ThinkProgress Logo

LGBT

NEWS FLASH

Defense Budget Advances With Watered-Down ‘License To Bully’ Provision | As expected, the defense budget bill has advanced out of conference with a watered-down version of Rep. Todd Akin’s (R-MO) “license to bully” amendment, which protects anti-gay servicemembers from discipline. According to the Washington Blade, the new version of the “conscience protections” clarifies that actions and speech can still be disciplined, but anti-gay beliefs themselves cannot be used to justify adverse personnel actions. The precise new language has not yet been made public. Rep. Adam Smith (D-WA) says the language was unnecessary because beliefs are already protected, but doesn’t believe the change will have negative consequences.

Politics

Florida Sought To Disenfranchise College Students In 2012 Election, Lawmaker Admits

Election Day in Florida became a nightmare due to several changes to election law, resulting in marathon lines and more provisional ballots. Now that the election is over, Florida Republicans are beginning to admit the mess was intended to suppress votes.

State Rep. Dennis Baxley (R-FL) and GOP chair of Alachua County, Stafford Jones, cooked up one of Florida’s many new laws specifically to keep college students from voting in the 2012 election. The vote-suppressing measures were inspired by the 2010 victory of Gainesville’s first openly gay mayor, Craig Lowe, which Republicans claim was stolen by Florida college students.

Baxley’s law prevented people from voting if they did not change their address a month before Election Day. Many of the people affected were college students or young people who were moving for a new job. Jones explained this vote suppression was intentional and accused liberals of bringing in students to swing the election:

Baxley said Jones told him that voters from Tampa and other cities shifted their voter registrations to Gainesville for a day to vote in the city’s 2010 mayoral election in which Craig Lowe became the city’s first openly gay mayor by a 42-vote margin.

“It wasn’t right for people to move in and steal an election like that,” Baxley said.

Jones said he wanted the county transfer provision to keep college students from voting.

“The liberals do a good job of bringing in college kids to vote on local issues,” Jones said. “The kids vote on raising our taxes, but don’t have to live here to pay the consequences.”

Jones said he has no proof to support his claim, only recollections of liberal blog posts that people were moving to vote.

Gainesville is the home of the University of Florida, one of the most diverse universities in the nation. College students tend to hold more liberal views, and favored President Obama by 30 percent this year. Disenfranchisement of students is a tried and true Republican tactic. During the recall election of Gov. Scott Walker (R-WI) in June, election officials ruled that some student IDs were not eligible for voting and passed a law that made it harder for Wisconsin students to claim residency in the state.

Beyond hijinks at the local level, the Florida GOP admitted soon after the election that the goal of these new laws was always to keep Democratic voters away from the polls. Their efforts at voter suppression succeeded; the number of provisional ballots jumped an average of 25 percent in each county from last year.

NEWS FLASH

New York Mets Investigates New Pitcher’s Homophobic Tweet | Through a recent trade, the New York Mets recently picked up right-handed pitcher Noah Syndergaard, rated one of Toronto’s top pitching prospects. Unfortunately, he’s homophobic as well, tweeting last week, “@DMarze89 nice crocs fag lol.” The tweet has been deleted and the Mets claim to be investigating the full context of the tweet, though it’s unclear what context could possibly redeem its offensiveness.

Vatican Editorial Claims Gay Couples Exist In ‘A Different Reality’

Monday’s edition of Osservatore Romano, the official newspaper of the Vatican, features a front-page editorial attacking French Catholic magazine Temoignage Chretien (“Christian Witness”) for supporting marriage equality. The editorial claims that same-sex couples exist in “a different reality” because they are unable to conceive children, and goes on to claim that marriage equality is part of some socialist “utopia”:

Saying that marriage between a woman and a man is equal to that between two homosexuals is, in fact, a denial of the truth that affects one of the basic structures of human society, the family. We cannot base a society on these foundations without then paying a very high price as happened in the past when there was an attempt to achieve total economic and social equality. Why repeat the same mistake and chase after an unattainable utopia?

The editorial comes on the heels of Pope Benedict’s World Peace Day 2013 address claiming that marriage equality threatens “serious harm to justice and peace.” Though the Catholic Church has always condemned homosexuality as “sinful,” cries of “socialism” represent a new low for the Holy See’s desperation to oppose LGBT equality.

So-Called ‘Family Values’ Group Sued For Sexual Harassment

A former employee is suing the anti-gay Family Research Council for sexual harassment, citing the sexually suggestive comments of her supervisor, particularly in regards to birth control.

Moira Gaul worked as director of women’s and reproductive health for the FRC, an anti-gay hate group that claims to represent “traditional family values.” Her expertise is in abstinence-only education. But even for a woman ideologically aligned with such a socially conservative organization, the anti-woman rhetoric of her supervisor proved too much:

According to court documents first obtained and reported by journalist Evan Gahr, former FRC employee Moira Gaul, 42, filed a complaint in 2009 with the District of Columbia Human Rights Commission in which she accused her supervisor of gender discrimination. She claimed that her boss, the director of the Center for Human Life and Bioethics at the time, referred to the use of birth control pills as “whoring around,” addressed emails to her with the words “hi cutie,” pressured her to attend parties, and referred to her as a “young, attractive woman.”

“His attitude toward me and other women was rude, belittling, and at times, angry,” she wrote in the complaint.

Gaul’s supervisor’s comments are reminiscent of the assertion by Rush Limbaugh that young women’s rights activist Sandra Fluke was on birth control because she was having “so much sex.” FRC has been one of those groups most opposed to the contraception mandate requiring employers to cover contraception under the Affordable Care Act. The organization promotes abstinence-only sex education and is rabidly anti-gay.

The Huffington Post reports that the suit was originally settled back in 2009, but that it has re-emerged because Gaul and her attorney believe the FRC illegally retaliated against her for filing the original suit.

NEWS FLASH

Rhode Island Senate President Will Allow Marriage Equality Vote | Rhode Island Senate President Teresa Paiva Weed (D) has announced that she will allow the Senate to vote on a marriage equality bill, but only after it passes in the House. Speaker Gordon Fox (D), who is openly gay, has promised to bring forth the legislation as one of his top priorities in 2011. Rhode Island was expected to pass marriage equality in 2013, but ended up only managing to advance a weak civil unions bill because of Paiva Weed’s opposition. Because Rhode Island recognizes same-sex marriages from other states and all its neighbors offer them, civil unions have been so unpopular, only 68 couples got one over the first year they were offered. An October poll showed that 56 percent of Rhode Island voters support the freedom to marry.

Justice

Montana Supreme Court Denies Benefits To Gay Couples — For Now

The Montana Supreme Court

Yesterday, a sharply divided Montana Supreme Court turned aside a lawsuit by several same-sex couples “complaining that they are unable to obtain protections and benefits that are available to similarly situated different-sex couples who marry under State law.” Although this is a setback for gay rights, it is not clear that this setback will be permanent. Rather than challenge a particular provision of law, the plaintiffs in this lawsuit “seek a general declaration of their rights and seek orders enjoining the State to provide them a ‘legal status and statutory structure’ that protects their rights.” In essence, yesterday’s order tells the plaintiffs to be more specific in explaining just how their rights have been violated — and which specific statutes have violated them — and then come back an try again.

Three of the court’s seven justices dissented, in opinions indicating that they would extend equal benefits to gay couples right now, rather than wait for another round of litigation. One justice, Justice Jim Rice, wrote a separate concurring opinion indicating that he rejects extending equal rights to gay couples outright. So, with three votes on record in support of gay rights and only one opposed, the plaintiffs appear to be in a strong position if their case reaches these same justices again.

The most significant impact of yesterday’s order, however, is that it ensures that this issue will not reach the same panel of seven justices again. Justice James Nelson will retire from the bench this month. And his 119 page dissenting opinion leaves no doubt that he is the court’s staunchest supporter of equality:

There are many who believe that gays and lesbians are second-class citizens; that they are morally inferior; that they are objects worthy of societal scorn, derision, and hatred; that they may be reviled and demonized on the floor of the Legislature with impunity; that they may be discriminated against by local governments; that they may be bullied in their schools and workplaces; and that they are not entitled to the same rights accorded to heterosexuals. Such views parallel those held by many—even the United States Supreme Court—regarding racial minorities and women a century ago. . . . We legitimize those similar, pernicious views about gays and lesbians when, as the Court does today, we abrogate our solemn obligation to declare and uphold the constitutional rights of all Montanans—especially those among us who have been subjected to majoritarian and state-imposed hatred and discrimination.

My abiding belief is that no person—no human being—in our society should be reviled, demonized, and discriminated against for being gay, lesbian, or bisexual, any more than they should be treated in that fashion for being Native American, Presbyterian, female, disabled, poor, or Irish. No person should be the object of state-sanctioned bigotry simply for being born homosexual or for choosing to love another person of the same sex. No person should be made to suffer the deprivation of their civil rights and liberties because of the religious beliefs and doctrines of others—doctrines that are now constitutionalized in the Marriage Amendment and enforced by Montana’s government. And no person should be stripped of her or his inviolable human dignity based on sexual orientation. Ever!

Although Nelson deeply regrets the court’s decision to put this question off until another day, he ends his opinion on a hopeful note: “the taboo will die because the scare tactics, propaganda, and misinformation of those who would hang on to the maledictions and stereotypes have proven to be so patently false, malicious, and absurd. Most decent people just hate being lied to. Indeed, a not-too-distant generation of Montanans will consign today’s decision, the Marriage Amendment, and the underlying intolerance to the dustbin of history and to the status of a meaningless, shameful, artifact.”

Led By Akin, Republicans Push For Military ‘License To Bully’

Rep. Todd Akin (R-MO)

Rep. Todd Akin (R-MO) is departing the House at the end of this year, but he’s trying to force some of his odious anti-gay rhetoric into law before he goes. Earlier this year, he proposed an amendment to the defense budget that would create a “license to bully” for military personnel, essentially guaranteeing that anybody who has a problem with LGBT people can’t be disciplined for it, even if they’re engaging in blatant discrimination or harassment.

The House passed the amendment, but the Senate didn’t give the idea any consideration. Now that the bill is in conference, Republican leaders are trying to add it back in.

The conference is being negotiated by Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) and Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon (R-CA), both of whom opposed the repeal of Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell (DADT) and have substantial anti-gay records. When McKeon assumed leadership of the House Armed Services Committee, he pledged to pass clean defense bills that were “not weighed down” by social issues, but for the past two years, he has done just the opposite, supporting anti-gay measures like Akin’s and others. Though none of the measures advanced by the House last year survived conference with the Senate, a House Democratic aide says McCain and McKeon are “pushing pretty hard” to get Akin’s through this year.

OutServe-SLDN’s Allyson Robinson points out that Akin’s measure would foster the kind of unit cohesion problems Republicans incorrectly claimed DADT repeal would cause:

ROBINSON: As a former military commander, I can tell you that allowing any service member to openly discriminate against a comrade in this way will compromise good order and discipline — the very thing supporters of ‘Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell’ falsely claimed was going to happen back when we repealed the law. The fact is, there are already strong protections for all service members, including chaplains, in place, and all this provision would do is create a license to discriminate. The next Secretary of Defense should not be saddled with a law that makes it harder for small unit commanders in the field to lead their troops.

Conference negotiations for the defense budget bill have been underway for several days already, and it’s unclear when they will conclude. Hopefully Congress will find a way to support the military without endorsing mistreatment of the gay, lesbian, and bisexual troops proudly serving their country.

NEWS FLASH

Helena, Montana Passes LGBT Nondiscrimination Protections | The City Commission of Helena, Montana has unanimously approved an ordinance that protects LGBT people from discrimination in employment, housing, and public accommodations. Many community members expressed concern about the “bathroom” meme, that somehow children would be at risk if trans people could use the bathrooms with which they identify. The law’s passage represents a big victory for LGBT Montanans, but reflects a long persistent process of advocacy.

East Aurora School District Abandons Trans Students Again

East Aurora School Board

Illinois’s East Aurora School Board does not have the courage of its convictions, having once again given up on protecting transgender students. In October, the district innocuously passed a policy that would protect transgender students’ ability to identity with their authentic gender. The Illinois Family Institute, an anti-LGBT hate group, objected to the accommodations for “gender-confused teens,” and four days after passing it, the school board rescinded the policy.

Despite caving, there was hope that East Aurora would still do right by its trans students. The board formed an ad hoc committee to explore the issues with a goal of forming an alternative policy. However, when the committee met, over a hundred community members came to protest, claiming that protecting trans students was somehow “destructive” and that it would threaten the safety of other students if they were allowed to use the appropriate bathrooms. These arguments were of course spurred again by the Illinois Family Institute, which went so far as to encourage the bullying of trans students. The outcry overwhelmed the committee, which decided to put the transgender policy on hold. Now, they’ve abandoned it entirely.

The committee was not designed to be effective in the first place. Rather than focus on researching the policy, the committee allowed itself to be overwhelmed by public comment. The crowd was so against the effort that security had to be called to protect committee members. Anthony Martinez, executive director of Illinois LGBT advocacy group The Civil Rights Agenda, sat on the committee and described it as a “failure of leadership”:

MARTINEZ: I think it was a failure of leadership by the school board. I think the folks handling this from the beginning were out of their depth. You only have to look and see that the Ad Hoc committee never once discussed the matter of policy. All we did was sit and listen to people voice their displeasure.

Indeed, the school board’s failure was ever questioning itself in the first place or creating space for a hate group’s influence to play out. The end result was stirred up antipathy towards trans people with no real progress for the safety of the students at risk.

The Morning Pride: December 18, 2012

Welcome to The Morning Pride, ThinkProgress LGBT’s daily round-up of the latest in LGBT policy, politics, and some culture too! Here’s what we’re reading this morning, but please let us know what stories you’re following as well. Follow us all day on Twitter at @TPEquality.

- Towleroad takes a look at 50 powerful coming out stories from 2012.

- The family of a gay teen in Utah who committed suicide last week claim the school did not appropriately handle a discipline situation.

- Intel is going to offer trans-inclusive health benefits to employees.

- Pastor Blasious Ruguri, the president of the Seventh-day Adventist church in East and Central Africa, has endorsed Uganda’s “Kill the Gays” bill.

- San Francisco is warning gay men traveling to New York City to get vaccinated against meningitis due to an outbreak there.

- Transsexual magazine Candy features a trans model portraying Michelle Obama.

- Three years ago, the Atlanta Police Department led a controversial raid on a gay bar, but now they’re saying, “It Gets Better”:

  • Comment Icon

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up