ThinkProgress Logo

Security

Brewer Announces She Is Countersuing The Government For Failing ‘To Protect Arizona From Invasion’

Last year, the U.S. federal government filed a lawsuit challenging Arizona’s new immigration law, SB-1070, on the grounds that it “usurps federal authority.” In late July, a federal district court judge enjoined several major provisions of Arizona’s immigration law, arguing that “the United States is likely to succeed on the merits in showing that…[they] are preempted by federal law” and the “United States is likely to suffer irreparable harm” in the absence of an injunction.

Today, Gov. Jan Brewer (R-AZ) announced that she is filing a countersuit against the federal government on behalf of the state of Arizona. The countersuit names several counts, including a “failure to protect Arizona from invasion.” KPHO reports:

Brewer and state Attorney General Tom Horne outlined five counts in a counterclaim filed in the government’s lawsuit against Arizona:

  • The Department of Homeland Security has failed to achieve and maintain operational control for the Arizona/Mexico border as required under the Secure Fence Act of 2006
  • The federal government has failed to live up to its Constitutional duty to protect Arizona against invasion and domestic violence
  • The federal government has failed to enforce and follow immigration laws
  • The federal government has failed to compensate states for the substantial economic burdens suffered as a result of the failure to incarcerate or deport criminal aliens
  • The federal government has prevented Arizona from enforcing its own laws for illegal immigration. The state is seeking an injunction under this count
  • Brewer reportedly claimed that the federal government has failed to protect the “citizens of Arizona.” “We did not ask for this fight. We did not start this fight,” Brewer said at today’s news conference announcing the lawsuit. “We will not rest until our border is secure and the laws are enforced,” she said.

    Usually, referring to the high levels of illegal immigration the country has been experiencing as an “invasion” has been relegated to right-wing chat boards and other xenophobic forums. The term itself suggests conquest and plunder by a foreign enemy. Of course, no rational person would claim that the U.S. or the state of Arizona is currently confronting that scenario — unless they happen to have a problem with the population of poor, brown immigrants who came to the U.S. to build a better future for their families.

    The suit comes just a few short weeks after Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Secretary Janet Napolitano urged politicians to stop exaggerating the levels of violence occurring on the U.S. side of the border with Mexico. She also recently noted the significant strides the Obama administration has made in securing the border, stating, “the additional manpower, technology and resources represent the most serious and sustained action to secure our border in our nation’s history…it is clear from every key measure that this approach is working.” Last year, the U.S. deported a record breaking number of undocumented immigrants. The country’s border cities are among the safest in the nation and DHS has been prioritizing going after undocumented immigrants who pose a threat to public safety.

    Brewer claims that taxpayer money will not be used to fund the suit. Apparently, money from a private fund will pay the costs. Yet taxpayers will have to pay for it because the taxpayer-funded federal government will have to defend itself against this ridiculously unnecessary lawsuit.

    Alyssa

    Another Road Through China

    As yet another entry in the West’s attempts to figure out how China fits into our movies, be it as a replacement archenemy to fill the void left behind by the Soviet Union or as a land ripe for saving by dashing Westerners played by Christian Bale, I’ve been curious about the slow development of Snow and the Seven. The project’s been under discussion since 2002, and it’s (obviously) a retelling of Snow White and the Seven Dwarves, a historical drama about an Englishwoman who discovers her Hong Kong-based stepmother (duh) means her all sorts of unpleasantness and flees to mainland China and takes up with a band of seven warriors. Now, apparently, one of Toy Story 3‘s writers is working on the script.

    I was not wildly impressed by Toy Story 3‘s gender politics, even while thinking it was one of the better movies I saw in 2010. The treatment of Barbie and Ken was certainly of a piece with the fact that the toys have some origins in their making, but they were still sort of troubling, especially the treatment of Ken as either gay or insufficiently masculine. So I’m sort of curious to see what happens with this story. Snow is supposed to learn a few tricks of her own. Will this be a cliche story of girl-learns-things-from-dudely mentors? Another instance of Westerners becoming better at martial arts than the crafts’ originators? Or the movie I suspect a lot of us have been waiting for since Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon? That movie’s originality was so refreshing, I tend to think of it as a more emotionally engaged Inception. And the rage between the female characters was just beautifully done:

    I’d really like to see Snow White and her grandmother actually have it out.

    Economy

    EXCLUSIVE: US Chamber’s Lobbyists Solicited Hackers To Sabotage Unions, Smear Chamber’s Political Opponents

    ThinkProgress has learned that a law firm representing the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, the big business trade association representing ExxonMobil, AIG, and other major international corporations, is working with set of “private security” companies and lobbying firms to undermine their political opponents, including ThinkProgress, with a surreptitious sabotage campaign.

    According to e-mails obtained by ThinkProgress, the Chamber hired the lobbying firm Hunton and Williams. Hunton And Williams’ attorney Richard Wyatt, who once represented Food Lion in its infamous lawsuit against ABC News, was hired by the Chamber in October of last year. To assist the Chamber, Wyatt and his associates, John Woods and Bob Quackenboss, solicited a set of private security firms — HBGary Federal, Palantir, and Berico Technologies (collectively called Team Themis) — to develop tactics for damaging progressive groups and labor unions, in particular ThinkProgress, the labor coalition called Change to Win, the SEIU, US Chamber Watch, and StopTheChamber.com.

    According to one document prepared by Team Themis, the campaign included an entrapment project. The proposal called for first creating a “false document, perhaps highlighting periodical financial information,” to give to a progressive group opposing the Chamber, and then to subsequently expose the document as a fake to undermine the credibility of the Chamber’s opponents. In addition, the group proposed creating a “fake insider persona” to “generate communications” with Change to Win. View a screenshot below:

    The security firms hoped to obtain $200,000 for initial background research, then charge up to $2 million for a larger disinformation campaign against progressives. We don’t know if the proposal was accepted after Phase 1 was completed.

    The e-mails ThinkProgress acquired are available widely on the web. They were posted by members of “Anonymous,” the hactivist community responsible for taking down websites for oppressive regimes in Tunisia, Egypt, and American corporations that have censored WikiLeaks. Anonymous published the emails from HBGary Federal because an executive at the firm, Aaron Barr, was trying to take Anonymous down. Barr claimed that he had penetrated Anonymous and was hoping to sell the data to Bank of America and to federal authorities in the United States. In response, members of Anonymous hacked into Barr’s email and published some 40,000 company e-mails.

    It is widely believed that Wikileaks has sensitive information about Bank of America, and plans to expose it later this year. This revelation prompted Bank of America to hire the law/lobbying firm Hunton and Williams, which in turn, according to the e-mails posted online by Anonymous, hired HBGary Federal and other firms to go after Anonymous and supporters of Wikileaks. For instance, one proposal from HBGary Federal and its associates proposed targeting Salon reporter and Wikileaks-supporter Glenn Greenwald with “actions to sabotage or discredit” him.

    ThinkProgress has published a series of articles investigating the Chamber and its activities. We exposed the Chamber’s efforts to coordinate a lobbying campaign on behalf of large banks, including JP Morgan, to kill significant portions of financial reform. In October, we published a series looking into the Chamber’s efforts to solicit donations from foreign corporations for the same account the Chamber used to run partisan attack ads during the midterm campaign, as well as the Chamber’s participation in secret fundraising meetings convened by the billionaire plutocrats David and Charles Koch.

    ThinkProgress will be posting more details of the Chamber lobbyist campaign to target progressives soon.

    – With reporting from Scott Keyes

    Update

    The Chamber has yet to respond to an inquiry from ThinkProgress. We’ll update the post if we receive a response.


    Update

    ,The Chamber responds on its blog by dismissing the emails as “baseless attacks” from ThinkProgress.


    Update

    ,Commenting on the leaked documents, Marcy Wheeler writes that they’re probably “going to cause the Chamber of Commerce to rethink the spying work with HBGary it apparently has been considering.”

    Yglesias

    The Specter of Inflation

    From Annie Lowrey’s excellent profile of Ron Paul’s monetary economics:

    When I asked Paul about this, he maintained the Fed has set us up for a currency crisis down the road. “It won’t be as bad as Zimbabwe,” he says. “But perhaps something like 1979 or 1980.” He noted that geopolitical events often kick of economic ones. “The revolutions in the Middle East, that could end up being the precipitating event,” he said. “Tunisia, Egypt—they may well tumble.”

    From David Leonhardt:

    Even better than look at current core inflation, nowadays we can look at the TIPS spread and measure market expectations of inflation over the next ten years:

    The market thinks Paul is really wrong. Lowrey quotes him complaining that the Fed “sticks it to the people who want to save and make money. It is so unfair.” But there’s nothing stopping Paul or any other inflation-averse savers from investing in inflation protected securities (TIPS) that pay a guaranteed interest rate over and above the inflation rate. Indeed, if Paul’s right he and his followers will be able to make a killing in this market.

    LGBT

    Pawlenty: Opposition To Same-Sex Marriage Is A ‘Universal’ Value ‘Embedded In Our Culture’

    Tomorrow, former Minnesota Governor Tim Pawlenty (R) will address CPAC. On Monday, he was brandishing his conservative credentials by appearing at a forum in Iowa sponsored by The Family Leader, a conservative group spearheading the repeal same-sex-marriage campaign in Iowa. Pawlenty repeatedly emphasized his Christian faith during the event, even going so far as to suggest that his opposition to expanding marriage to gays and lesbians was a “universal” value that was “embedded in our culture”:

    REPORTER: Is it appropriate for policy to be driven by values that are not necessarily shared by everyone, yet have a very significant effect on everyone?

    PAWLENTY: Well, these values that come from God and that our county was founded on, even if you personally…doesn’t necessarily codify them in their religion, these are universal values not based on some mythical idea but it’s based on things like we’re going to make sure we respect life, we’re going to make sure we respect traditional marriage. We’re going to make sure we’re going to promote not discourage parenting…So I don’t think those values ore demeaning or disrespectful to somebody else’s religion. These are values that are embedded in our culture, our society, they have been for a long time and they’re appropriate subjects for public debate and discourse.

    Watch it:

    Ironically, by refusing to recognize same-sex relationships and families — and by specifically advocating for legislation that would take away these protections from families in Iowa — Pawlenty is discouraging parenting and families. He’s also disrespecting the many denominations of Christianity — Evangelical Lutherans, Unitarian Universalists and Episcopalians — who recognize same-sex couples.

    Yglesias

    Let Airports Be Airports

    I’m basically in agreement with Atrios on the question of intercity rail. One thing I do want to add to the conversation, however, is that better intercity rail connections could free up some valuable airport space.

    The DC metro area, for example, is served by three airports. One of them, DCA, is much more centrally located than the other two but it’s also smaller and because it’s centrally located it can’t really be expanded. That airport features six daily flights to Pittsburgh, 245 miles away. There are also four flights per day from Dulles, and three flights per day from BWI. Clearly, there’s a lot of demand for going to Pittsburgh. Were there a high-quality DC-Pittsburg rail connection, many of these air trips would instead be done by train. And were that the case, then airport space—particularly the scarce space at DCA—would be reallocated to flights to destinations that really need a plane to get to. Portland or Los Angeles or Miami or what have you. This isn’t number one on my list of American problems, but it really isn’t ideal to have so much of our airport capacity sucked up by these relatively short trips. There are large classes of travel for which there’s no good alternative to an airplane and in an ideal world the vast majority of flights would be on routes like that.

    What’s more, there’s a decent chance that jet fuel is going to become prohibitively expensive at some point in the future and then we’ll really be sorry if we’re stuck relying on planes for 200-400 miles trips.

    Politics

    GOP Lawmaker Tells Republicans To ‘Put Up Or Shut Up’ On Health Care Law

    After blindly voting to repeal the health care law last month, several GOP lawmakers are waking up to the actual consequences of their vote. The Washington Post’s Greg Sargent caught another GOP lawmaker, Rep. Richard Hanna (NY), questioning the party rhetoric. Going “way off the national Republican Party’s message” in an interview with the Auburn Citizen, Hanna dismissed the health care repeal as “ceremonial.” Noting that Republicans have “complained for two years” without offering “viable” alternatives, he called on the GOP to finally “put up or shut up” on health care:

    HANNA: I didn’t like the format. But those were the votes. That was the opportunity I was given. I had to vote up or down. So the idea to repeal it without reforming what is already here is not something I look forward to. But they did that…This in many ways was looked at as kind of a ceremonial vote. Because let’s face it, the Senate isn’t going to approve it, and the President of course isn’t. They’ve complained for two years about this health care bill. They’ve offered alternatives, but they’re not alternatives that are in many ways viable. Well, now they have to put up the goods. They have to say “here’s what we’re presenting, here’s why it will work…Let’s see what they do. I say give them a chance. Let the Republican party put up or shut up.

    Watch it:

    GOP Rep. Sean Duffy (WI) expressed the same concerns, recently admitting that “I wasn’t gonna vote for” the repeal until leadership assured him it’d be replaced with “our ideas.” However, as the Wonk Room’s Igor Volsky notes, if the GOP offers the health care ideas that they pledged to, they will basically be reinstating the exact law they voted to repeal last month.

    Health

    GOP Cuts Eliminate $1.3 Billion From Community Health Centers They Once Considered ‘Essential’

    Yesterday, in an effort to make good on their election promise to significantly reduce federal spending, Republicans on the House Appropriations Committee released a preliminary plan of specific cuts that would result in a “9% reduction in nondefense, discretionary spending from 2010.” The proposal makes significant reductions to health care programs, including $1 billion from the national institutes of health, $327 million from Title X, and $210 million from Maternal and Child Health Block Grants.

    Surprisingly, Republicans would also eliminate $1.3 billion from community health centers — which provide much needed care to rural and undeserved communities. The programs were expanded by former President George W. Bush (and Obama) and have previously been described as “essential” by Appropriations Committee Chairman Hal Rogers (R-KY). In fact, his website is littered with press releases touting new federal funds for CHCs in his district:

    – U.S. Congressman Hal Rogers (KY-05) announced today that the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) has awarded $100,000 to Grace Community Health Center….”"Grace Community Health Center serves those who are most in need and will use this funding to help improve the quality of life for those with little to no access to health care. This investment in Clay and Knox counties improves the well-being and health of the local community.” [State News Service, 9/17/2010]

    – U.S. Congressman Harold “Hal” Rogers (KY-05) announced today that the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) has awarded Morehead State University (MSU) with a $235,620 Rural Health Care Grant…“This is great news for the people of Martin County,” said Rogers. “By providing new resources to focus on preventative health care, the community will now be better equipped to address the health care problems that have plagued our region for far too long.” [Press Release, 10/17/2009]

    – U.S. Congressman Harold “Hal” Rogers announced today that the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) has awarded Health Help, Inc. with a $1,433,244 Rural Health Care Grant…”This Rural Health Care Grant program ensures medical care is available to seniors, children, and low-income families,” said Rogers. “In these challenging economic times, rural health care clinics are now more than ever an essential part of the health care safety net in our region and this investment in Jackson County will aid in continuing these important services.” [Press Release, 5/18/2009]

    “If this cut were to be approved, it would mean that America’s health centers will lose the capacity to serve 11 million patients over the next year, with well over 3.3 million current patients losing their care within the next few months,” Tom Van Coverden, president and CEO of the National Association of Community Health Centers, said in a statement.“That is equivalent to terminating all healthcare to the entire population of Chicago, or to everyone living in the states of Wyoming, Vermont, North and South Dakota, and Alaska combined,” Van Coverden said.

    Indeed, this kind of disinvestment could also translate to serious job losses on the local level. Economists estimated that the additional $2 billion investment in CHCs from the stimulus package generated $3.2 billion of economic activity in 2009, with health centers creating approximately $20 billion in economic activity for the communities where they are located.” Health centers directly employ people in their communities, including key entry-level jobs, training, and other community-based opportunities. The clinics also purchase goods and services from local businesses and expand and build new locations. That’s why members of both parties embrace these centers and will have a hard time in actually voting for their elimination.

    Yglesias

    Let Obama Be Obama!

    I’m not usually a fan of “prisoner of the staff” type arguments, but reading this LA Times account of an Obama administration divided between advocates of pressing for change in Egypt (Ben Rhodes and Samantha Power) and those who prefer a more modest approach (Hillary Clinton and Robert Gates) I can’t help but notice something.

    There were good reasons to keep Robert Gates on as Secretary of Defense. And there were good reasons to make Hillary Clinton Secretary of State. But an odd consequence of the move was to leave surprisingly little room on the team for people such as Rhodes and Power who were Obama suporters from the get-go. This is a strange state of affairs on the subject where the president has the most autonomy from congress and also where policy preferences are least determined by partisan coalitions. I was an Obama supporter from way back primarily because of his statements and records on foreign policy issues, and now here we are faced with a real split between that original vision and the views of the national security establishment. I think this is an issue where the perceived interests of the permanent security elite diverge from those of most Americans and Obama would do well to listen to the Obama-ists on his team.

    Climate Progress

    Charles Krauthammer: Global warming is a “religion”

    Washington Post columnist catches Gore Derangement Syndrome

    Look, if Godzilla appeared on the Mall this afternoon, Al Gore would say it’s global warming, because the spores in the South Atlantic Ocean, you know, were. Look, everything is, it’s a religion. In a religion, everything is explicable. In science, you can actually deny or falsify a proposition with evidence. You find me a single piece of evidence that Al Gore would ever admit would contradict global warming and I’ll be surprised.

    That would be Washington Post columnist Charles Krauthammer, who like his colleague George Will, is a climate science denier.  Of course, it is Krauthammer and Will whose denial can never be falsified because it isn’t actually based on science, but rather ideology (see Krauthammer: The real reason conservatives don’t believe in climate science and below).

    The scientific literature is clear that indeed global warming will cause more snow “” especially in warm years (see “An amazing, though clearly little-known, scientific fact: We get more snow storms in warm years!“).  Indeed, the U.S. Global Change Research Program (USGCRP) U.S. Climate Impacts Report from 2009 reviewed that literature and concluded:

    Cold-season storm tracks are shifting northward and the strongest storms are likely to become stronger and more frequent.

    But because Krauthammer doesn’t have the most basic understanding of climate science — more warming means more water vapor in the atmosphere available for more intense storms — he not only labels all of climate science a religion, he falls victim to the full Gore Derangement Syndrome that has infected conservatives like they’re in some sort of zombie apocalypse (see Stop the madness: Mark Kirk, a U.S. Senator, blames his climate flip-flop on “¦ Al Gore’s personal life).

    UPDATE:  Some commenters seem to think January saw record-breaking cold for the entire nation or glob.  Globally, NASA reports that January was tied for 10th warmest January on record (see here).  January 2011 was more than 0.1 C warmer than the average January temperature in the 1990s.

    And it wasn’t even the coldest U.S. January in 20 years — January 1994 was colder, according to NOAA’s National Climatic Data Center.  Since record highs and record lows are set pretty much every day, regular readers know I prefer the statistical aggregation across the country, since it gets us beyond the oft-repeated point that you can’t pin any one daily record temperature in one city on global warming.

    As CapitalClimate reported last week “preliminary data for January from the National Climatic Data Center indicate that, for the U.S. as a whole, record high temperatures actually exceeded record low temperatures.”  The long-term statistical trend is unmistakeable (see “Record high temperatures far outpace record lows across U.S.“):

    Read more

    Older

    Newer

    Switch to Mobile
    ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

    Sign Up