri Legislator Posts Photo Comparing Same-Sex Marriage To ‘Legalized Perversion’ | Donna Lichtenegger, a Missouri Legislator, has posted a translation guide that characterizes same-sex marriage as “legalized perversion” and a “multicultural community” as a “high-crime area” on her Facebook profile. Fired Up! Missouri notes that Lichtenegger shared the photo with two other representatives and and House Majority Leader. Look:

NEWS FLASH

1 Gay Person Is Killed Every 24 Hours In Brazil | The overall crime rate is falling sharply in Brazil, but “murders of gays and lesbians are on the rise,” the Daily Beast’s Kristian Jebsen reports. “Attacks against gays have climbed steadily for most of the last decade, with 272 murdered in 2011—one every 36 hours, according to Grupo Gay da Bahía, a leading gay-rights group that tracks antigay violence. This year, GGB reports, it’s even worse, with 75 murders in just the first 10 weeks. That’s one every 24 hours.” The increasing violence may be the result of the growing visibility of the LGBT rights movement and legislators have offered legislation on the national and local levels to stem the bloodshed. Brazil is considered one of the most LGBT-friendly countries in South America, offering marriage equality, open military service, and gender-reassignment surgery “as part of the country’s national health service.”

Rick Warren: Same-Sex Marriage Is Wrong Because God Said So

Past Rick Warren reiterated his opposition to same-sex marriage during an appearance on ABC’s This Week on Sunday, insisting that God and the Bible “is very clear that sex is for a man and a woman in marriage only”:

TAPPER: Do you think there will come a time when Saddleback Church needs to adjust its position on same-sex marriage in the same way the churches have throughout the years adjusted their position, for instance, on divorce.

R. WARREN: Well, if the Bible is the word of God, then I don’t have the right to change it. Policies come and go over the years. And so if I’m unpopular for certain beliefs, well, then I’m unpopular for certain beliefs. And to me, the Bible is very clear that sex is for a man and a woman in marriage only. [...]

TAPPER: I’m wondering if you think the church, in order to continue to thrive, might have to adjust its policy on same-sex marriage?

R. WARREN: Actually, history shows that when the church accommodates culture, it weakens it. This is why there is a very weak church in Europe today. It’s almost non-existent in many areas.

Watch it:

Warren’s anti-gay views became a topic of national conversation after President Obama chose him to deliver the invocation at his inauguration. His beliefs run deep. In 2005, Warren told Fortune magazine that “he would counsel gays and lesbians to adopt a heterosexual lifestyle” and later explained that gay people are immature. “We all have biological predispositions,” Warren explained during an interview with TODAY in December of 2008. “You say because I have natural impulses to the same sex, I shouldn’t have to reign them in. Well I disagree. I think that’s part of maturity, I think that’s part of delayed gratification, I think that’s part of character.” In 2008, the website for Warren’s Saddleback Church also explicitly said that “someone unwilling to repent for their homosexual lifestyle would not be accepted as a member at Saddleback.” The language has since been changed.

The pastor had initially refusing to condemn condemn Uganda’s Anti-Homosexuality Bill — which would make certain homosexual acts punishable by death — insisting that it wasn’t his “personal calling” to “comment or interfere in the political process of other nations.” When he finally did issue a statement distancing himself from the measure, Warren reiterated his belief that being gay is a sin.

  • Comment Icon

NEWS FLASH

Study: Homophobes May Have ‘Unacknowledged Attraction To The Same-Sex’ | “Homophobia is more pronounced in individuals with an unacknowledged attraction to the same sex and who grew up with authoritarian parents who forbade such desires,” a series of physiological studies conducted by scientists at the University of Rochester, the University of Essex, England, and the University of California in Santa Barbara conclude. “Individuals who identify as straight but in psychological tests show a strong attraction to the same sex may be threatened by gays and lesbians because homosexuals remind them of similar tendencies within themselves,” explains Netta Weinstein, the study’s lead author. “In many cases these are people who are at war with themselves and they are turning this internal conflict outward,” says co-author Richard Ryan.

NEWS FLASH

Donald Trump Jokes About Transgender Beauty Contestant’s Genitals | Barbara Walters sat down with transgender Miss Universe contestent Jenna Talackova on Friday to discuss her transition and the controversy surrounding her participation in Donald Trump’s competition. After initially facing rejected for being trans, Talackova will be allowed to compete in the pageant this coming May and says, “I feel like the universe, the creator put me in this position as an advocate. If it’s helping anyone else, and my story, then I feel great about it.” Walters also interviewed prominent Romney endorser Trump, who, building off his previous comments about the size of his genitalia, joked that Talackova’s name spells “JENNATAL.” The comment prompted Talackova’s lawyer Gloria Allred to observe, “With all due respect to Mr. Trump, he really needs to stop being focused on genitals. His, or anyone else’s. This world does not revolve around his penis or anyone else’s genitalia. Whether a person is a woman is not simply defined by her genitalia.” Watch it:

The entire program is available here.

The Morning Pride: April 9, 2012

Welcome to The Morning Pride, ThinkProgress LGBT’s daily round-up of the latest in LGBT policy, politics, and some culture too! Here’s what we’re reading this morning, but please let us know what stories you’re following as well. Follow us all day on Twitter at @TPEquality.

- At today’s Easter Egg Roll, a gay couple from New Mexico will urge President Obama to sign an executive order protecting federally contracted LGBT employees from discrimination.

- A Library of Congress staffer has filed a complaint that he was made to work in a hostile work environment and ultimately fired for being gay.

- Sen. John Kerry (D-MA) is working to help protect a same-sex binational couple from being separated by deportation.

- Ian James of Freedom to Marry Ohio will not address whether he expects his consulting firms to profit from the marriage equality ballot initiative he is advancing.

- The ACLU has demanded that there be a thorough investigation of voter fraud in Anchorage, where an LGBT non-discrimination ordinance apparently failed last week.

- The University of Idaho is considering offering domestic partner benefits.

- The National Organization for Marriage continues to avoid taking ownership of “fanning hostility” between racial groups.

- Equality Matters profiles Todd Starnes, the new prominent anti-gay voice on Fox News.

- Police in St. Petersburg, Russia made several arrests during Saturday’s “Day of Silence” protest of the state’s new anti-gay “propaganda” laws.

- Check out this compelling new ad from Chile urging same-sex couples to identify themselves in the census.

- The Servicemembers Legal Defense Network considers what more can be done to support LGBT veterans.-

  • Comment Icon

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up