ThinkProgress Logo

LGBT

NEWS FLASH

Catholic Leaders Not Giving Up On Marriage Inequality | The Catholic Church gave millions of dollars to fight marriage equality this year — money that could have gone to charitable causes — but is apparently unfazed by the defeat in all four states. When congratulating President Obama on his re-election, Cardinal Timothy Dolan promised that the Church will continue to “stand in defense” of life, marriage, and religious freedom. Responding to the marriage equality victory in Maryland, Baltimore Archbishop William Lori similarly said the Church must “redouble our efforts to defend marriage,” warning that the freedom to marry “will prove not to have been for the common good of our state.” If one of the Church’s top priorities remains opposing legal security for same-sex couples and their children, it will become more difficult to argue that its mission has anything to do with supporting the common good.

NOM Admits Its Anti-Gay Mission Moving Forward Is Entirely Religious

NOM's stock photo-banner defending 'marriage as God designed it.'

Earlier today, the National Organization for Marriage admitted that it lost its various fights, but that it still believed it had a winning case to make. It followed up this afternoon with a message to its supporters that included some new language — namely, that its entire crusade against same-sex marriage is based on religious ideas:

But make no mistake: we are disappointed, but we are not defeated! We are fighting for a true and just cause—God’s institution of marriage. This is a social compact that is not only ordained by the Almighty, it has served society very well. It’s a cause worth fighting and with your support we will continue to do just that. [...]

Though we are disappointed over these losses, we remain faithful to our mission and committed to the cause of preserving marriage as God designed it. Marriage is a true and just cause, and we will never abandon the field of battle just because we experienced a setback. There is much work to do. With your continued support and with faith in God, we begin that process now.

NOM used to distinguish itself from more obviously “Christian”-affiliated groups like the Family Research Council by not using religious rhetoric. Instead, NOM claimed it was protecting “traditional marriage,” and argued that same-sex marriage would somehow negatively impact children, fidelity, and the “institution” of marriage. In this low moment, the organization has made clear that those arguments are all spin and that its true goal is to impose one set of religious values upon the entire country. This isn’t a surprising reality, but it is a notable admission.

NEWS FLASH

Los Angeles County Votes To Require Condoms In Porn | Voters in Los Angeles County have approved a measure that would require any adult film stars filming there to wear condoms in their films. It’s an expansion of an already existing city ordinance in Los Angeles, designed to protect actors and promote safe sex practices among pornography consumers. Though opponents claimed that it would hurt the industry, the measure passed with 55.9 percent of the vote.

Looking Ahead: The Seven States That Could Soon Expand Rights For Same-Sex Couples

Credit: AP Photo/Ted S. Warren

Credit: AP Photo/Ted S. Warren

With Tuesday’s sweeping pro-LGBT victories in Maine, Maryland, Minnesota, and Washington state, marriage equality will be the law of the land in eight or nine states and the District of Columbia. Another five states have civil unions laws. The National Organization for Marriage, along with other anti-equality organizations, have lost their principal talking point and can no longer claim that every time voters considered marriage, equality loses — so it seems likely the number of states recognizing same-sex couples will continue to climb in the upcoming year.

Here are some states that could consider the issue in the near future:

1. Colorado: While a 2006 constitutional amendment prevents the state legislature from enacting marriage equality, a civil unions bill was only defeated this year thanks to stunning maneuvers by Colorado Speaker of the House Frank McNulty (R) to thwart the majority in his chamber. McNulty lost his majority Tuesday and his likely successor as Speaker, openly gay Rep. Mark Ferrandino (D), is the bill’s chief backer. Polling shows 70 percent of Coloradans support legal recognition for same-sex couples, so movement on this appears likely in 2013.

2. Minnesota: Not only did Minnesota voters defeat a proposed constitutional amendment to ban same-sex unions Tuesday, they also flipped control of both the state House of Representatives and Senate. The Republican majorities who pushed the marriage inequality amendment onto the ballots will be replaced by a new Democratic majority in each chamber. With Gov. Mark Dayton (D) a strong supporter of marriage equality and a clear popular mandate for marriage equality evident from the amendment vote, Minnesota could also potentially move on this in 2013.

3. Rhode Island: With Tuesday’s victory in Maine, Rhode Island is now the only state in New England without marriage equality. With polling showing more than 56 percent of voters in the Ocean State favoring full marriage equality — instead of the state’s existing weak civil unions law — openly gay state Speaker of the House Gordon Fox (D) has promised to bring up a marriage equality bill next year. Tuesday’s Rhode Island legislative races saw “significant and undeniable gains,” for the pro-marriage-equality side, according to supporters.

4. Illinois: Since Gov. Patrick Quinn (D) backs marriage equality and popular support is surging for moving from civil unions for full marriage, state legislators are pondering a bill for 2013.

5. Delaware: Gov. Jack Markell (D) was re-elected with nearly 70 percent of the vote on Tuesday. He has called the transition from civil unions to marriage equality “inevitable” and expects the legislature to take it up in 2013.

6. Ohio: With poll numbers showing growing support, citizens in Ohio are working to repeal the state’s 2004 marriage inequality amendment and are trying to place an amendment on the ballot in 2013 to replace it with pro-equality language.

7. New Jersey: Though Gov. Chris Christie (R) vetoed a bill to move from civil unions to full marriage equality last February, the state continues to support the idea. Christie has proposed putting the measure up for a vote, though the success of the initiative may depend on the 2013 New Jersey gubernatorial and legislature election results.

With the Supreme Court set to consider whether to take up the Proposition 8 case in California later this month, the citizens of the nation’s most populous state could also once see marriage equality in the near future. The high court is also expected to decide on a challenge to the unconstitutional Defense of Marriage Act, which could create new protections for all same-sex couples across the country.

Despite the best efforts of anti-equality groups to defeat President Obama and an array of pro-marriage equality Democrats, Tuesday’s results show that the American electorate will no longer be fooled by the gay-baiting homophobic attacks that obstructed progress on this issue for the past two decades.

National Organization For Marriage Claims ‘We Are Not Defeated,’ Ignoring Reality

NOM's Brian Brown crying after New York passed marriage equality in 2011.

It’s impossible to examine yesterday’s incredible victories as anything but confirmation that votes have finally caught up with polls and a majority of Americans now supports marriage equality. That is, of course, except for the National Organization for Marriage — the chief opponents of equality — who woke up today as convinced as ever that nothing is changing among public sentiment. Here is how NOM President Brian Brown responsed today:

BROWN: Despite the fact that NOM was able to contribute a record amount to the campaigns (over $5.5 million), we were still heavily outspent, by a margin of at least four-to-one. We were fighting the entirety of the political establishment in most of the states, including sitting governors in three of the states who campaigned heavily for gay marriage. Our opponents and some in the media will attempt to portray the election results as a changing point in how Americans view gay marriage, but that is not the case. Americans remain strongly in favor of marriage as the union of one man and one woman. The election results reflect the political and funding advantages our opponents enjoyed in these very liberal states.

Brown’s response is fairly insulting to voters, insinuating that money alone can change hearts and minds. As Nathaniel Frank points out today, these marriage equality victories reflect a successful new campaign approach to help straight voters better understand how to relate to their gay friends, family, and neighbors. In contrast, NOM relied on its traditional scare tactics, which newspapers across the country vehemently debunked and decried. NOM is not just on the losing side of a money fight, but of an ideas fight too.

NOM will likely never give up on its anti-gay principles, but every day it stands by them is another day it is out of touch with reality. If four public votes, many huge corporations, and several prominent political leaders are not evidence enough to convince NOM that it’s on the wrong side of history, nothing will.

What An Ally Looks Like: Chris Kluwe Celebrates Marriage Equality Victories

Minnesota Vikings punter Chris Kluwe emerged somewhat abruptly this year as a passionate advocate for marriage equality, particularly because of his colorful response when a Maryland legislator tried to tell Brendon Ayanbadejo of the Baltimore Ravens to keep his LGBT support to himself. Following the explosion of public interest, Kluwe applied his notoriety to campaigning against Minnesota’s marriage inequality amendment, including recording a memorable radio ad. Commemorating the victories in Maryland, Maine, and Minnesota and the likely victory in Washington, Kluwe shared some reflections today at Slate.com:

Together, we made a statement that America is tired of division. America is tired of discrimination, of exclusion, and of unthinking oppression—the belief that people have to live their lives according to someone else’s views rather than their own free will.

Together, we made sure that the world our children will grow up in is one step closer to tolerance, love, and equality; a world where our children can make their own choices instead of being shackled to dusty hate from the past.

Together, we showed this nation that a polity functions best when it includes all of its citizens, when it celebrates their differences as part of one glorious whole, when it synthesizes a wide assortment of cultures and beliefs under the guiding principles of freedom and happiness for everyone.

Together, we can approach the work still at hand. We can face the continuous fight for equality that every society must wage each generation. We may not know the specifics until they’re upon us, but the underlying foundation is always the same—living your own life vs. someone else making your choices for you.

Together, we can promote free will over oppression. We can treat others the way we want to be treated, with dignity and respect. We can work together to find common ground, despite our differences, and build a stable, nurturing society.

It’s no secret that the LGBT community depends on friends, family members, and other allies to support progress towards equality. Kluwe may be brazen at times, but he is a shining example of what an ally looks like and what it truly means to love and respect LGBT people.

NEWS FLASH

Troy, Michigan Voters Oust Homophobic Mayor | Another important victory for LGBT equality took place in Troy, Michigan, where voters ousted their anti-gay mayor, Janice Daniels. Last summer, when marriage equality passed in New York, Daniels posted on Facebook that she had to throw out her “I Love New York” bag “now that queers can get married there.” In January, she told a group of high school students that homosexuality is a dangerous mental disease, and when threatened with the recall vote, she compared homosexuality to the dangers of smoking. Daniels is entitled to a recount, but with a 52-48 defeat, it seems unlikely to change the result.

Sweeping 2012 Victories Show Promise Of LGBT Equality’s Future

Senator-elect Tammy Baldwin (D-WI)

In no uncertain terms, this year’s election was a sweeping mandate on LGBT equality. Forgotten is 2008′s bittersweet realization that though Barack Obama had won, California’s Proposition 8 had passed. Instead, this election’s returns show a new America poised to move forward and ensure that sexual orientation and gender identity are never barriers to freedom and security. Here’s a glimpse of just how sweeping the victory is for the LGBT community:

Maine

Maine’s voters have approved marriage equality with 53 percent in favor and 47 percent opposed, a complete reversal of the 2009 people’s veto of the very same law. Victory in Maine demonstrates the incredible power of personally connecting with voters, as advocates spent everyday since the 2009 loss canvassing to reach out. It is a significant milestone, because it is the first state to extend the freedom to marry entirely through a grassroots effort: voters brought forth a petition and then voters approved it. Conservatives cannot point to judges or lawmakers and somehow claim that the people did not have a say.

Maryland

Maryland also approved marriage equality by a 52-48 margin, proving that efforts to drive a wedge between the gay and black communities will not succeed. Like in Maine, the people had the opportunity to weigh in, and they weighed in on the side of equality and validating the legislature’s decision to pass same-sex marriage. This is also a significant win for Gov. Martin O’Malley (D), who championed this legislation all year long.

Washington [UPDATED]

UPDATE: As of Wednesday afternoon, victory has been officially declared in Washington for marriage equality!

This morning, Washington’s Referendum 74 is still too close to call, but with the votes coming in so far, it is leading 52-48. Given Washington’s victory in approving everything-but-marriage domestic partnerships in 2009, there is reason to be optimistic that its voters once again sided with equality.

Minnesota

Though Minnesota does not have marriage equality to embrace yet, the 51-48 defeat of its marriage inequality amendment is a significant victory. Opponents have boasted that in every state where voters have the chance to limit marriage to opposite-sex couples, they have done so, and Minnesota breaks that record. In addition, Democrats won control of both chambers of Minnesota’s legislature, ensuring that there will not be future attempts to enshrine discrimination in the constitution anytime soon.

LGBT Candidates

Yesterday was an historic victory for openly LGBT candidates, and the next Congress will break records for its significant out contingent. Tammy Baldwin (D-WI) will become the first LGBT member of the Senate. Mark Pocan (D-WI) will fill her House seat, joined by fellow newcomer Sean Patrick Maloney (D) of New York. In addition, Reps. Jared Polis (D-CO) and David Cicilline (D-RI) won re-election. A projected winner remains to be called in the House races for Mark Takano (D-CA) and Kyrsten Sinema (D-AZ), but they are both leading in the polls so far and could add to the record-breaking LGBT caucus.

(UPDATE: Mark Tokano has declared victory.)

One out candidate who did not win was Massachusetts Republican Richard Tisei, though this does not necessarily represent a loss for the LGBT community. Incumbent victor John Tierney (D) is a dedicated ally to the LGBT community who does not bear the same risk of further empowering conservatives who would act against equality.
Read more

NEWS FLASH

Marriage Equality 2 For 2 With Maine And Maryland Victories! | History has been made already tonight. Voters in Maine have reversed their 2009 decision and have passed marriage equality into law through a popular vote effort. In addition, Maryland voters had the opportunity to reverse the state legislature’s decision to pass same-sex marriage, but has instead upheld it. Numbers continue to look good for a similar result in Washington with Minnesota possibly defeating its marriage inequality amendment as well.  Stay tuned!

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up