Tumblr Icon RSS Icon

House GOP Hold Tax Cut Hostage to Keystone XL Pipeline, Based on Discredited Job Numbers

By Climate Guest Contributor  

"House GOP Hold Tax Cut Hostage to Keystone XL Pipeline, Based on Discredited Job Numbers"

Share:

google plus icon

Anthony Swift, in a NRDC Switchboard repost

The Speaker of the House John Boehner has just announced that he plans to hold payroll tax cuts and unemployment benefits hostage to a bill that would rubber stamp approval of the Keystone XL tar sands pipeline. This legislation, proposed by Rep. Lee Terry (Neb.), is nothing like the bill the House voted on in the summer.

Rather than requiring an expedited decision by the Administration, Terry’s new bill would require automatic approval of Keystone XL in thirty days, giving the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) authority to permit (but not decline) a Presidential permit. In the process, it also exempts TransCanada from having to abide by the same laws that domestic pipelines do – laws intended to protect the nation’s land and water.

Speaker Boehner’s reason for pushing such a bad bill is his belief that the American people will mistake Keystone XL for a national jobs package. It isn’t. The House leadership is echoing discredited and widely exaggerated job numbers for the project. The State Department found that the pipeline would only create between 5,000 to 6,000 temporary construction jobs and only 20 permanent jobs (pg. 3.10-79, 80). Even the pipeline’s sponsor TransCanada has admitted that the pipeline would create no more than a few hundred permanent jobs. The 13.3 million Americans who are out of work will not thank Speaker Boehner when they realize that rather than seriously working on their behalf to advance national job creation, he used their distress to try to get a pipeline that is for the benefit of Big Oil.

The new Terry bill a surprising choice for a national shutdown – as a piece of legislation it’s fraught with problems. Unlike legislation proposed by Terry last year which would have set a deadline for the Administration to decide whether to issue a permit for Keystone XL, the new Terry bill essentially takes the decision away from the President and regulatory agencies with scientific and technical expertise. Of course, the legislation gives FERC a thirty day window to approve a Presidential permit before automatic approval happens. But this isn’t actual permitting authority anymore than an election where voters may vote for one candidate before that candidate automatically wins is real democracy.

The Terry bill would also exempt TransCanada from state and federal regulations that domestic pipeline operators must abide by. The bill would exempt TransCanada from any law other than the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration’s (PHSMA) safety regulations and FERC’s authority to regulate pipelines rate and services in the construction, operation and maintenance of the Keystone XL tar sands pipeline. That means TransCanada wouldn’t to abide by the same laws that domestic pipelines do – laws intended to protect the nation’s land and water.Terry’s bill also sets an alarming precedent for future poorly conceived projects to go and get boutique legislation when the public and regulators ask pointed questions.

President Obama has made a commitment to protect the Americans living along the pipeline route and consider Keystone XL’s impacts on public health, safety and environment are properly understood. Health, safety and environmental protection are core values for all Americans and protecting these values is of bipartisan importance. As President Obama has said, this is a fundamentally American issue: “How do we make sure that we’ve got the best possible energy mix to benefit our businesses, benefit our workers but also benefit our families to make sure that the public health and safety of the American people are looked after?”

As a nation, we should be working on measures that will create jobs on a national scale while achieving true energy independence for our country. We’ve already made tremendous strides on that front.  According to Brookings, more than 2.7 million people are working in the U.S. clean energy economy right now – more than the entire fossil fuel industry put together. Clean car manufacturers have created over 151,000 quality long term jobs in the United States while saving consumers billions of dollars at the pump. Between 2003 and 2010, the clean energy sector grew nearly twice as fast as the overall economy. Moreover, a recent study found the U.S. can gain as many as 1.9 million more jobs with a comprehensive energy policy. These clean energy jobs are real, long term, and number in the millions.

Our lawmakers need to consider serious steps to get achieve energy independence and get our country back to work. Investments and jobs in clean energy is something our country can get behind. So why is Speaker Boehner pushing a divisive project that isn’t shovel ready and threatens our country’s land and water? He seems to be playing politics with the concerns of Americans all to benefit Big Oil.

– Anthony Swift, in a NRDC Switchboard repost

Related Post:

Tags:

‹ Top Eight Climate Disasters During The Durban Climate Talks

Romney: Scientists Will Figure Out Man’s Contribution To Global Warming ’10, 20, 50 Years From Now’ ›

14 Responses to House GOP Hold Tax Cut Hostage to Keystone XL Pipeline, Based on Discredited Job Numbers

  1. Sasparilla says:

    Nothing here is a surprise. As to the discredited numbers, the Republicans know that the most often repeated and quoted number becomes the “real” one in the public space.

    As to the “He seems to be playing politics with the concerns of Americans all to benefit Big Oil.” – Seems to? The GOP has been doing this for decades, standard operating procedure, with the major assistance of the Democrats (that’s why President Obama approved two previous tar sands pipelines from Canada in 2009).

    The GOP also knows that on the soundbite TV area the XL will sound like a winner (pipeline for jobs, lower oil prices blah blah blah) – seems a long shot the Democratically controlled Senate would pass a similiar bill though.

    • Mulga Mumblebrain says:

      Sasparilla ‘seems to’ is up there with ‘perceived’ as a MSM weasel word and obfuscation. They cannot afford to annoy the masters by speaking honestly about what they are doing. For state enemies, like the evil Putin, the abuse is unambiguous and histrionic.

  2. Texas Progressive says:

    I say Barry should refuse such extortion, last minute or any time, and block XL and let the SS tax cut expire, then make it clear that his Exec decision to delay XL decision is not open to Repug extortion.

  3. SecularAnimist says:

    Anthony Swift wrote: “The 13.3 million Americans who are out of work will not thank Speaker Boehner when they realize that rather than seriously working on their behalf to advance national job creation, he used their distress to try to get a pipeline that is for the benefit of Big Oil.”

    No worries. The corporate-owned mass media will make sure that they never realize that.

  4. Both of these terrible ideas need a stake through the heart.

    The SS tax “holiday” is designed to weaken Social Security’s fiscal integrity, in preparation for its eventual privitization or demise — horse trading this very, very bad idea for green-lighting of the “game over” Tar Sands pipeline is betrayal, not leadership!

  5. fj says:

    Long overdue that Obama acts decisively to end the tyranny of oil as promised.

    • Mulga Mumblebrain says:

      The ‘promises’ made by Obama to the rubes are ‘writ in water’. Those made, sub rosa, to his business owners, are hewn in granite.

  6. shoshanabryner says:

    I researched the question of who High Speed Universities admits, their retention rates, and graduates, and I have to say that a school that is just looking for enrollment, would not hold these types of numbers. You can research this information yourself.

  7. Joan Savage says:

    A look at Rep. Lee Terry’s constituency shows the 2nd congressional district is mostly the metropolitan area around Omaha, NE. The area is not directly impacted by proposed Keystone XL, according to the latest TransCanada map. The TransCanada map does show that a major hub for the existing and proposed pipelines is Steele City, NE, southwest of Omaha.

    Major institutional political donors to Terry don’t look explicitly related to the pipeline, but according to opensecrets.org, his 2011-2012 campaign has received $176,686 (32%) from large individual donors.

    maplight.org reports that Terry received 62% of his donations from OUTSIDE his district or 57% from outside his state, principally from the Washington, DC area.
    http://maplight.org/us-congress/legislator/487-lee-terry

    I had been wondering why he didn’t demonstrate some allegiance to his fellow Nebraskans who vigorously oppose the pipeline. The contribution pattern is inconclusive, but a hint.

    • Joan Savage says:

      This is another reason to review the North American Free Trade Agreement, NAFTA. The agreement seems to allow rough-shod treatment of state/provincial and local government, but I don’t know NAFTA well enough to see if that is explicit in the agreement or if there have been opportunistic interpretations going on in both the US and Canada.

      The international corporations who extract from the Alberta tar sands seem to have privileges that ignore local preferences, rather like the Nebraska situation.

      NAFTA website
      http://www.nafta-sec-alena.org/en/view.aspx

  8. Peter Capen says:

    Elections have consequences.

    PC

  9. Betty S Bougher says:

    IF THE MEMBERS OF CONGRESS cannot help the average American when the economy is not going anywhere but down hill,How is the average American able to pay their bills and eat,We need to vote all the do nothing congress people out of office