ThinkProgress Logo

Yglesias

Edwards Versus Petraeus

General Petraeus says we’ll be in Iraq for years. John Edwards fired back this morning:

“General Petraeus’ comments are just the latest example of the Bush Administration’s disconnect from the reality on the ground. In order to get the Iraqi people to take responsibility for their country, we must show them that we are serious about leaving, and the best way to do that is to actually start leaving. Instead of talking about keeping our troops in Iraq for another decade, the Administration should begin bringing our troops home to the hero’s welcome they deserve.

I’m not entirely sure how this fits into the residual forces debate but Edwards does seem to be at least playing footsie with the idea of differentiating himself on this issue.

Yglesias

Purity Ball Fun

This really creeps me out.

Jessica Valenti notes in particular “the creepy pseudo-incestuous dad” and “the girls offering themselves ‘as a priceless gift’ in the purity pledge” as particular highlights. Personally, my favorite was a part where someone suggested that “purity” was the way to go because if you get involved in sex and dating and so forth there’s a risk of broken hearts. Tennyson sheds a tear.

My recollection is that, for better or for worse, studies indicate that this sort of thing doesn’t actually result in the women who make the “purity” pledges actually saving it for marriage.

Security

Snow: ‘I Don’t Know’ If Iraq War Has Helped Stabilize Middle East, It’s ‘Hard To Say’

In November, months before President Bush announced the troop escalation, Jordan’s King Abdullah predicted that three civil wars could erupt in the Middle East in 2007. “We’re juggling with the strong potential of three civil wars in the region, whether it’s the Palestinians, that of Lebanon or of Iraq,” he said.

With the eruption of violence recently in Lebanon and Gaza, Abdullah’s prediction has manifested into a bloody reality.

During today’s press briefing, CNN correspondent Ed Henry asked White House spokesman Tony Snow whether the “war in Iraq has helped push the peace process forward in any way.” Snow’s response: “Don’t know. … Hard to say.” Echoing his claim last week attacks in Iraq were “signs of success,” Snow suggested that the increased violence in the region is a by-product of “pro-democracy movements…making some progress.” Watch it:

[flv http://video.thinkprogress.org/2007/06/snowmideast.320.240.flv]

But the White House’s uncertainty marks a stark departure from Bush’s confidence in the early stages of the war. In July 2003, Bush stated:

A free Iraq will not destabilize the Middle East. A free Iraq can set a hopeful example to the entire region and lead other nations to choose freedom. And as the pursuits of freedom replace hatred and resentment and terror in the Middle East, the American people will be more secure.

Yesterday on CBS’ Face the Nation, Iraq Study Group co-chair Lee Hamilton offered a very different take than Snow. “The Middle East is in flames,” Hamilton said. “Everywhere you look, there’s deep trouble — Iraq, Lebanon, the Palestinians, the peace process, Iran.” Asked whether the instability was linked to the war, Hamilton replied, “Of course they’re linked.”

Transcript: Read more

Politics

Escalation architect Fred Kagan

two months ago, on how Iraq was “turning the corner.”

The new effort to establish security in Iraq has begun. At this early stage, the most positive development is a rise in hostility to al-Qaida in the Sunni community. … [O]n balance, there is reason for wary optimism. … The most that can be said now is that we seem to be turning a corner.

Fred Kagan now: “More Time Needed.”

Kagan recommended waiting until the end of the year before judging the operation’s success. Even then, he added, it might be some months before Iraqis make the political compromises necessary to bring lasting stability to the country.

Climate Progress

Who Killed the Electric Car?

electric-car-2.jpg

[Hint -- the killer has the initials G.M.]

Celsias has posted the whole movie (at least until Sony makes them take it down). It is well worth watching — and not just because I make an appearance to explain the “five miracles” needed for hydrogen cars to succeed.

General Motors is still operating under the delusion that “GM would have a ‘cost-effective’ fuel cell car by 2010.” A “cost-effective” fuel cell car is like “victory” in Iraq — a difficult concept to define in theory and essentially impossible to achieve in practice.

Fortunately, GM is pursuing plug-in hybrids, so at least somebody in the company has a clue.

Politics

Parts of the White House evacuated

after K-9 units pick up a suspicious scent, several news sources are reporting.

UPDATE: The AP notes that it was a “bomb scare.” Security in the area was “heightened because of the visit to Washington of Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert.”

Politics

Blair feared U.S. would ‘nuke the sh*t’ out of Afghans.

“Britain joined the United States’ invasion to oust the Taliban in 2001 because it feared America would ‘nuke the shit’ out of Afghanistan, the former British ambassador to Washington reportedly told a television documentary to be screened Saturday.”

Christopher Meyer said that fear explained why Prime Minister Tony Blair chose to stand with US President George W. Bush in his decision to invade Afghanistan in the immediate aftermath of the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks — to temper his aggressive battle plans.

Blair’s real concern was that there would be quote unquote ‘a knee-jerk reaction’ by the Americans … they would go thundering off and nuke the shit out of the place without thinking straight,” Meyer reported told the documentary, according to the Mirror.

Yglesias

Surge No Matter What

That surge architect Fred Kagan thinks the surge’s failure to deliver results merely proves the need to take more time with the surge is unsurprising. The end of the article, however, is striking. Kagan, according to Time‘s Michael Duffy, “fears a significant increase in Iranian support for those fighting U.S. forces. Finally, he noted that the shaky government of Nouri al-Maliki could just implode.”

While that might not end the cause of progress in Iraq, Kagan said, it could lead to something worse for those who believed a surge would lead to a stabilization of Iraq: a breakdown in political support for the war effort in Washington.

In other words, according to Kagan even the total collapse of the Iraqi government wouldn’t, in his mind, demonstrate that the war had failed. Even under those circumstances he’s going to stick to the stab in the back story that the only problem is the collapse of political support for the war here in DC.

Media

CPAC 2007: The Unauthorized Documentary

Max Blumenthal’s short documentary based on his visit to CPAC 2007 was shown at the opening of a panel I’m attending here at Take Back America and whaddaya know but it’s on YouTube.

Funny! I need to find a way to make some decent multimedia one day.

Older

Newer

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up