ThinkProgress Logo

LGBT

Politics

Rubio Breaks With Romney On Marriage Equality, Says It Should Be Left To The States

Florida Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL) — who is rumored to be on Mitt Romney’s vice presidential short list — told Fox News’ Neil Cavuto Thursday afternoon that he disagrees with the former Massachusetts governor’s support for a federal constitutional amendment defining marriage as union between one man and one woman. “Ultimately marriage is regulated by states, so, that is where it remains and where it should remain and that is what most people believe,” Rubio said in response to a question about the amendment and reiterated his personal opposition to the freedom to marry.

Watch it:

The Florida senator was far more circumspect while challenging Charlie Crist for the seat in 2010, however, telling reporters that he had “mixed feelings” about the Federal Marriage Amendment.

Pan American Health Organization Condemns Ex-Gay Therapy

Today, the Pan American Health Organization, the Regional Office for the Americas of the World Health Organization, condemned ex-gay therapy in a new position statement, calling it a “serious threat to the health and well-being — even the lives — of affected people.” Not only does the PAHO statement identify the therapies as ineffective and a threat to personal autonomy and personal integrity, but concludes that those who offer such therapies are reinforcing stigma and should be penalized:

Health professionals who offer “reparative therapies” align themselves with social prejudices and reflect a stark ignorance in matters of sexuality and sexual health. Contrary to what many people believe or assume, there is no reason — with the exception of the stigma resulting from those very prejudices — why homosexual persons should be unable to enjoy a full and satisfying life.

The task of health professionals is to not cause harm and to offer support to patients to alleviate their complaints and problems, not to make these more severe. A therapist who classifies non-heterosexual patients as “deviant” not only offends them but also contributes to the aggravation of their problems.

“Reparative” or “conversion therapies” have no medical indication and represent a severe threat to the health and human rights of the affected persons. They constitute unjustifiable practices that should be denounced and subject to adequate sanctions and penalties.

PAHO also offers numerous recommendations to limit the impact of ex-gay therapy:

  • Governments should ban ex-gay therapy for its violation of human rights and sanction clinics that offer it.
  • Schools should train health professionals about sexuality and sexual diversity to combat stigma.
  • Professional associations should reject ex-gay therapy and continue to educate members about it.
  • The media should expose homophobia as “a threat to human dignity and human rights” and reject any positive publicity for ex-gay therapy.

This condemnation for ex-gay therapy is appropriately bold and unwavering. Ex-gay therapy is a stain on society that serves no purpose but to encourage internalized stigma and perpetuate falsehoods about the nature of sexual orientation. PAHO should be applauded for its defense of LGBT health and human rights.

NEWS FLASH

Two NC Couples Denied Marriage Licenses As Part Of ‘We Do’ Campaign | Two more lesbian couples were denied marriage licenses in North Carolina on Tuesday. The requests came as part of the week-long “We Do” campaign, organized by the Campaign for Southern Equality. The first couple to request a marriage license, Alice Phelan and Sally Young, have been together for 29 years. The other women, Laurel and Amy Rose, were legally married in Washington, DC in 2010 and wanted their marriage to be recognized in North Carolina. Both couples knew their requests would be rejected, since North Carolina previously had a law banning same-sex marriage. That ban was recently written into the state constitution with the passage of Amendment One. Despite this, LGBT rights supporters say they will continue fighting for equal rights in the state:

-Zachary Bernstein

Anti-Homophobia Protests Blocked By Activists, Authorities

Today marks the International Day Against Homophobia and Transphobia (IDAHO), a worldwide day of activism against anti-LGBT prejudice. Last year, activists in over 80 nations got involved, according to the Arcus Foundation. This year, prayer vigils and parties are planned all over the world, with Burma marking a milestone by holding its first ever gay pride celebrations.

Unfortunately, but perhaps not surprisingly, not all of the response has been positive. Despite the global show of support, anti-LGBT activists and government officials have tried to stymie some of these events. Here are a few examples:

-A gay pride march in Georgia was attacked by several Christian activists, including some Orthodox priests. About 20 people marched through the streets of Tbilisi, but were blocked by an “improvised cordon” of activists who threw punches and smashed signs. Police arrested at least three people.

-LGBT activists in Malaysia announced they would not be holding a march, citing security reasons. One organizer of the march claimed “a rising wave of threats made against the LGBT community by the government and certain religious organizations” since the government banned a sexual minorities festival, Seksualiti Merdeka, last year.

-Police in Fiji canceled a gay pride parade despite granting a permit the month before. According to one rights activist in Fiji, police “said we cannot march today because they did not realise they had given a permit for gays to march.” Homosexuality in Fiji was decriminalized in 2010, but homophobia is still prevalent, according to activists.

-Government officials in Belarus rejected requests to hold three separate demonstrations in the capital Minsk. The officials cited “technical” issues and repair work being done near the sites, according to the owner of an online portal, who also said he found the explanations “far-fetched.”

Responses like these show just how important an event like IDAHO is. Despite the remarkable progress that has been made on LGBT rights over the past several years, strong homophobia still exists across the world, whether it is religious activists attacking peaceful protestors in Georgia or a government minister in Zimbabwe urging tribal chiefs to “banish” people who support marriage equality. A lot has been gained, but a lot more is left to do.

-Zachary Bernstein

Senate Takes Significant Step With Domestic Partnership Benefits Bill

Our guest blogger is Ben Harris, intern for LGBT Progress.

Yesterday, the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee passed legislation that extends health insurance and other benefits to the same-sex partners of federal employees.  Senators Joe Lieberman (I-CT) and Susan Collins (R-ME) introduced the bill, called the Domestic Partnership Benefits and Obligation Act, which if passed into law would extend health insurance and a number of other workplace benefits to federal employees and their same-sex partners.

Because of discriminatory laws like the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA), gay federal employees do not have full access to benefits currently afforded to straight federal employees and their spouses. Without access to health insurance through their partners, many gay individuals must either purchase costly insurance plans in the private market or forgo health insurance, a considerable financial risk should be they become seriously ill. Yesterday, the Senate committee advanced a bill that would significantly alleviate that risk and bolster economic security for gay couples in the federal workforce.

Passing this bill out of committee is long overdue. Not only does this mean equal treatment for gay employees in the federal workforce, it also ensures that we attract the best and brightest workers into public service. When it was introduced back in November, Senator Collins remarked :

COLLINS: This change is both fair policy and good business practice. The federal government must compete with the private sector when it comes to attracting the most qualified, skilled, and dedicated employees. Today, health, medical, and other benefits are a major component of any competitive employment package. Indeed, private sector employers are increasingly offering these kinds of benefits as standard fare.

She’s right. Eighty-six percent of Fortune 100 companies offer equal health care benefits to employees with same-sex partners, according to the Human Rights Campaign. And research shows that when you treat gay workers equally on the job, what results is a happier, healthier, and more productive workforce.

Some, like Governor Rick Snyder (R) of Michigan, who recently vetoed a bill to extend domestic partner benefits to state employees, oppose equality in the workplace because they say it costs too much. They’re wrong . The take-up rate for domestic partner benefits is extremely low and it is likely that the boon from attracting a more talented and productive workforce outweighs any costs of providing equal benefits to gay couples.

What’s more, passing laws that extend workplace benefits to gay employees is politically popular. A whopping 8 in 10 Americans believe gay employees should be given equal benefits on the job. Even Mitt Romney agrees. Just last week, after restating his opposition to marriage equality, he voiced his support : “My view is that domestic partnership benefits, hospital visitation rights and the like are appropriate.”

Conservatives and corporations should take a cue from the American people: workplace equality is critical to fostering a more efficient and effective government.

The Obama Effect: Growing Number Of African Americans Come Out For Marriage Equality

While African Americans are generally less supportive of marriage equality as a whole, a growing number of black leaders and community members have come to embrace the issue since President Obama endorsed the freedom to marry last week.

As Rep. John Lewis (D-GA) explained during an appearance on MSNBC Thursday afternoon, “Dr. [Martin Luther] King took a simple position. When people would ask him about interracial marriage, he would simply say races don’t fall in love and get married, individuals fall in love and get married.” “So if two men or two women want to fall in love and get married it’s their business,” he added:

LEWIS: My position is very, very simple. That I fought too long and too hard against discrimination based on race and color, not to stand up and fight against discrimination based on sexual orientation. If you’re going to provide civil rights and equality for everybody, you cannot draw a line, you cannot build a wall. We must respect the dignity and the worth of every human being whether they are gay or straight.

Watch it:

African Americans are agreeing with Lewis in greater numbers:

– 54 percent of African Americans support Obama’s position on same-sex marriage: A recent ABC News/Washington Post poll found that since Obama declared his support, “54 percent express a favorable view of his position on the issue,” compared to “just 41 percent of African-Americans supported gay marriage in ABC/Post polls in mid-2011 and early 2012.”

– 11 point shift in support for marriage among African Americans in NC: A Public Policy Polling survey found “a noticeable shift in the attitudes of African Americans in North Carolina toward rights for gay couples in the wake of President Obama’s announcement last week that he supports gay marriage. Our final poll before the primary last week found only 20% of black voters in the state favoring gay marriage, with 63% opposed. Now 27% express support for gay marriage with 59% opposed, for an overall 11 point shift on the margin.”

– Rep. James Clyburn (D-SC) comes out for marriage equality: The highest ranking African American in Congress told MSNBC earlier this week, “I, like the president, have evolved to a point of marriage equality. I have not always been there. I grew up in a parsonage, a fundamentalist Christian parsonage, and I grew up with that indoctrination. And I have grown to the point that I believe that we have evolved to marriage equality.” “If we consider this to be a civil right — and I do — I don’t think civil rights ought to be left up to a state-by-state approach,” Clyburn said. “I think that we should have a national policy on this.”

– African Americans say Obama’s support did not change their opinion of him: A Pew Research Center survey concluded that “most African Americans, on the other hand, say the announcement did not alter their opinion of Obama.”

More black than white people oppose marriage equality, but since 2008, “the proportion of African Americans favoring gay marriage has increased from 26% to 39%, while opposition has fallen from 63% to 49%.”

NEWS FLASH

Oklahoma Senate Committee Refused To Confirm Gay Appointee | Virginia is not the only state where Republican legislators refuse job confirmations to appointees just because they’re gay. The Oklahoma Senate Rules Committee refused to give a hearing to Jim Roth, an openly gay Oklahoma City attorney nominated to the Election Board. Sen. Al McAffrey (D), who is also gay, explained, “Senators do not want during election time to vote on a gay person. That is what it comes down to.”

NEWS FLASH

Today Marks 8 Years Of Massachusetts Marriage Equality | On May 17, 2004, the first legal same-sex marriages in the United States began taking place in Massachusetts. In the eight years since then, 18,462 same-sex couples have wed in the state, according to MassEquality. As of 2009, 28 percent of Massachusetts married same-sex couples were raising children, and 93 percent of them reported that their children were happier and better off as a result of their marriage.

George Allen Disagrees With Virginia Republicans: Sexual Orientation Should Not Be A Criteria For Judges

Former Senator George Allen (R), who is now running to reclaim his seat, said he disagreed with a recent decision by the state’s House of Delegates to reject the confirmation of a judicial nominee because he is gay. The House rejected the appointment of Tracy Thorne-Begland, one of the state’s top prosecutors, because “his lifestyle is exactly contrary” the the state’s anti-marriage equality law, Delegate Bob Marshall (R) said.

But Allen said he does not think sexual orientation should be a consideration for judges. “What I’d look at as far as judges is, I’d look at their qualifications. As far as judges are concerned, sexual orientation is not one of their criteria for being a judge,” Allen said during a campaign stop in Prince William County, according to Inside Nova.

Allen is hardly an LGBT-friendly lawmaker. He’s said that gay rights are not civil rights, co-sponsored a constitutional amendment to ban marriage equality, and often used to raise the specter of same-sex marriage in stump speeches.

Justice

Anti-Gay Virginia Lawmaker Explains His Decision To Block Gay Judge: ‘Sodomy Is Not A Civil Right’

Gay judicial candidate Tracy Thorne-Begland during his military service

Earlier this week, the Virginia House of Delegates rejected Tracy Thorne-Begland, a former Navy pilot and top Virginia prosecutor, for a seat on Virginia’s lowest ranking trial court because, in the words of Del. Bob Marshall (R-VA), Thorne-Begland’s gay “lifestyle is exactly contrary to” his obligation to uphold the state constitution. On CNN this morning, Marshall doubled-down on this view, explaining that he blocked Thorne-Begland because the judicial candidate had the audacity to serve his country while gay:

MARSHALL: [Thorne-Begland] had to misstate his background in order to be received into the military in the late 1980s. There was a specific question, “are you a homosexual?” He had to say no. He took an oath of office which he had to defy. . . . Dr. Martin Luther King and Rosa Parks never took an oath of office that they broke. Sodomy is not a civil right. It’s not the same as the Civil Rights Movement. You have to look at the past, and, in fact, look, in late 2011 he was critical of the, you know, Don’t Ask/Don’t Tell. He criticized our attorney general simply for explaining what the law of Virginia is with respect to certain protected classes.

Watch it:

First of all, “sodomy,” as Marshall so quaintly puts it, is a civil right. That was the holding of Lawrence v. Texas, which established that consenting adults have a right to be free from government interference in their “private sexual conduct.”

Additionally, while it may in fact be true that Thorne-Begland once misrepresented his sexuality in order to serve his country in the United States Navy, it is important to understand exactly what he signed up for when he told this potential lie. Tracy Thorne-Begland was a Navy pilot, and his superiors did nothing to hide from him the dangers inherent in this job. When Thorne-Begland was stationed at Virginia Beach, he was informed that 25 percent of pilots are killed in action over the course of a 20 year career. This was the job he might have lied in order to sign up for — to risk his life every day in defense of his county. Bob Marshall, by contrast, never served a day in the United States military.

Nor, apparently, did Marshall familiarize himself with civil rights history during all that time he spent not serving his country. Martin Luther King may not have taken an oath of office, but his entire career was rooted in a campaign to peacefully defy unconstitutional laws. And while there is some dispute over whether Rosa Parks’ famous decision to keep her seat on a Montgomery bus violated a city ordinance or merely a racist custom, her refusal to stand is widely perceived as an act of civil disobedience that triggered a movement of opposition to Jim Crow laws. A judge’s oath is to the Constitution, and Thorne-Begland acted with the greatest respect for our founding document when he fought back against the unconstitutional and now-repealed Don’t Ask/Don’t Tell policy.

NEWS FLASH

POLL: Marriage Equality Support Remains Strong In New Jersey | A new Quinnipieac poll finds that 53 percent of New Jersey voters would support a marriage equality law with 52 percent opposed. Though support dipped when respondents were giving the additional choice of civil unions — which New Jersey already has — 48 percent still supported marriage equality compared to a combined 47 percent who support civil unions or nothing. A strong majority of 67 percent still welcomes the opportunity to vote on same-sex marriage at the ballot, but support for Gov. Chris Christie’s (R) veto of marriage equality legislation declined from 48 percent to 44 percent since March. Reactions to President Obama’s support for marriage equality were split, with Republicans and older voters becoming less likely to vote for him and Democrats and younger voters becoming more likely to vote for him.

Fox News Joins The Marriage Poll Distortion Band Wagon

A slew of polls have surveyed voters’ beliefs about marriage equality since President Obama’s endorsement last week, but the data collection is quickly becoming lazy and the interpretation sloppy. Monday’s CBS/New York Times poll has been roundly criticized for its incredibly small sample size (615) and the odd framing of its questions. Fox News unsurprisingly conducted a poll of its own in the same fashion and eagerly spun the results to accommodate its anti-equality agenda:

A majority of voters don’t support allowing gays and lesbians to marry legally, yet at the same time a majority also opposes a constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage.

According to a Fox News poll released Wednesday, 37 percent of voters believe gays and lesbians should be allowed to get married legally. While that’s unchanged from 2010, when the question was most recently asked, it’s nearly double the 20 percent who felt that way in March 2004, the first time it was asked.

There is actually nothing in the data that supports this conclusion. What the Fox News article doesn’t mention until its fourth paragraph is that it asked its question the same way the CBS/NYT poll did: forcing a choice between same-sex marriage, legal unions not called marriage, or no legal recognition. The true result of this poll is that 70 percent believe there should be legal recognition for same-sex couples, which was actually 8 points higher than what Monday’s CBS/NYT poll found.

But the problem with both polls is that they never force respondents to choose between same-sex marriage and nothing, creating an incomplete picture of where voters stand. Consider the recent polling from Colorado, which found that 62 percent support civil unions, but that 53 support full marriage equality as well. Forcing respondents to make an either/or choice about marriage and civil unions instead of allowing consideration for both separately creates a distorted view of where voters actually stand.

The Times’ Ross Douthat attempts to spin the interpretation the other way, suggesting that because so many “prefer” civil unions, their support for  marriage equality when not provided with an alternative is “reluctant.” And it’s because of that reluctance, he believes, that the results of ballot measures don’t match the polling. This, of course, is a conclusion that can only be drawn from the strange construction of the question in these polls, and it also ignores the reality that many complex factors impact these plebiscites. In North Carolina, the most current example, polling showed that voters were largely uninformed (or misinformed) about the actual impact of Amendment One, and thus did not realize they were voting to ban civil unions and domestic partnerships in addition to marriage — against their wishes. Plus, as Nathaniel Frank points out, polls on social issues are simply “notoriously bad at predicting [voter] behavior.”

Fox News wants to be able to claim it has data opposing the conclusion that a majority of Americans support the freedom to marry, despite consistent national polling over the past two years that shows otherwise. Any poll can be structured and framed to deliver a certain bias to the results, but the true momentum for marriage equality cannot be disregarded so easily.

  • Comment Icon

NEWS FLASH

Michigan Prisoner’s Sexual Orientation Discrimination Claim Advances | Ricky Davis, a gay prisoner at the Florence Crane Correctional Facility in Coldwater, Michigan, has received a favorable decision allowing his suit of anti-gay discrimination to proceed. The ACLU is defending Davis, who claims he was improperly removed from his employment in the prison public works program because of his sexual orientation. He also claims that his crew supervisors “made a spectacle” of him after he had a diabetic episode while on duty, avoiding interacting with him because he is gay. At this point, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals has merely saved Davis’ suit from being dismissed, but the decision guarantees that his case — and others like it — will get a fair hearing.

The Morning Pride: May 17, 2012

Welcome to The Morning Pride, ThinkProgress LGBT’s daily round-up of the latest in LGBT policy, politics, and some culture too! Here’s what we’re reading this morning, but please let us know what stories you’re following as well. Follow us all day on Twitter at @TPEquality.

- Today is the International Day Against Homophobia & Transphobia, a call to consciousness worldwide. Prayer vigils and parties will be taking place around the globe.

- Meet nine-year-old Josef Miles, who took it upon himself to counter-protest the Westboro Baptist Church with a sign that said, “God Hates No One.”

- Opponents of marriage equality in Maine have published a “Gay Marriage House Of Horrors,” but it’s unclear what message it’s really trying to convey.

- Kansas middle school teacher Jack Conkling wrote on Facebook that same-sex marriage “ranks in God’s eyes the same as murder, lying, stealing, or cheating.”

- The National Organization for Marriage is challenging Florida electioneering law law so it can secretly campaign for candidates.

- A Las Vegas trans student will be allowed to walk with the other men in his class after KLAS-TV reported on the school’s intention to ignore his identity.

- Chrissy Polis is still scarred from the savage anti-trans attack she experienced in a Baltimore McDonald’s last year.

- Jenna Talackova is officially the first-ever transgender candidate to compete at the Miss Universe Canada pageant.

- The Knesset has voted down a bill that would have allowed same-sex and interfaith couples to marry under Israeli law.

- The gay man banned from giving the commencement address at a Catholic school in Michigan will give a separate address at Central Michigan University.

- Will Smith supports President Obama’s “brave” support of marriage equality.

- Floyd Mayweather proves that not all boxers oppose the President’s position:

  • Comment Icon

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up