ThinkProgress Logo

Security

Yglesias

Still Broken

cover.jpg

If you only buy one foreign policy book this year, it should obviously be Heads in the Sand by a talented young writer with whom I’m acquainted. But if you buy a second, you could do a lot worse than A.J. Rosmiller’s Still Broken: A Recruit’s Inside Account of Intelligence Failure From Baghdad to the Pentagon. You’ve got some memoir, some policy analysis, and even a touch of action-adventure thrills.

It shows on both a micro and a macro level in what bad shape we are, intelligence-wise. The system doesn’t work, and good intelligence product isn’t getting into the right hands and being acted on in the right way. But what’s more, the system’s driving smart, talented, patriotic, and knowledgeable people right out of the system. AJ’s writing books and blog posts (and going to law school) instead of still working in the IC in part because it’s the kind of screwed-up place that’s driving the best people away rather than pulling them in. So to repeat, pre-order Heads in the Sand but it won’t come for a while, so while you wait pick up a copy of Still Broken (available Tuesday!) and read that.

Discovery Channel Drops Plans To Air ‘Taxi To The Dark Side’ Because It Is Too ‘Controversial’

Taxi to the Dark Side, a documentary about an innocent Afghan taxi driver tortured to death by U.S. officials at Bagram Air Base, has received wide critical acclaim since its debut in April at the Tribeca Film Festival. The New York Times’s A.O. Scott said, “If recent American history is ever going to be discussed with the necessary clarity and ethical rigor, this film will be essential.”

Director Alex Gibney agreed to sell the rights of Taxi to the Discovery Channel because executives convinced him they would “give the film a prominent broadcast.” Now, however, Discovery has dropped its plans to air the documentary because the film is too controversial. Gibney responded to the news in a press release this week:

Now, I am told that ‘it doesn’t fit into Discovery’s plans,’ and that the film’s controversial content might damage Discovery’s public offering.

Having directed ‘Enron,’ very little about this kind of corporate behavior shocks me, but I am surprised that a network that touts itself as a supporter of documentaries would be so shamelessly craven. This is a film that, in an election year, is of critical interest to the viewing public. What Discovery is doing is tantamount to political censorship.

It’s ironic that Taxi’s content is too “controversial,” considering it depicts real acts perpetrated by the current Bush administration. In an interview with the Center for American Progress, Gibney noted that Americans are excited about dramatizations of torture, such as in the show 24, but uncomfortable “with the reality of torture.” Listen to the interview here:

[flv http://video.thinkprogress.org/2008/02/gibneytorture2.320.40.flv]

As Gibney added in the press release, “In refusing to air the film, Discovery is perpetuating what has become the policy of this government: it is ok to employ torture, just not to show it.”

Transcript: Read more

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up