ThinkProgress Logo

Security

U.S. Citizen And Samoan Diplomat Accidentally Arrested By Immigration Authorities

keil_1Court House News reports that Hans Joachim Keil, a U.S. citizen and Samoan diplomat, was wrongfully arrested by US immigration authorities who thought he was an “illegal alien” and incarcerated for nine days.

Keil alleges that immigration agents confiscated his valid U.S. and Samoan Diplomatic passports and questioned him without providing legal counsel. Keil claims that he was charged with falsely claiming to be a U.S. citizen and is seeking punitive damages for “constitutional violations, unlawfully imprisonment, pain and suffering, emotional and mental duress, and for being denied permission to leave Missouri for 4 months to tend to his diplomatic duties.”

Keil isn’t the first U.S. citizen to get tangled up in the nation’s broken immigration system. In June, U.S. citizen Irving Palomo was detained and put in a van headed for Mexico due to an U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) mix-up. Diane Williams, a U.S. citizen of Caucasian and Native American descent, was recently deported to Honduras due to a mistake made by ICE officials. Mark Lyttle, a U.S. citizen who suffers from a mild mental disorder, was deported to Mexico. Mexican officials then deported him to Honduras, and Honduras deported him to Guatemala. After spending four months in Latin American prisons and homeless shelters, Atlanta airport officials tried to deport Lyttle again on his way back to his home in North Carolina.

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) conservatively estimates that approximately 100 U.S. citizens are accidentally ensnared by the country’s broken immigration system each year.

The charges against Keil were immediately dropped when the Department of State acknowledged he was a citizen.

Do Anti-Immigration Tea Parties Have Dick Armey’s Blessing?

dick_armey1233235736William Gheen, founder of Americans for Legal Immigration PAC (ALIPAC), claims he is organizing 50 “tea parties” this coming Saturday in an attempt to stop efforts to “destroy America through mass illegal immigration and amnesty.” Gheen says his rallies are joining ranks with the Taxpayer Tea Party and 9/12 Movements. However, while the events do pose a great organizing opportunity for Gheen, they may not attract the support of all tea partiers. Apparently tea bagger-operative and FreedomWorks chairman Dick Armey takes a more politically savvy approach to immigration. This weekend, the New York Times wrote:

He [Armey]also has a more liberal view of immigration than many in his party. “Reagan went to Berlin and said, ‘Tear down this wall,’ ” Armey said. “We went to San Diego and said, ‘Build a fence.’ It was just stupid. You have Hispanics saying, ‘I’m not going to vote for those guys because they don’t like me.’

While Gheen warns that American “hospitality and values are being strained” by “illegal aliens,” Armey has long been opposed to anti-immigrant fear mongering, stating:

More and more these days, immigrants are being viewed as if they were the source of America’s problems. It seems the old Malthusian notion that people are a drain is making one of its regular revivals…

Anti-immigration has always been ironic, because throughout our history newcomers have been a source of strength, not weakness. America still attracts the world’s best talent. And surely that is no liability. Think of it. We can avail ourselves of much of the world’s intellectual wealth simply by opening our doors…The impulse to limit immigration is really a manifestation of the protectionist impulse. And it’s misguided.

During the 2006 immigration debate, Armey referred to anti-immigrant xenophobe, former Rep. Tom Tancredo (R-CO), as the “cheerleader of jerkiness in the immigration debate.” Armey has proposed privatizing the US immigration system to allow in immigrants who love liberty and are willing to obey the law.

Nonetheless, Armey’s immigration views are probably motivated more by his pocket book than the goodness of his heart. A few months ago, Think Progress reported that corporate lobbyists were playing a big role in orchestrating tea party protests. That might help explain why Armey’s FreedomWorks was one of the few right wing organizations to support comprehensive immigration reform in 2006. Curiously, his lobbying firm was simultaneously representing the Senado de Republica (Mexican Senate) on “enhancing U.S.-Mexico relations,” specifically on immigration policy. Armey also probably recognizes that opposing immigration hurts his movement more than it helps. Only 9% of Republican voters cite immigration as one of their top issues and 89% of Republicans support comprehensive immigration reform that includes a path to legalization.

Armey might be pro-immigration, but ultimately he’s at least partly responsible for inspiring anti-immigrant tea party sideshows. In April, the Southern Poverty Law Center warned that hate groups and “nativist extremists” would begin exploiting the anger of tea baggers in an effort to recruit more supporters to join their hateful cause.

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up