Tumblr Icon RSS Icon

DeWine: ‘We Don’t Want To Have Any Kind of Debate About Whether Its Constitutional’

By Faiz Shakir on February 17, 2006 at 7:01 pm

"DeWine: ‘We Don’t Want To Have Any Kind of Debate About Whether Its Constitutional’"

Share:

google plus icon
dewine

    The White House announced its support for a legislative proposal by Ohio Sen. Mike DeWine to exclude Bush’s NSA wiretapping program from the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. ThinkProgress explained earlier why the proposal is a bad idea. Tonight, on Fox News, DeWine explained his motivations:

    You know, there’s been some controversy about whether or not this program is legal or is not legal. I think we need to get beyond that. And the vast majority of American people believe these calls need to be listened to. But we don’t want to have any kind of debate about whether it’s constitutional or not constitutional. So I think we need to put that beyond us.

    The reason DeWine and the White House don’t want to talk about the program’s legality is because the program is illegal. DeWine is attempting to fix a problem that he hasn’t even properly diagnosed. Even Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Arlen Specter isn’t buying DeWine’s spin:

    Unless they’re prepared to have a determination on constitutionality as to their programs, window dressing oversight will not be sufficient.

    President Bush said today, “I mean, a lot of lawyers looked at this, and they said, you bet, Mr. President, it’s legal.” If he’s so confident about that, why is he so afraid to have a debate?

    Tags:

    ‹ PREVIOUS
    Abramoff needs more time to spill the beans.

    NEXT ›
    The Real Pat Roberts Returns

    By clicking and submitting a comment I acknowledge the ThinkProgress Privacy Policy and agree to the ThinkProgress Terms of Use. I understand that my comments are also being governed by Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, or Hotmail’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policies as applicable, which can be found here.