ThinkProgress Logo

Security

Justice

FLASHBACK: Herman Cain Says States Can Ban Firearms

If Herman Cain gets his way, shopping for guns could become illegal in many states

Texas Gov. Rick Perry’s (R) radical belief that everything from Social Security to Medicare is unconstitutional rocketed him to the front of the GOP presidential race, but he collapsed just as quickly once GOP voters learned that he supports allowing undocumented immigrants to pay in-state tuition at public universities. Perry’s loss has been Herman Cain’s gain — Public Policy Polling most recent round of polls shows the former pizza executive springing to the front of the GOP pack.

Yet the GOP electorate’s quest for total ideological purity could be Cain’s downfall as well. Just last June, Cain told CNN’s Wolf Blitzer that — although Cain claims to “support the Second Amendment” — he also believes that state governments should have the power to regulate or even ban firearms if they choose:

BLITZER: Should states or local governments be allowed to control the gun situation

CAIN: Yes

BLITZER: So the answer is yes?

CAIN: Yes. The answer is yes, that should be a state’s decision.

Watch it:

Cain’s belief that Congress can’t touch guns but states can not only places him well to the left of the NRA, it also places him at odds with the Supreme Court. In McDonald v. Chicago, the justices held 5-4 that the Second Amendment applies equally to the states and to the federal government. The four justices who agreed with Cain that states can freely regulate guns were left-of-center Justices Stevens, Ginsburg, Breyer, and Sotomayor.

Cain would only have to watch Sotomayor’s confirmation hearing to learn that his relatively moderate position on guns places him well outside the Republican mainstream. Senate Republicans savaged Justice Sonia Sotomayor during her confirmation hearings because she took the Herman Cain position on gun control while she was a lower court judge — although Sotomayor’s decision was the correct one because it came down before the Supreme Court changed its interpretation of the Second Amendment in McDonald.

Because McDonald was such a closely divided decision, the Supreme Court would drastically roll back Second Amendment rights if a hypothetical Cain Administration appointed just one more pro-gun control justice to the Supreme Court. If that happened, President Cain would do more to strike at gun owners’ rights with just one appointment that President Obama will accomplish in an entire presidential term.

NEWS FLASH

POLL: Half Of Americans Think Afghan War Not A Success | A new poll from CBS News shows deep dissatisfaction among Americans with the U.S.-led war in Afghanistan. Fully half of respondents said they didn’t think the war was a success, and 62 percent think U.S. troop numbers there should be decreased (down slightly from June). More than half of both Democrats and independents thought the war effort had been unsuccessful, while 41 percent of Republicans held that view. Almost seven in 10 Americans said the war has gone on longer than they expected.

Mullen: U.S. Will ‘Absolutely’ Have Capability To ‘Hammer’ Taliban After Drawdown

Last month, U.S. Ambassador to Afghanistan Ryan Crocker said the only way to get the Taliban to the negotiating table for real peace negotiations is apply more military pressure. “The Taliban needs to feel more pain before you get to a real readiness to reconcile,” Crocker said.

In an interview that aired yesterday on CNN, host Fareed Zakaria asked outgoing Joint Chiefs of Staff chairman Adm. Mike Mullen if the withdrawal President Obama ordered this year would in any way impede this fight to the negotiating table. Mullen, in what was his last interview as JCS chairman, said it would not:

ZAKARIA: Why has it not been possible to draw some of the Taliban back into the fold? Ryan Crocker, the ambassador, says it’s because we haven’t yet hit them hard enough or they haven’t – they don’t feel beaten down enough. Do you think that’s true?

MULLEN: I do agree with that. I think that reconciliation takes place. You get them to the table when they’re in a much weaker position. And there’s no question that at some point in time there’s got to be ail political solution here and reconciliation is key to that.

ZAKARIA: But is that compatible, that desire to hammer them more? Is that compatible with this drawdown?

MULLEN: Absolutely.

Watch the clip:

But since Crocker’s comment, peace negotiations with the Taliban are now virtually non-existent after Taliban operatives killed former President Burhanuddin Rabbani, the leader of Afghanistan’s High Peace Council. Former presidential candidate and Northern Alliance leader Abdullah Abdullah said the lesson of the attack should be that “we shouldn’t fool ourselves” that the Taliban “are willing to make peace.” Indeed, President Hamid Karzai announced today that he would instead turn his attention to cutting a deal with the Pakistanis.

But Mullen’s comment pretty much puts to rest claims by critics of Obama’s Afghanistan withdrawal plan that it wouldn’t leave enough troops there to force the Taliban to the negotiating table. “I don’t think there will be serious negotiations with the Taliban until they are convinced that they cannot succeed” in attaining their goals, Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) said in July, “through the force of arms on the battlefield.” Yet Mullen — the outgoing top military official — disagrees.

McCain Dismisses Cheney’s Demand That Obama Apologize For Rebuking Bush Administration’s Use Of Torture

Former Vice President Dick Cheney lauded President Obama for his significant success in his counterterrorism efforts and even admitted Obama secured more successes than the Bush administration. However, still smarting from Obama’s rebuke of torture or “enhanced interrogation techniques” in 2009, Cheney and his daughter Liz Cheney asked that Obama apologize to the Bush administration after wrongly insisting he benefited from such techniques.

Today on CNN, Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) once again slammed the use of “enhanced interrogation techniques,” stating, “It’s very obvious one of the great recruitment tools that our enemies has is the fact that we tortured people which is not in keeping with the standards of the treatment of prisoners.” In direct rebuttal of Liz Cheney, he added, “We never got useful information as a result of torture but we sure got a lot of angry citizens around the world.”

When asked whether Obama owes the Bush administration an apology over his rebuke of torture techniques, McCain coyly responded, “About what?” Noting resounding opposition in the Senate to torture and the United Nations Geneva Convention’s prohibition of such treatment, he dismissed the idea that the Bush administration deserves any apology after having used those methods:

MCCAIN: The vote was 90 to 6 in the United States Senate to prohibit cruel and inhumane mistreatment — this amendment, a piece of legislation that I was a sponsor of. The Senate has spoken, the American people have spoken, people of the world have spoken. Torturing people in violation of international agreements such as the Geneva Conventions is prohibited and frankly very harmful to the image of the United States of America.

Watch it:

National Security Brief: October 3, 2011


– The U.S. Justice Department drafted a secret memo giving a legal justification under “due process in war” to the killing of Anwar al-Awlaki, a U.S. citizen and extremist propagandist killed last week in Yemen.

– Last week’s killing of al-Awlaki was a serious blow to al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula but eliminating the threat there will require the killing of its leadership in Yemen, according to a newly released Army counter-terrorism report.

– Syrian dissidents meeting in Istanbul formed a council uniting most of the opposition groups working to bring down the government of Bashar al-Assad.

– The Afghan government of Hamid Karzai said it intends to stop peace talks with the Taliban after a peace council official was killed by a Taliban suicide bomber: “From now on to us, the main party for peace in Afghanistan is Pakistan, not the Taliban or whatever other elements,” said a government security adviser.

– U.S. military commanders said that Pakistan is the source of explosives in the vast majority of insurgent bombs planted in Afghanistan this summer. Meanwhile, NATO said this weekend that it had captured a man they described as a high-ranking member of the Haqqani network.

– Secretary of Defense Leon Panetta warned that Israel is becoming increasingly isolated and should work to restart negotiations with the Palestinians and restore relations with Egypt and Turkey, saying, “Real security can only be achieved by both a strong diplomatic effort as well as a strong effort to project your military strength.”

– The top U.S. commander for Africa, Gen. Carter Ham, said NATO’s involvement in Libya could begin to wrap up as soon as this coming week after allied leaders meet in Brussels.

– New Joint Chiefs of Staff Chairman Gen. Martin Dempsey told the New York Times that he didn’t think the U.S. fighting force would be smaller, but that examining new capabilities was essential because of economic challenges.

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up