ThinkProgress Logo

LGBT

Black Pastor ‘Coalition’ Becomes Star Of NOM’s ‘Race-Wedging’ Strategy

Rev. Bill Owens

In March, confidential memos detailed the National Organization for Marriage’s strategy to drive a wedge between the gay and black communities (and nullify the existence of people who are both black and gay in the process). Unfazed by the backlash, NOM doubled down on the strategy, following through on it in North Carolina and refusing to apologize, even after internal emails showed how particular the group was about highlighting black religious leaders at events.

Now, NOM has redoubled its effort to “fan the hostility” by propping up the overstated Coalition of African-American Pastors and its founder (and NOM’s new spokesperson), Rev. Bill Owens, who likes to compare homosexuality to bestiality. The organization has released a new video, featuring Owens, the vitriolic Bishop Harry Jackson, Pastor Ericka McCrutcheon (who says gays “sodomize each other and practice other deviant behaviors in society), and others, criticizing the NAACP for “pandering to the President” and joining him in supporting marriage equality. Here are a few of the talking points taken right out of NOM’s race-wedging playbook:

JERRY MARTIN: The NAACP is wrong to label same-sex marriage as a civil right.

JOHN MCCRUTCHEON: To use homosexual marriages and civil rights in the same sentence is an oxymoron… Homosexuality is not a civil right.

OWENS: Many African-Americans are struggling because of peer pressure. They don’t know what a person would feel if they speak out against President Obama and the NAACP because they’re black.

Watch it:

While technically CAAP is a coalition of black pastors, it’s not actually representative of anybody except the few radicals who’ve joined it. When CAAP had the gall to demand a meeting with the President two weeks ago, it admitted that it does not speak for any denomination, including the African Methodist Episcopal Church and Church of God in Christ. The group’s only purpose since its founding has been to attack marriage equality, and only since partnering with NOM has its anti-gay tantrums received any legitimate media attention. Unsurprisingly, in the vein of all of NOM’s failed online campaigns, CAAP’s 100000 Signatures 4 Marriage campaign has garnered a full 46 Likes on Facebook.

NOM’s media effort has been to paint CAAP as being some huge conglomeration of black pastors, when in fact it seems to have at best tens of active members (despite Owens’ claim of 1,300 members), and they clearly do not speak on behalf of their community. National polls have shown that a majority of African-American voters support marriage equality, even at higher rates than the national average. Even in Maryland, where Harry Jackson is quite present, a majority of African-American voters are prepared to uphold the state’s same-sex marriage law. NOM is clearly failing and trying to follow through on its plan to sow divisions, but there’s nothing quite as desperate as encouraging black voters to abandon their largest civil rights organization, top civil rights leaders, and the first black president over an issue on which they already largely agree.

Health

New York City Police Targets Sex Workers For Carrying Condoms Despite High Rates of HIV Infection

New York City health workers distributed over 32.7 million free condoms last year in attempt to encourage safer sex. However, the NYPD actively works against the benefits of promoting tools to ensure safer sex by targeting sex workers who have condoms in their possession, using condoms as evidence to arrest people on prostitution charges.

In light of the 19th International AIDS Conference that will be held in Washington, DC later this month, activists are calling on legislators to take concrete steps toward addressing HIV infection. Decriminalizing carrying condoms is part of this initiative, since sex workers are 10 times more likely to be infected with HIV than the general population. Furthermore, sex work is more likely to become a tool of economic survival for disenfranchised populations, such as the estimated 43 percent of trans people who have worked in the sex industry at some point in their lives.

Advocacy groups like the Human Rights Watch (HRW) say it is imperative to promote condom use among this community, rather than aggressively deterring it with threats of arrest:

Police officers confiscate condoms and prosecutors try to enter them as evidence not because it is official policy to do so, but simply because they have not been trained to do otherwise…Categories of evidence — like testimony regarding the sexual history of rape victims — are excluded as a matter of public policy in many legal systems. In this case, the value of condoms for H.I.V. and disease prevention far outweighs any utility they might have in the enforcement of anti-prostitution laws. Law enforcement efforts should not interfere with the right of anyone, including sex workers, to protect his or her own health.

According to HRW’s recent survey on sex workers and condom use, 45.7% of respondents have, at one point or another, decided against carrying condoms for fear that they might get in trouble with the police. In U.S. cities where rates of HIV are close to the rates in some African countries, this is a dangerous precedent.

State Sen. Velmanette Montgomery (D-Brooklyn) introduced legislation in April that would make New York to be the first state to ban police officers from confiscating condoms as evidence for prostitution cases. Montgomery explained that her bill is not meant to endorse prostitution, but rather address the high rates of HIV infection in New York. The bill is currently pending in the New York State Assembly.

Patriots’ Rob Gronkowski Would Be ‘Cool’ Playing With A Gay Teammate

New England Patriots tight end Rob Gronkowski has a colorful reputation that gets him into hot water with the media, so the stakes were high at last Wednesday’s ESPY awards when he took a moment to answer some questions from OutSports. But rather than create a new controversy with an insensitive remark, he joined the many professional athletes who would welcome a gay teammate into the lockerroom:

OUTSPORTS: How would you feel if one of your teammates on the Patriots came out of the closet this season?

GRONKOWSKI: If that’s how they are, that’s how they are. I mean, we’re teammates so, as long as he’s being a good teammate and being respectful and everything, that’s cool.

Gronkowski couldn’t recall ever playing with a gay teammate — certainly no professional football players have ever come out until after they retire from play — but his comments will help create a more inclusive environment for future players to come out. As openly gay former player Wade Davis remarked, “Just the fact that Gronkowski was willing to be interviewed by you for a gay Web site, it’s powerful to somebody.” For many young people, athletes like Gronkowski with a prominent public profile serve as role models for success and achievement. Hopefully someday soon a gay player can serve in the same capacity.

Alyssa

Murs’ Gay Rights Video For “Animal Style” And Hip-Hop Homophobia

Murs’ video for “Animal Style,” a story about the tragic consequences of internalized homophobia and closeting, was planned long before Frank Ocean released the liner notes from Channel Orange that tell the story of his first love. But the timing’s been such that it enters an existing conversation that’s already underway:

The video itself plays into some very old narratives about self-hating black gay men that, while they may be a powerful dramatization of the worst consequences of internalized homophobia, are hardly the sum of the experiences of non-straight African American people. But there’s still something bracing about Murs’ willingness to play a gay man even though he’s straight and married, without any of the coyness or shock-value courting of Lil B’s I’m Gay (I’m Happy) album.

But no matter the content, one of the things that’s fascinating about the reaction to the clip is the anxiety some people appear to feel about its existence. “Since when is HIP HOP and being GAY ever intertwined,” complains one commenter on World Star Hip-Hop. “Wtf , why are rappers trying to capitalize on this gay shit now,” whines another. The idea that hip-hop has somehow been captured by a gay takeover is ludicrous, of course. But it’s amazing how threatened people feel by even a couple of positively-received efforts by rappers and R&B singers to explore sexuality and homophobia. Frank Ocean, Lil B, and Murs are a beginning of a conversation, rather than the end of it. And some people seem very nervous about the prospect of that conversation taking place anywhere, even if there’s absolutely no requirement that they participate in it, if only because they know that it means their views may no longer be dominant.

NEWS FLASH

AT&T CEO Says He Will Back End To Boy Scouts’ Anti-LGBT Ban | Randall L. Stephenson, chairman, CEO, and president of AT&T and vice president of the Boy Scouts of America, supports efforts to lift the ban on LGBT scouts and scout leaders. The Dallas Voice reported last week that a Stephenson spokesman told the paper he is committed to changing the policy. Ernst & Young CEO James Turley, another member of the BSA national board, has already voiced his support for such a change. A Change.org petition launched by Jen Tyrrell, an Ohio mom removed from her position as a Cub Scout den leader purely because she is a lesbian, successfully urged both Turley and Stephenson to publicly support dropping the ban. For more context on the proposed change, check out the ThinkProgress interview with Eagle Scout Zach Wahls.

Florida Lieutenant Governor: ‘Black Women Who Look Like Me’ Don’t Have Lesbian Relationships

Florida Lieutenant Governor Jennifer Carroll (R) — a former Florida state representative and a Romney surrogate — has been accused of having a sexual relationship with one of her female aides. Carroll denies that the affair ever happened, but her response to the controversy relies on a line of reasoning that simply wouldn’t hold if she were accused of having a relationship with a male aide:

CARROLL: The problem is that when you have these accusations that come out, it’s not just one person you’re attacking. It’s an entire family. My husband doesn’t want to hear that. He knows the type of woman I am. I mean, my kids know the type of woman I am. For twenty-nine years – I’m the one that’s married for twenty-nine years. The accuser is the one that’s been single for a long time. So usually black women that look like me don’t engage in relationships like that.

Regardless of whether the accusation against her is true or false, Carroll’s defense of her character has more to do with disproving the allegations about her sexuality than with disproving the allegations about marital infidelity. Carroll seems to believe that her marriage, her children, and her appearance all prevent her from being capable of having a relationship with a woman — when, of course, none of these factors is actually a precursor to heterosexuality.

Carroll, who believes President Obama’s decision to allow gay and lesbian individuals to serve openly in the military will throw the armed forces “off their mission,” may have personal opinions about the LGBT community that impact her response to the current controversy. However, perpetrating negative stereotypes about lesbians — particularly the false assumption that they look a certain way — is not a persuasive way to defend her character.

NEWS FLASH

WHO HIV/AIDS Chief: Arsenal Of Drugs Could Eliminate Future HIV Infections | In an interview with AFP, Gottfried Hirnschall, the World Health Organization’s HIV/AIDS chief, said that “a fairly large arsenal of drugs” is currently available to someday end new infections of HIV. Due to research breakthroughs, the world now “has 26 antiretroviral (ARV) drugs on the market and more in the pipeline for treating people” with HIV, and in 2010, 700,000 people with HIV were kept alive thanks to the ARV medications. What’s more, WHO suggests that the new drugs may be able to prevent HIV transmission and infection of healthy people. According to AFP, one such drug already exists, and “a U.S. advisory panel has urged the Food and Drug Administration to approve the first-ever HIV prevention pill…for use in some high-risk populations.” Next week, Hirschnall will be attending the International AIDS conference in Washington, the first since 1990.

Nina Liss-Schultz

Update

This afternoon the FDA officially approved Truvada, an HIV prevention pill that has been on the market since 2004. This is the first time an oral pill has been given the FDA seal of approval for combating HIV infections.

Mississippi Public Museum Discriminates Against Same-Sex Couple

Ceara Sturgis and Emily Key

Ceara Sturgis and Emily Key wanted to rent the Masonic Hall at the Mississippi Agriculture and Forestry Museum to hold a commitment ceremony, but were refused because they are a same-sex couple. Sturgis’ mother, Veronica Rodriguez, lamented that her daughter has been denied use of the “perfect venue”:

RODRIGUEZ: As a mother, I have dreamed of giving my daughter the wedding that she desires, and I want her to be able to get married in her hometown in front of our family and friends. We are not asking Mississippi to recognize Ceara and Emily’s relationship, although it should. We are just asking that they have the opportunity to hold a ceremony in a public place – the same as other couples.

The state-owned museum allows heterosexual couples to use the space for their ceremonies, but its director claims that it has a policy banning same-sex weddings and ceremonies. In 2009, State Attorney General Jim Hood released a letter stating that the museum can limit use of its facilities to events considered “legal” under state law. The Southern Poverty Law Center has come to the couple’s defense, arguing that the policy violates the First Amendment (with viewpoint discrimination) and the Fourteenth Amendment (with differential treatment).

Hood’s argument fails on its face. If it were true, then it would technically be illegal to have any kind of same-sex wedding or commitment ceremony. There is a difference between not recognizing same-sex unions and declaring them to be unlawful. What Hood seems to have suggested is that Sturgis and Key could be arrested simply by declaring their love for each other in front of their family and friends, which would obviously violate their right to free speech and expression. Given the growing number of religious denominations that recognize marriage equality, such a precedent would also be a clear violation of religious freedom.

For the state of Mississippi to declare that a same-sex commitment ceremony is unlawful behavior is an egregious attack on gay community and its personal liberties. It’s nothing more than a pathetic excuse for blatant anti-gay discrimination.

NEWS FLASH

Seattle Shop Supports Marriage Equality Campaign Selling Gay Cupcakes | A Seattle cupcake shop, Cupcake Royale, has been raising money in support of R-74, a ballot initiative in Washington to ratify the state legislature’s decision to legalize same-sex marriage. Jody Hall, the owner of Cupcake Royale, designed a special cupcake, called “The Gay,” for the campaign, and raised $7,000 from its sales in June. Due to her success selling The Gay cupcakes last month, Hall was asked to set up a political action committee (PAC) for her fundraising.  To date, supporters of R-74 have raised over $2 million, compared to opponents of the initiative, who have raised only $142,000.

Nina Liss-Schultz

France Passes Law Against Transgender Discrimination And Harassment

The French senate voted unanimously last week to prohibit discrimination against transgender people. Unfortunately, the language used to identify the protections was “sexual identity,” which is a less accurate term than “gender identity” as used in other legislation throughout Europe. Still, a number of impassioned speeches preceded the important vote, including from Sen. Michelle Miller (Socialist Party):

MILLER: Transgender people have alerted us to high frequency of harassment and assaults they experience, particularly during the transition period that can last several years. It seems necessary to me to complete the law on discrimination and to add recognition of transphobia.

According to a recent poll, 34 percent of young trans people in France have attempted suicide and 19 percent have been disowned by their family. Those numbers are even higher in the U.S., where 41 percent of trans people have attempted suicide and 57 percent experience significant family rejection. Establishing legal protections are an important first step to reducing anti-trans discrimination, a step the U.S. has yet to take.

  • Comment Icon

The Morning Pride: July 16, 2012

Welcome to The Morning Pride, ThinkProgress LGBT’s daily round-up of the latest in LGBT policy, politics, and some culture too! Here’s what we’re reading this morning, but please let us know what stories you’re following as well. Follow us all day on Twitter at @TPEquality.

- A bi-national same-sex couple has filed a new lawsuit challenging the Defense of Marriage Act to avoid separation or relocation to the Philippines.

- Carl Siciliano, founder of the Ali Forney Center for LGBT youth homelessness, is officially a White House “Champion of Change.”

- Meet Kevin Loosterman, a former Mormon bishop who came out as an LGBT ally after watching Queer Eye For The Straight Guy.

- Anti-gay zealot Scott Lively, who believes the Nazi party was part of the “gay agenda,” is campaigning against a non-discrimination ordinance in Springfield, Missouri, comparing the protections to the chicken pox.

- Jamaica’s outgoing assistant police commissioner blamed the gay community for the violence it suffers in the very homophobic country.

- Target stores have begun selling greeting cards for same-sex weddings.

- What happened after Dean Ostrum’s wife and kids realized he was gay:

  • Comment Icon

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up