Our guest blogger is Crosby Burns, special assistant for the LGBT Research and Communications Project at American Progress.
Today, Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY) introduced federal legislation that would bar discrimination against prospective LGBT adoptive or foster parents. The “Every Child Deserves a Family Act” prohibits any organization that receives federal assistance and is involved in adoption or foster care placements from discriminating against prospective adoptive or foster parents on the basis of their sexual orientation, gender identity, or marital status. Congressman Pete Stark (D-CA) introduced the same bill in the House earlier this year, which currently has 76 co-sponsors.
LGBT couples looking to adopt currently face discrimination in more than 30 states, and if passed, Gilibrand’s bill would ensure that no child is left without a home because their adoption agency or foster care provider discriminated against prospective LGBT caretakers. There are currently approximately 400,000 children in the US foster system, with an additional 107,000 children nationwide waiting to be adopted.
This bill comes the same week that a broad coalition of LGBT and social welfare organizations released a comprehensive report, All Children Matter, that documents the ways in which state and federal laws hurt the more than 2 million children living with LGBT parents. For example, the report identified state and federal adoption policies that prevent children from leaving the adoptive and foster care system and entering into loving homes headed by LGBT couples. These policies have disastrous implications for our nation’s children, putting them at a higher risk for poverty, homelessness, incarceration, and early parenthood.
The report also offers numerous policy recommendations – such removing restrictions to LGBT adoption – to ensure that all children have the financial and emotional support needed to develop happily and healthily. Studies have consistently found that LGBT parents are just as fit and effective as straight parents, and their children are just as well-adjusted and physically and psychologically developed.
Domestic Abuse Increases Throughout LGBT Community |
A new report from the National Anti-Violence Project reveals that rates of domestic abuse and violence have increased among couples in the LGBT community and that support and protections for survivors is low. Reports of domestic violence increased 38 percent from last year, including seven deaths. Over 44 percent of survivors were turned away from traditional shelters and over 54 percent who sought court orders for protection from abuse were denied. (HT: David Mixner.)
Bishop William Lori of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops testified before a House Judiciary subcommittee on Oct. 26 about the “grave threats to religious liberty that have emerged even since June.” Lori specifically singled out the administration’s refusal to defend the constitutionality of the 1996 Defense of Marriage Act and state efforts to expand marriage equality to gays and lesbians:
The federal Department of Justice (DoJ) has ratcheted up its attack on the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) by mischaracterizing it as an act of bigotry….If the label of “bigot” sticks to our Church and many other churches—especially in court, under the Constitution—because of their teaching on marriage, the result will be church-state conflicts for many years to come. [...]
At the state level, religious liberty protections associated with the redefinition of marriage have fallen far short of what is necessary. In New York, county clerks face legal action for refusing to participate in same-sex unions, and gay rights advocates boast how little religious freedom protection individuals and groups will enjoy under the new law. In Illinois, Catholic Charities has been driven out of the adoption and foster care business, because it recognizes the unique value of man-woman marriage for the well-being of children. [...]
We also applaud the decision of the House to take up the defense of DOMA in court after DoJ abandoned it, and we urge you to sustain that effort for as long as necessary to obtain definitive confirmation of its constitutionality.
The Catholic Church has led the opposition to same-sex marriage across the country (including fights in California, Maine, New York, and now Minnesota), despite limited support from American Catholics. A recent poll found that just 35 percent of Catholics oppose same-sex marriage and only 16 percent of Catholics say church leaders have “the final say” on homosexuality, down from 32 percent over the past 25 years.
Commonwealth Report Calls On Countries To Abandon Anti-Gay Laws |
A report to British Commonwealth leaders calls for the repeal of anti-gay laws, but “frames the issue as one of disease control, stating such laws ‘impede the effective response of Commonwealth countries to the HIV/AIDS epidemic.” Even the Queen echoed a general call for reforms, saying “I wish heads of government well in agreeing further reforms that respond boldly to the aspirations of today and that keep the Commonwealth fresh and fit for tomorrow.” Forty-one of the 54 Commonwealth countries still criminalize gay sex.
NEWS FLASH
New York Gov. Cuomo Calls On ‘Every State’ To Pass Marriage Equality |
Gov. Andrew Cuomo (D) urged “every state” to follow New York’s example and pass marriage equality, during a gala for the Empire State Pride Agenda last night. “We need marriage equality in every state in this nation. Otherwise, no state really has marriage equality, and we will not rest until it is a reality,” Cuomo said. Watch the NY1 report:
Welcome to The Morning Pride, ThinkProgress LGBT’s 8:45 AM round-up of the latest in LGBT policy, politics, and some culture too! Here’s what we’re reading this morning, but let us know what you’re checking out too. Follow us all day on Twitter at @TPEquality.
- The National Organization for Marriage continues to use disingenuous photos on their New Hampshire anti-equality website. The group has now spent $27,325.22 trying to insert the issue of marriage into an Iowa Senate race.
- Truth Wins Out responds to Linda Harvey’s threat of a law suit: “Bring it on.”
- Chicago businesses are committing to a “T-Friendly Bathroom Initiative,” pledging not to discriminate against a transgender person’s choice of bathroom.
Standing Up for New Hampshire Families — a coalition of New Hampshire residents and business leaders — held a press conference today urging state lawmakers to abandon efforts to repeal the state’s same-sex marriage law and focus on jobs. On Tuesday, the House Judiciary Committee voted along party lines to approve a measure that would eliminate the law and enact civil unions. The full House is expected to take-up the issue in January.
Watch it:
The two separate bills would preserve existing same-sex marriages but replace the law with civil unions for unmarried adults, including relatives. Anyone would be able to discriminate against such couples “in employment, housing and public accommodations based on religious or moral beliefs.” A WMUR Granite State Poll from Oct. 14 found that voters want to keep marriage equality by a two to one margin.
Australian Legislator: Same-Sex Marriage Proponents Are Heterophobic |
As Australian lawmakers debate legalizing same-sex marriage, MP Rob Messenger accused the gay community of oppressing his “tolerant western Christian” point of view and challenged advocates to “explain their heterophobia.” “I will feel discriminated against if gay people, a minority group, try to interfere with my traditional cultural values and impose their own,” he said.
NEWS FLASH
28 Percent Of Audiences Watch LGBT-Inclusive TV Programming | Twenty-eight percent of audiences and advertisers watched programing that included LGBT characters, and such programs represented 24 percent of “broadcast primetime scripted and reality shows last season,” Nielsen is reporting. Interestingly, “LGBT-Inclusive characters were incorporated into shows that skewed towards Eastern and Pacific viewers and were less watched by Midwesterners. This differential was most pronounced among 18-24 year olds in the Midwest, especially when compared to 18-24 year olds in other regions of the U.S.” Look:
Judge Alison Nathan with her family and President Obama
Earlier this month, the Senate confirmed Judge Alison Nathan to a federal judgeship in New York. Shockingly, Nathan is only the third openly gay attorney confirmed to a lifetime appointment on the federal bench, and President Obama is only the second president to place an out judge on the bench.
The lion’s share of Nathan’s confirmation process went without serious controversy. Nathan’s nomination cleared the Senate Judiciary Committee by a lopsided 14-4 vote, and, even in this hyperobstructionist Senate, Republicans agreed not to filibuster Nathan’s nomination and allow her to go straight to a confirmation vote. By the week of the vote, Nathan appeared poised to be confirmed in a walk.
Schumer said he received a “friendly call” from one of his Republican colleagues about 90 minutes before the vote on October 14 to tell him that their conference planned to oppose the nominee uniformly. The senators had received an alert about the nominee from the conservative Heritage Action for America, which scores lawmakers on their votes, and a letter from the Concerned Women for America that took direct aim at Nathan’s sexual orientation.
“Nathan has a long history as political activism with Lesbian Gay Bisexual Transgender (LGBT) which calls into question her impartiality and judicial temperament,” said the letter, which cited her work as a member of the LGBT policy committee for the Obama campaign in 2008, and her pro-bono representation for groups including the ACLU, Lambda Legal, and Servicemembers Legal Defense Network.
So let’s be clear what happened here. Alison Nathan is a brilliant lawyer and former Supreme Court clerk. Half the Republicans on the Judiciary Committee saw no problem with making her a judge. No one in the Republican Caucus objected to giving her an up or down vote on the Senate floor. And then two anti-gay organizations threw tantrum, and the Senate GOP turned on a dime to oppose her.
Husband Of Booed Gay Soldier: I’m ‘Confident’ We’ll Beat DOMA |
Among the plaintiffs in the Servicemembers Legal Defense Network’s suit against the Defense of Marriage Act is Army Captain Steve Hill and his husband Joshua Snyder. Hill was the Iraq-based soldier who asked the Republican presidential candidates about Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell at a debate last month and was booed by audience members. Snyder appeared on MSNBC today to discuss the suit, which calls for same-sex partners to have equal access to military benefits. Watch it:
Lt. Gary Ross explained how DOMA undermines families’ access to medical care during a segment with MSNBC’s Live Nation:
NEWS FLASH
First Openly Gay NBA Player: Homophobia Is A ‘Massive Problem’ In Athletics |
John Amaechi was the first openly gay former NBA player and has just accepted an Officer of the British Empire Medal. Upon receiving it, he condemned homophobia in athletics, which he described as a “massive problem” that is often ignored or “relegated.” He also singled out how little is being done about it in soccer, offering, “If you compare their emphasis on racism to what they’ve done on homophobia, it’s an embarrassment.”
Rosie O’Donnell appeared on MSNBC with Thomas Roberts this afternoon to discuss her new talk show on OWN and how changes in the media may be contributing to the bullying of LGBT youth. Speaking of her now infamous feud with Donald Trump, O’Donnell said she was “pretty shocked on how many stations he was allowed to go on and sort of debase my character, my physical appearance, my femininity, every single thing about me…he was bullying for like seven months,” she said, adding that “some of the 24-hour news networks seemed to take pride in the fact that they bully people.”
“When I was on T.V. …nobody was asking you if you were gay or not. You know, nobody ever asked me in the entire run of my show if I was gay, because it wasn’t part of the social zeitgeist, it wasn’t part of pop culture,” O’Donnell observed. “But then, after I was on a few years, Will and Grace went on the air and that changed everything. And then Ellen came out. You know, it changed. So you have to think that in the 15 years so many things have changed and some parts of the country have not really caught up.” Watch it:
Earlier this month, an audio recording captured an election volunteer for Virginia state Sen. Janet Howell — a Democratic incumbent running for re-election to the state Senate — admitting to “gay-baiting” Republican voters into opposing her openly gay Republican challenger Patrick Forrest. Kavita Imarti, an intoxicated volunteer for Howell, can be heard admitting to Forrest’s field director that the campaign is informing conservative voters of Forrest’s sexuality and claiming that he will push a “homosexual agenda” in schools. “We’re showing your party [is]… prejudiced against someone because of their sexuality,” Imarti shouts on the recording.
Yesterday, reporters asked Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell (R) about the incident during a campaign fundraiser for Forrest. McDonnell responded that Republicans “stand for equal opportunities for all people” and insisted that supporting a gay candidate would not hurt his standing among the party’s more conservative social base:
“I don’t know what she’s doing but I can only say that Patrick and I — and I think all of us in our party — stand for equal opportunities for all people. I think you heard his message about job creation. He’s not focused on divisive social issues. He’s focused on the two things that really matter, getting people back to work and getting our spending and our government under control, and I think that’s what people care about, especially independent voters right now.”
But McDonnell’s own record on issues of “equal rights” is mixed at best. While McDonnell did eventually issue an executive directive prohibiting discrimination “based on factors such as one’s sexual orientation” in state employment, he doesn’t support extending workplace protections to gays and lesbians in the private sector, arguing that “there isn’t really any rampant discrimination on any basis in Virginia.” He also opposes marriage equality and gay and lesbian couples adopting children.
NEWS FLASH
Shorter University’s New ‘Faith Statements’ Ban Gay Employees |
Georgia’s Shorter University, a Southern Baptist college, has adopted new “faith statements,” including a “Personal Lifestyle Statement” all employees must agree to. The statement requires them to “reject as acceptable all sexual activity not in agreement with the Bible, including, but not limited to, premarital sex, adultery and homosexuality” and dictates that they can be fired for violating it.
Mega church leader Joel Osteen reiterated his belief that being gay is a “sin” during an interview with the Washington Post’s Sally Quinn, but said that gay people should still purchase his new book “Everyday a Friday” and learn from its message of empowerment. “They don’t have to let people steal their power, especially all the bullying, things that we see going on with that,” he said. Osteen also suggested gays could be converted:
Somebody that maybe had this certain difficulty now, maybe in five years they’re not if we will love them. You know, I think one of the messages I speak on sometimes is, you know, we can love people back into wholeness. But sometimes we want to beat them down — you got this addiction and you shouldn’t have that, or you did this — I just don’t think that’s the best way.
Watch it:
Osteen said that he would attend a same-sex marriage but wouldn’t officiate it, before adding, “we’re all growing, we’re all changing.” “Somebody who has a certain difficulty now, maybe they won’t in five years. You know, one of the messages I speak to is, you can love people into wholeness.”
Servicemembers And Veterans Challenge Constitutionality Of DOMA |
A group of gay military servicemembers and veterans are filing suit today against the Defense of Marriage Act, highlighting the inequality faced by same-sex partners of those in the military. If plaintiff Massachusetts Army national Guard Maj. Shannon McLaughlin were to be deployed overseas, her wife, Casey, would be barred from taking their 10-month old twins to their regular medical appointments at a nearby military base. Casey also has to pay for a separate healthcare account.
NEWS FLASH
Same-Sex Marriage Not Discussed At Iowa’s Special Senate Seat Debate |
Iowa Republican Cindy Golding and Democrat Liz Mathis — the candidates in Iowa’s special Senate election — squared off in an hour-long candidate forum yesterday that focused on the economy and local issues. But as the forum ended, “one man shouted out that he wanted to know where the candidates stood on same-sex marriage and whether the candidates would support a House-passed resolution to put a constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage on the ballot.” National anti-gay groups like the National Organization for Marriage (NOM) have attempted to insert the issue into the election since a Republican victory would evenly split the balance of power in the senate and pave the way for such a measure. But neither candidate sees the issue as a priority and as forum moderator Todd Dorman noted, “[A]mong the audience questions we got, not one was on the marriage issue.”
Welcome to The Morning Pride, ThinkProgress LGBT’s 8:45 AM round-up of the latest in LGBT policy, politics, and some culture too! Here’s what we’re reading this morning, but let us know what you’re checking out too. Follow us all day on Twitter at @TPEquality.
- The U.S. Agency for International Development will now “strongly encourage” contracting businesses to have non-discrimination policies that protect LGBT workers.
- Rep. Steve King (R-IA) described marriage equality as “an active effort to desecrate a sacrament of the church.”
- A Joplin, MO teacher wrote on Facebook that she doesn’t think enough young people have committed suicide for anti-gay bullying to warrant attention: “11-13 ought to do it. Somewhere in that vicinity.”
- The Human Rights Campaign has attacked the National Organization for Marriage for its crowd photo manipulation, accusing the anti-gay group of sinking to “a new level of deception” and “truly scraping the bottom of the barrel.”
- The Log Cabin Republicans had three Republicans to pick from in the San Diego mayoral race, and they chose to endorse the one who’s not gay.
- AFA’s most pathetic pro-bullying argument yet: New bullying accountability laws require too much paperwork.
- The group Beyond Ex-Gay is looking to hear from ex-gay survivors, individuals who pursued and then abandoned ex-gay therapy. Please fill out their survey if you’ve had this experience.
- The Johnson Family Foundation has awarded almost half of a million dollars to LGBT community centers.
- Rhode Island Bishop Thomas Tobin says that gays should be treated with “the same respect and love as every other child of God,” then sentences later calls for the condemnation and disapproval of their sinful “lifestyle.”
- A Denver transgender girl was refused acceptance to her local Girl Scout troop, but the Girl Scouts of Colorado have clarified it was a mistake and she is welcome to participate.
Illinois Republican Senators Unanimously Support Discrimination Against Same-Sex Couples |
The Civil Rights Agenda (CRA), an Illinois-based group, has indicated that every Republican in the Illinois Senate has co-sponsored SB 2495, a bill solely designed to empower religious groups like Catholic Charities to discriminate against same-sex couples in civil unions when providing adoption and foster care services. In a press release, CRA executive director Anthony Martinez explains, “As a non-partisan organization it becomes increasingly difficult to appeal to Republican ideals when the party is seemingly hostile towards the LGBT community. This is a hollow political move that could have dire consequences for LGBT people.”