Anyone interested in the much-replicated/exonerated Hockey Stick and the phony challenges to it by the anti-science blogosphere should read “Hockey Stick fight at the RC Corral.”
Judith Curry has made an amazing series of comments, even after writing, “OK, I officially give up over here” (at #152).
Many of us have asked a favor of her — please define your terms, please respond to the detailed debunking of the Montford critiques you have repeated, and please defend the sweeping but unsubstantiated attacks on the judgment and integrity of unnamed scientists. But she has ignored those requests, continued with her unsubstantiated and primarily personal attacks on scientists and the scientific community, and continued to curry favor with the disinformers, citing Steven Chu, Peter Gleick, and even Feynman, in her defense, using quotes that ironically apply more to what she is doing, and not her critics.
It is a meltdown of historic proportions. For continuity’s sake, please respond in that post.
Previous in TP Climate Progress
