ThinkProgress Logo

Health

Group Opposed To Birth Control Mandate Compares Contraception to Seafood, Red Wine

During last week’s “utterly surreal” hearings on contraception, Reverend William Lori equated requiring religiously-affiliated institutions to provide birth control with mandating a Kosher deli to serve pork.

The analogy—along with the rest of the hearing—was widely ridiculed. And yet on Tuesday, the House Judiciary Committee held a hearing of its own on birth control only to field another food-based comparison. Faith in Public Life flags the exchange between Asma Uddin, an attorney from the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, and Chairman Lamar Smith (R-TX):

SMITH: What are other examples, what else could the government force religious organizations to provide if this mandate were to remain in effect as is unchanged.

UDDIN: Well, I mean, this mandate has been justified on the basis of the fact that there’s health benefits to providing contraceptives. But the issue of health benefits is not the point. If the government mandated everything that had positive health benefits, it could possibly mandate that everyone drink red wine for heart health even though it violates the religious beliefs of Muslims and Mormons. And it could mandate that everyone eat shellfish even though that violates the religious beliefs of Jews.

Watch it:

The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty is a group that represents several religiously-affiliated colleges and organizations. There are several problems with the point Uddin was trying to make, however. For starters, the bill does not require people to consume anything. At best, if we stick to the restaurant analogy, the law would ask restaurants that refuse to serve red wine to at least have a Bring Your Own Bottle policy, or to be more precise, the alcohol would be delivered from across the street.

Of course, that’s far from the only point. Religious institutions like denominational colleges and universities service many nonreligious individuals who would be negatively impacted by their inability to easily access contraception because of the school’s refusal to cover birth control on religious grounds. Under the new rule, since Catholic colleges aren’t required to provide birth control coverage, the women who do want to use the benefit will receive it directly from their insurance company.

NEWS FLASH

Ninth Circuit Opens Misconduct Review On Judge Who Sent Racist, Anti-Obama Email | The Judicial Council of the 9th Circuit will conduct a formal misconduct hearing into Chief Judge Richard Cebull’s decision to email a racist joke about President Obama’s mother having sex with a dog. According to the Ninth Circuit, Cebull initiated the inquiry. Additionally, Cebull told Rep. Denny Rehberg (R-MT) that he will formally apologize to the president.

NEWS FLASH

Sandra Fluke Responds To Limbaugh: ‘This language is an attack on all women’ | Rush Limbaugh devoted much of his three-hour radio show today and yesterday to sexist ad hominin attacks on Sanda Fluke, the Georgetown Law student whom House Republicans didn’t let testify at last week’s contraception hearing. Limbaugh unleashed a thesaurus of sexist slurs at Fluke to his 15 million listeners, and now Fluke is speaking up. She released this statement:

We are fortunate to live in a democracy where everyone is entitled to their own opinions regarding legitimate policy differences. Unfortunately, numerous commentators have gone far beyond the acceptable bounds of civil discourse.

No woman deserves to be disrespected in this manner. This language is an attack on all women, and has been used throughout history to silence our voices.

The millions of American women who have and will continue to speak out in support of women’s health care and access to contraception prove that we will not be silenced.

NEWS FLASH

Lesbian Who Was Denied Communion Says Episode Has ‘Strengthened My Faith In The Church’ | Barbara Johnson said she was “stunned” when a Catholic priest denied her communion at her own mother’s funeral because she was a lesbian living “a sin” and told CNN this afternoon that the now infamous episode “felt unreal.” The priest also walked out in the middle of Johnson’s eulogy to her mother. The Archdiocese of Washington has apologized for the episode and admitted that the preist — Father Marcel Guarnizo — followed improper protocol. Interestingly, Johnson claims that the outpouring of support she received from within the Church and other Catholics has actually “strengthened my faith in the Church itself.” Watch Johnson talk about the experience:

Climate Progress

Leaders Ask Why We’re Exporting Fossil Fuels Without Considering American Security First

By Jessica Goad, Manager of Research and Outreach, Center for American Progress Action Fund.

The “battle over energy exports is intensifying” and at the same time we have no coherent national export policy were the primary takeaways from an event called “Power Play:  Fossil Fuels and U.S. Export Strategy” held this morning at the Center for American Progress Action Fund.  Coal, refined petroleum products from tar sands, and natural gas are currently being exported to hungry overseas markets, and the event was designed to look at the implications of these decisions.

Panelists Senator Ron Wyden (D-OR) and Congressman Ed Markey (D-MA)  bemoaned the fact that the United States does not have a national strategy on exports.  Wyden accused the country of being “on autopilot” to an energy export policy, which could have tremendous economic, social, and environmental consequences.  He expanded:

So I have been somebody who’s been expansionist on trade and think that we ought to have freer trade, have fairer trade, but we also need to have smarter trade.  And allowing energy producers—we haven’t really touched on this—to trade away our international competitiveness and our energy independence by exporting the resources right now without thinking through the implications here of what it means for consumers and our companies doesn’t strike me as a smart trade policy.

Watch it:

 

As the price of natural gas continues to plummet, pressure to export it as liquefied natural gas has increased, and last year the U.S. was a net exporter of refined petroleum products for the first time since 1949.  As well, the coal industry is preparing to significantly increase exports of American coal overseas.  In response to these trends, the members detailed four critical areas that could be impacted by exports, which they believe need more careful consideration:  domestic energy, national security, consumer prices, and environmental impacts.

A second panel addressed different perspectives on coal exports.  Panelists represented the energy finance industry, Pacific Northwest residents impacted by coal export traffic and terminals, landowners concerned about the impacts of mining, and a labor and environmental alliance.

Markey, who released a report at the event entitled “Drill Here, Sell There, Pay More,” summed up the need for serious thinking on exports by saying:

We should first decide what we want to do for the United States of America.

Justice

Sheriff Joe’s Birther Squad Concludes Obama’s Birth Certificate Is A ‘Forgery And Fraud’

Joe Arpaio, the Arizona Sheriff who has drawn the interest of Republican presidential candidates and federal criminal prosecutors alike, revealed the results of his months-long investigation into President Obama’s birth certificate today and concluded that the document is mostly likely forged. The Maricopa County Sheriff even has a “person of interest,” though he refused to reveal the name. “A fraud has been committed,” Arpaio’s volunteer chief investigator warned. “The document is fake.”

In a lengthy and delirious press conference that relied on a mix of pseudo-science and innuendo, Arpaio and his dower band of volunteer investigators rolled out a series of films that depict documents being Xeroxed and scanned into Adobe software to supposedly show that someone forged Obama’s birth certificate. “This is serious. This is very serious,” the investigator said. The probe was apparently also aided by serial fabulist Jerome Corsi, of the birther-obsessed website WorldNetDaily.

At the close of the event, Arpaio acknowledged that many would see his investigation as “silly, pointless, trite,” but said, “I hope that maybe you’ll have a change of opinion.”

However, Arpaio and his “posse” not only expect Americans to believe that the president forged his birth certificate, but that he did a really terrible job of it. Apraio’s posse uncovered so many apparent errors hiding in plain sight that it seems impossible no one would have found them before.

Arpaio was careful to say he is not accusing the president of breaking the law, but said there is “enough evidence to support probable cause.” He’s considering calling for a Congressional investigation or other law enforcement probe. A Republican state lawmaker was even on hand the lend his credibility, and said several of his colleagues were also interested in perusing the matter.

Perhaps this is not surprising from a man embroiled in so many scandals that there’s a 6,000 word Wikipedia article dedicated to “Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office controversies.” Some will say that Arpaio should probably be using his office’s taxpayer-funded resources to investigate the hundreds of child sex-crimes that he and his deputies neglected, but that’s a matter for Maricopa County voters.

What’s more troubling is that so many mainstream Republicans, especially those running president, have been so eager to associate themselves with Arpaio.

Alyssa

Ten Women Major Magazines Should Be Commissioning

Mac McClelland is a female reporter, who is more than capable of doing the same work as her male counterparts.

In keeping with our conversation on Tuesday about the pathetically small number of pieces by women published in major American magazines, I thought I’d move beyond frustration to solutions. If it’s so hard for editors (and as many readers pointed out, who’s commissioning and editing is critically important to who gets commissioned and published) to find female writers who have the chops to get major magazine assignments, I’ll offer up 10. These are just a few of the wildly talented women out there that major magazines would benefit from publishing on a regular basis, and their subscribers would benefit from reading. And you don’t need to stick them in a lady-issues slot, either:

1. Mac McClelland: I said it last year, and I’ll say it again. Someone should send Mother Jones’ awesome investigative reporter out on the road with a dude movie star to send back awesome—and non-flirtatious—reports from the road. That, or ship her off to a war zone. Either way, McClelland would turn in an account that’s deeply reportered and wildly entertaining to read.

2. Irin Carmon: The Salon reporter’s turned in everything from ferocious reports on the wide array of measures conservative lawmakers have been pushing to limit women’s access to reproductive health care to seminal essays on the enduring cultural legacy of Dirty Dancing. And she’s proven she can do everything from Jezebel-style blogging to substantial reporting, which is all editors who need to fill the front of the book, the back of the book, and the feature well should need to know.

3. Amanda Hess and Tracy Clark-Flory: Periodically, a major magazine will decide it wants to get a little edgy and profile a porn star or a porn entrepreneur. Sometimes, they’ll even assign a woman to do it, like when Vanessa Grigoriadis hung out with Sasha Grey at the beginning of her transition from pornography to mainstream movies for a Rolling Stone profile. But she’s not the only woman who can write these kinds of pieces. Magazines who want to get erudite about the adult industry should consider Hess and Clark-Flory, both of whom cover porn as a core part of their beats.

4. Willa Paskin: Okay, she already shows up in the pages of New York Magazine, so it’s not like Paskin’s a stranger to the national magazine circuit. But more publications should be putting her gimlet eye for pop culture and ability to break down why a show or movie works—or just as often, doesn’t—on a large scale. Maybe a weekend in Los Angeles with the Sisters Deschanel? Just sayin’.

5. Charlie Jane Anders: The only writer on this list who could write for the fiction section of your magazine as well as turn in reviews, the managing editor of io9 should be your go-to gal for all things science and science fiction. And because she runs the San Francisco-based Writers With Drinks series, she could probably hook you up with a whole other range of talented writers to fill your pages.
Read more

Health

GOP Asks Sebelius If She Supports Forced Sterilization ‘As A Condition Of Citizenship’

Republicans were not willing to let go of the contraception debate during this morning’s House Energy and Commerce Committee hearing with HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius. The GOP misconstrued the administration’s contraception coverage requirement as an attack on religious liberty and argued that Catholic institutions would be required to offer birth control. During a particularly strange exchange, Rep. Mike Burgess (R-TX) even asked Sebelius if she supports requiring sterilization as a condition of citizenship:

BURGESS: If a state required sterilization as a condition of citizenship, would you be required to do that on the federal level?

SEBELIUS: Sir, I’m not going to answer that question.

Watch it:

Climate Progress

Gas Price Facts: Domestic Oil Production Is At Eight-Year High

As international tensions and Wall Street speculation move the national gas price average closer to $4, Republicans have charged that Obama is “intentionally” raising prices. Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX) said the “single biggest obstacle to greater domestic energy production is the Obama administration.”

But, as Business Insider’s Joe Weisenthal points out, attacks that claim we’re “not expanding our domestic energy capacity” like Cornyn’s “couldn’t be more misguided.”

With gas price misinformation everywhere, a few facts on oil production stand out:

– Under the Obama administration, domestic energy production is at its highest level in eight years.

– The U.S. has more oil and natural gas drilling rigs than the rest of the world. The number of rigs have exploded in the past three years to 1,272.

– “After declining to levels not seen since the 1940s, U.S. crude production began rising again in 2009,” writes the Houston Chronicle.

– The Energy Department confirmed yesterday that the U.S. exported more oil-product than imported for the first time since 1949.

– The five oil giants benefited from $200 million more profit for every penny rise in quarterly gas prices. Yet the industry still benefits from $40 billion in subsidies.

Clearly, we’re producing more oil:

Strangely, Buzzfeed argues this chart by the Obama administration “demonstrates how to play politics with statistics.” The main reason that our import mix is declining is that production has increased while we move to reduce oil dependence altogether with clean energy investments and new fuel efficiency standards that cut carbon pollution and more than $2.2 million barrels of oil per day.

Climate Progress

Bingaman Clean Energy Standard Is A Welcome Piece of Legislation In Face of GOP Dirty Energy Push

by Richard W. Caperton

The barrage of dirty energy bills being introduced in Congress is dizzying. With extreme policymakers looking to force the Keystone XL tar sands pipeline, cut funding for public transportation and dismantle EPA air quality regulations, the situation is bleak.

But there was some positive movement on clean energy in Congress today.

This morning, Senator Jeff Bingaman (D-NM) introduced a bill that would create a federal clean energy standard.  His bill, the Clean Energy Standard Act of 2012, would increase the amount of low-carbon power produced in the United States to 80% by 2035, while providing the policy certainty that’s essential to growing the clean energy economy.

In introducing his bill, Bingaman was joined by fellow Senators Bernie Sanders (I-VT), Al Franken (D-MN), and Chris Coons (D-DE), each of whom praised the bill for providing a path forward on fighting climate change.

The Clean Energy Standard Act also has the support of the energy industry. In addition to usual suspects like the American Wind Energy Association and the United States Clean Heat and Power Association, GE Energy and NextEra Energy Resources are supporting Bingaman’s approach.

In previous work, the Center for American Progress has laid out criteria for what a successful clean energy standard would look like:

Read more

Older

Newer

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up