ThinkProgress Logo

Security

Politics

Meet An Islamophobia Network ‘Expert’: Steven Emerson

Steven Emerson directs the Investigative Project on Terrorism (IPT), a group dedicated to exposing the dangers of Islamist infiltration in America through investigative journalism. But his career, as discussed in CAP’s new report “Fear, Inc.,” is marked by shoddy reporting and suspicious financial arrangements between private companies, in some cases listing him as the sole employee, and the nonprofit foundations which collect tax-exempt contributions to support his work.

Emerson got his start as an investigator with the Senate Foreign Relations Committee from 1976 to 1982 and, after serving as an executive assistant to Sen. Frank Church (D-ID), left public service in 1986 to join U.S. News & World Report. In 1990, he joined CNN as an investigative correspondent where he reported on terrorism. In 1995, Emerson left journalism and founded the Investigative Project on Terrorism, which claims to be “one of the world’s largest storehouses of archival data and intelligence on Islamic and Middle Eastern terrorist groups.”

But Emerson’s supposed expertise in researching terrorist networks have frequently been questioned due to his propensity for making false accusations against Muslims and his sloppy approach to investigative reporting. Most notably, in 1995, Emerson claimed that the Oklahoma City bombing showed “a Middle East trait” because it “was done with the intent to inflict as many casualties as possible.” And in 1998, Emerson was tied to a false report that Pakistan was planning a nuclear first strike on India.

Emerson’s weak credibility hasn’t stopped him from building a mini-empire from his offices at the well-funded IPT. But his penchant for secrecy — his office location is secret, employees refer to it as “the bat cave,” and journalists who visit it have been blindfolded en route — has raised serious questions about management of IPT’s finances.

As reported first by The Tennessean, IPT helps fund Emerson’s for-profit company, SAE Productions. IPT paid SAE Productions $3.33 million to “study alleged ties between American Muslims and overseas.” SAE Productions is a private company so no data is available on how the money was spent but Emerson’s role as SAE’s sole employee raises serious ethical questions.

Emerson’s finances took an even more bizarre turn when grants directed to the “Investigative Project” or “IPT” were contributed care of the Counterterrorism & Security Education and Research Foundation (CTSERF). A LobeLog investigation into CTSERF’s tax filings revealed that, much like the Investigative Project, all grant revenue was transferred to a private, for-profit entity.

When asked about the IPT-CTSERF relationship, Ray Locker, the Investigative Project’s then-managing director acknowledged to LobeLog that a relationship “exists” but would not elaborate further on how or why IPT donors send funds care of CTSERF.

Fear Inc.” examines Emerson’s role as a a key “expert” in the Islamophobia network and tracks over $5 million in grants to CTSERF and IPT.

IPT donors include: the Donors Capital Fund ($400,000); the Russell Berrie Foundation ($100,000); the Anchorage Charitable and William Rosenwald funds ($10,000); the Fairbrook Foundation ($25,000); and the Newton and Rochelle Becker affiliated foundations ($25,000).

Donors to CTSERF include: the Richard Scaife foundations ($1.575 million); the Russell Berrie Foundation ($2.736 million); The Anchorage Charitable and William Rosenwald fund ($15,000); and Newton and Rochelle Becker affiliated foundations ($4.526 million).

With All Of Its Choppers In Iraq, Vermont Has To Borrow From Other States To Respond To Irene

Vermont's Black Hawk helicopters are currently in Iraq.

The aftermath of Hurricane Irene has created not only an estimated $12 billion worth of damage, but it continues to leave many east coast residents without power and access to basic necessities.

In Vermont, where flooding has cut off a dozen towns from the rest of the state and left thousands without access to electricity, the state’s ability to respond to Irene has been hobbled by a previous disaster: the war in Iraq.

The Burlington Free Press reports that the state has had to borrow 10 helicopters total from Illinois and New Hampshire to respond to the disaster because all six of its Black Hawk helicopters are still in Iraq:

Eight helicopters on loan from the Illinois National Guard were expected to arrive Tuesday night in Vermont to help the Vermont National Guard deliver food, medicine, water and other supplies to 13 Vermont towns cut off from the rest of the state in the aftermath of Tropical Storm Irene. The outside helicopter support is needed because all six of the Vermont Guard’s Black Hawk helicopters are still in Iraq, where they and 55 Vermont soldiers are wrapping up a yearlong hospital transport mission, said Lt. Lloyd Goodrow, spokesman for the Vermont Guard. [...] The New Hampshire National Guard sent over two of its Black Hawk helicopters on Monday. The two were used to transport Federal Emergency Management Agency Administrator Craig Fugate, Gov. Peter Shumlin, Sen. Bernie Sanders I-Vt., and Rep. Peter Welch, D-Vt., on a survey of flood-damaged areas in the state.

“We’d be in a very different scenario if they were here,” said Lt. Lloyd Goodrow, a spokesman for the Vermont National Guard, of the six Black Hawk helicopters. The helicopters being used in operations to drop supplies to the dozen towns that have been cut off are smaller than Vermont’s Black Hawks, and deliveries are occurring slowly.

NEWS FLASH

Hagel Responds To Panetta’s Military Cuts Fearmongering: ‘The Pentagon Needs To Be Pared Down’ | Defense Secretary Leon Panetta has said repeatedly in recent weeks — without offering any evidence — that the $600 billion cuts in national security spending that would result if the debt ceiling deal’s so-called trigger mechanism takes effect would be “dangerous” and “devastating” to the United States. The Financial Times asked former Republican Sen. Chuck Hagel to respond to Panetta’s claims. “The Defense Department, I think in many ways has been bloated,” Hagel said, “So I think the Pentagon needs to be pared down. I don’t think that our military has really looked at themselves strategically, critically, in a long, long time.” Watch the interview here.

Bush Official And Bechtel VP Who Normalized Relations With Qaddafi Plotted With Dictator To Undermine Rebels

Why was Bechtel VP and former Bush official David Welch helping Qaddafi?

Today, Al Jazeera reports on an explosive new story that finds that the very same Bush official who spearheaded normalizing relations with Libyan dictator Moammar Qaddafi was secretly working with the dictator as late as this month to design a public relations campaign to undermine both the rebel forces and NATO.

Al Jazeera’s Jamal Elshayyal unearthed files in Libya’s intelligence headquarters that suggest that David Welch — the former assistant secretary of state under President George W. Bush who brokered the deal that normalized relations between Libya and the United States and who later went on to work for the manufacturing and development giant Bechtel — met with Libyan officials in early August to coordinate on undermining the Libyan rebels and NATO forces by, for example, trying to establish ties between the uprising and al Qaeda:

I found what appeared to be the minutes of a meeting between senior Libyan officials – Abubakr Alzleitny and Mohammed Ahmed Ismail – and David Welch, the former assistant secretary of state who served under George W Bush and the man who brokered the deal which restored diplomatic relations between the US and Libya in 2008. [...]During that meeting Welch advised Gaddafi’s team on how to win the propaganda war – suggesting several “confidence building measures”, the documents said. The documents appear to indicate that an influential US political personality was advising Gaddafi on how to beat the US and NATO. [...] Minutes of this meeting note his advice on how to undermine Libya’s rebel movement, with the potential assistance of foreign intelligence agencies, including Israel. “Any information related to al-Qaeda or other terrorist extremist organisations should be found and given to the American administration but only via the intelligence agencies of either Israel, Egypt, Morroco, or Jordan… America will listen to them… It’s better to receive this information as if it originated from those countries…”

Watch Al Jazeera’s video report about the documents:

It is unclear exactly what would motivate Welch to help Qaddafi battle the pro-democracy uprising and even his own country, but it should be noted that Welch’s position at Bechtel put him in a spot where he was incentivized to maintain strong business relationships with Libya. Shortly after helping normalize relations between the two countries, Welch became a vice president at Bechtel, overseeing the company’s Middle Eastern operations. Under Welch, the company rapidly expanded in Libya, even setting up its first office in the country since the 1960s.

Also included among the documents that Al Jazeera uncovered was evidence that Rep. Dennis Kucinich (D-OH), a Libya war foe, had contacts with Qaddafi’s regime and had asked for evidence of corruption or al Qaeda contacts among the rebels.

Ros-Lehtinen Wants To Break U.S. Laws On Hosting The U.N.

In a statement released yesterday, House Foreign Affairs Committee chairwoman Rep. Ileana Ros-Lehtinen (R-FL) called for the U.S. to violate its own laws and ratified international treaties governing the U.S. role as host to the United Nations.

In the statement, which focused on sanctioning officials from the Iranian government, Ros-Lehtinen said the U.S. should deny Iranian and Syrian officials access to the U.S. for the upcoming U.N. General Assembly:

And with the U.N. General Assembly convening in New York in weeks, the U.S. must unequivocally deny all Iranian and Syrian regime officials access to U.S. soil.

It’s impossible to read this statement as anything but a call from the top foreign policy official in the House of Representatives for the U.S. violate its own laws, specifically those enacted by the Congress in 1947 that established New York City as the host of the international body.

The U.S. and the U.N. signed the “Headquarters Agreement,” also known as U.S. Public Law 80 – 357, in June 1947 and both Houses of Congress subsequently passed the measure and the President signed it into law.

Article IV of the Headquarters Agreement outlines several provisions with regard to travel to New York by representatives of Member States:

Article IV — Communication and Transit
Section 11

The federal, state or local authorities of the United States shall not impose any impediments to transit to or from the headquarters district of (1) representatives of Members or officials of the United Nations [...]
Section 12

The provisions of Section 11 shall be applicable irrespective of the relations existing between the Governments of the persons refereed to in that section and the Government of the United States.
Section 13

(a) Laws and regulation in force in the United States regarding the entry of aliens shall not be applied in such a manner as to interfere with the privileges referred to in Section 11. When visas are required for persons referred to in that Section, they shall be granted without charge and as promptly as possible.

While Ros-Lehtinen has long been an opponent of the U.N. — she introduced a bill this week that would withdraw much of the U.S. funding for the organization — her call yesterday demonstrates that her anti-U.N. ideology trumps even respect for established U.S. law.

NEWS FLASH

Bolton: Reinvest Wasteful Military Spending Back Into Military Spending | War hawk John Bolton does not want U.S. military spending to take any further reductions. He even wants the U.S. to spend more on its military than it currently allocates. Where will he find the extra cash? Taking from Social Security, Medicare and veterans’ health and retirement. And last night on Fox News, he added another source: the monies found in identifying waste, fraud and abuse in military spending. “The thing to do is eliminate the waste and fraud and reinvest it in defense,” he said, “Don’t think that you can make savings by cutting the waste and fraud and thereby cutting the defense budget.” Watch the clip:

Cheney Credits Iraq War For Helping To Start Arab Spring

Former Vice President Dick Cheney has been making the media rounds to promote his new memoir, and this morning, he stopped by Fox and Friends where he credited the Iraq war with helping to start the Arab Spring. While Cheney cautioned that it’s hard to lump all Middle East countries together, he said it’s likely that the pro-democracy movement that swept the Arab world in the past six months is a “ripple effect” of the introduction of democracy in Iraq:

KILMEADE: Is it a reach to say Libya’s unrest…all has a lot to do with what happened in Iraq? Letting those people, seeing those people vote, and the Arab community seeing what’s going on?

CHENEY: Well, I think there may be some of that going on. [...] But I think that what happened in Iraq, the fact that we brought democracy, if you will, and freedom to Iraq, has had a ripple effect on some of those other countries.

Watch it:

A number of Bush foreign policy apologists have tried to claim the Arab Spring as vindication of the Iraq War and its cheerleaders’ claim that the invasion would help spread democracy across the Middle East. But as CAP’s Matt Duss pointed out this month, “there is no real evidence for the claim.” The war was overwhelming unpopular in the region and, as an April 2010 RAND study concluded, “Iraq’s instability has become a convenient scarecrow neighboring regimes can use to delay political reform by asserting that democratization inevitably leads to insecurity.”

Indeed, Iraq is hardly a model of democracy, and its leaders, rather than seeing solidarity with activists in other Arab countries and encouraging them, have done little to help the pro-democracy movement and at times even expressed sympathy for the autocratic regimes the movement is seeking to overthrow.

Addressing the question in July, the Council on Foreign Relations’ Steven Cook concluded, “It is time to put the Bush boosters’ arguments where they belong: in the trash heap of discredited ideas.” “There is no connection between the invasion of Iraq and Arab efforts to throw off generations of dictatorship,” he added.

Media

Fox News Lies About CAP’s Islamophobia Report By Making Up False Anti-Semitic Quote

In CAP’s recently-released report “Fear, Inc.: The Roots of the Islamophobia Network in America,” my co-authors and I demonstrate how the Islamophobia network operates: a small group of so-called “experts” produce anti-Muslim talking points, which are then propagated and echoed on news outlets like Fox News to reach larger audiences.

Unintentionally validating our research, last night Fox Business aired a segment that tried to debunk “Fear, Inc.” but instead reaffirmed the methods of the Islamophobia network. Fox’s “Follow the Money” host Eric Bolling, who has previously pushed the “creeping Sharia” myth, hosted The Investigative Project on Terrorism’s Steven Emerson — one of the five leading producers of anti-Muslim information identified in our report. (Fox did not offer us an invitation to defend the report.)

After Emerson spoke, Bolling invited a three-member panel to comment, who all agreed that there isn’t an Islamophobia network in America. Bolling set up the discussion by making this outlandishly false statement:

I need to point this out – I’m reading directly from this report: “The Obama-allied Center for American Progress has released a report that blames Islamophobia in America on a small group of Jews and Israel supporters in America, whose views are being backed by millions of dollars.”

Watch it:

To be clear, that quote is nowhere to be found in our report. If Fox wants to read “directly” from the report, we’re happy to send them a copy. In the meantime, they should stop making up quotes and issue a correction.

Before the panel discussion, Steven Emerson reacted to “Fear, Inc.” by gushing, “I feel sort of somewhat complimented because they’re attributing to me and four other people the ability to control the minds of 300 million Americans.” Emerson mischaracterized our report by stating: “What they deny — and what they claim is racist — is the assertion that Islamic terrorism is motivated by Islamic extremists, clerics, mosques…”

We don’t say anything like that in our report. There are clearly instances of radicalized Muslims committing violent acts and defaming their religion. As we say in the report, “Around the world, there are people killing people in the name of Islam, with which most Muslims disagree.” What Emerson does is try to cast aspersions on all Muslims because of the acts of a few. He questions Muslim American loyalties and tries to marginalize their voice.

For instance, Emerson has previously asserted that “nearly all of the Islamic organizations in the United States that define themselves as religiously or culturally Muslim in character have, today, been totally captured or dominated by radical fundamentalist elements.” And last night on Fox, Emerson pushed the same argument:

Most of the Islamic organizations in the United States, they’re run by the Muslim Brotherhood, or they were created by the Muslim Brotherhood – a group that believes in imposing Islam and Sharia around the world.

Watch it, courtesy of Media Matters:

National Security Brief: August 31, 2011


– Libyan rebels issued a Saturday deadline for Qaddafi loyalists to surrender but Qaddafi’s chief spokesman was quoted on Wednesday as rejecting the deadline, stating, “no dignified honorable nation would accept an ultimatum from armed gangs.”

– In its final report to Congress, the Commission on Wartime Contracting said that the U.S. has lost nearly $60 billion in waste and fraud in Iraq and Afghanistan over the past decade. The report said the government should prohibit wasteful and corrupt companies from federal contracts in warzones.

– The U.S. imposed new sanctions on two high-ranking Syrian diplomats in connection with the Syrian government’s crackdown on non-violent protests, even as Italy rejected a new set of European Union sanctions that would embargo Syrian oil in Europe.

– Syrian security forces, arriving with tanks and military vehicles, raided houses in central Syria and arrested suspected anti-government protesters a day after security forces killed seven people.

– A Washington think tank released a “report card” on implementing the recommendations of the 9/11 Commission and gave failing grades on 9 of the 41 policy prescriptions set out by the bi-partisan commission.

– Israeli ambassador to the U.S. Michal Oren said all agreements governing Israeli-Palestinian and U.S.-Palestinian cooperation could become null and void if the Palestinians go forward with seeking state recognition at the U.N. next month. The Israeli finance minister called the Palestinian initiative “a more serious threat than that posed by Hamas.”

– The Israeli military stepped up training of West Bank settler security teams in anticipation of possible Palestinian protests accompanying a bid for U.N. recognition of Palestinian statehood.

– In a move seen as protecting research and development of new military hardware, Sen. Carl Levin (D-MI) said U.S. bases abroad would be the first thing to get cut in military spending reductions.

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up