ThinkProgress Logo

Security

Panetta: Iran Hasn’t ‘Made The Decision To Develop A Nuclear Weapon’

This month, Director of National Intelligence (DNI) James Clapper and Secretary of Defense Leon Panetta fell under attack for making public statements asserting that U.S. intelligence indicates Iran has not yet decided whether to pursue a nuclear weapon. Newt Gingrich adviser Christian Whiton accused Panetta of not “telling the truth” about Iran’s nuclear program and Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC) told Clapper that, despite U.S. intelligence assessments to the contrary, “I’m very convinced that they’re going down the road of developing a nuclear weapon.”

Today, Graham asked Panetta a similar question during a Senate Budget Committee hearing:

LINDSEY GRAHAM: Do you believe the Iranians are trying to develop a nuclear weapon?

LEON PANETTA: I think they’re developing a nuclear capability [but] our intelligence makes clear that they haven’t made the decision to develop a nuclear weapon.

Watch him:

Graham moved on and chose not to publicly disagree with the Secretary of Defense but the message from Panetta was clear. U.S. intelligence, at this time, does not conclude that Iran is in the process of building a nuclear weapon.

These views are echoed by the the IAEA — the U.N.’s nuclear watchdog agency — which, just last week, reiterated its “serious concerns regarding possible military dimensions to Iran’s nuclear programme,” but came short of concluding that Iran is pursuing a nuclear weapon.

NEWS FLASH

Clinton: There Is ‘An Argument To Be Made’ That Assad Is A War Criminal | Last November, the U.N. Human Rights Council issued a report finding that Syrian security forces had committed crimes against humanity and this month, U.N. Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon accused the Syrian regime of “almost certain” crimes against humanity. Today during a Senate hearing, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton agreed that the argument can be made that Syrian President Bashar al-Assad is a war criminal but added that an official declaration as such may complicate a political solution to the crisis. “Based on definitions of war criminal and crimes against humanity, there would be an argument to be made that he would fit into that category,” Clinton said, adding, “But I also think that from long experience that can complicate a resolution of a difficult, complex situation because it limits options to persuade leaders perhaps to step down from power.”

Sen. Durbin: GOP Presidential Candidates ‘At War With Islam’

Senate Majority Whip Dick Durbin (D-IL) on Monday accused the Republican presidential field of incendiary rhetoric that did not match the level-headed tone in combating terrorism laid out by President George W. Bush and continued under President Obama. Appearing on CNN, Durbin was responding to the GOP candidates’ criticism that Obama’s apology to Afghans for the inadvertent burning of Muslim holy books was “unacceptable,” as former Senator Rick Santorum (R-PA) put it.

Durbin said the Bush “got it right” when “(h)e said our war is not with the religion of Islam.” Instead, he said, “Our war is with those who would distort [Islam] and turn it into terrorism.” Durbin went on to say that this was a “guiding principle” that “was adopted by President Obama.” He then drew a distinction with the GOP presidential field, and CNN commentator Will Cain asked him to clarify:

DURBIN: Now, listen to these Republican candidates for president. They’re at war with Islam. What the president is trying to do is to calm down –

WILL CAIN: Senator Durbin, I haven’t heard one thing that backs up what you suggest. Just give me an example, how are they at war with Islam?

DURBIN: Newt Gingrich saying that the president is guilty of appeasement. [...] What you listen to is incendiary rhetoric coming out in a very delicate situation. Lives are at stake here. The president is showing leadership. The president is stepping up, trying to calm a situation. These three candidates are coming on television doing the opposite.

Watch the video:

Indeed, Durbin is right. Much of the GOP presidential campaign has been steeped in Islamophobic rhetoric. Gingrich has said he would single out Muslims by advocating for an unconstitutional federal law that would criminalize some practices of being Muslim in America. Santorum has endorsed Muslim profiling at airports, and has said Muslims don’t believe in equality. In 2007, Mitt Romney reportedly said he wouldn’t consider Muslim candidates for a cabinet position.

Regarding Obama’s apology for the mistaken Quran burnings in Afghanistan, Media Matters noted that many conservative pundits said Obama was right to apologize, and added that Bush had also apologized for cultural transgressions in the course of the two wars his administration started. As for Obama, he’s had his own rather strikingly effective response to the charge of “appeasement.”

NEWS FLASH

Gingrich To Afghanistan: ‘Figure Out How To Live Your Own Miserable Life’ | Amid the current upheaval in Afghanistan following U.S. military personnel burning copies of the Quran, GOP presidential hopeful Newt Gingrich suggested yesterday that the U.S. can no longer achieve its goals there. “We are not going to fix Afghanistan. It is not possible,” he said, adding, “[t]here are some problems where you have to say, ‘You know, you are going to have to figure out how to live your own miserable life because you clearly don’t want to learn from me how to be unmiserable.’”

National Security Brief: February 28, 2012


– The U.N. withdrew its staff in northeastern Afghanistan because of safety concerns after protesters there, sparked by a Koran-burning incident laid siege to the offices.

– Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon (R-CA) plans to introduce a bill that would bar private security contractors and Afghans from guarding U.S. military installations as the U.S.-led war in Afghanistan winds down.

– Under pressure from the Israeli government, the U.S. is considering clarifying its “red line” with Iran, referring to the threshold of Iranian actions that would cause the U.S. to take military action.

– Retired Marine Corps Gen. James Cartwright, the former vice chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said that neither the U.S., nor Israel, can stop Iran from developing a nuclear weapon if it decides to do so. “The intellectual capital still exists. We could certainly bomb the place, but we don’t know where everything is with any kind of certainty,” he said.

– An American intelligence official said that the Israelis would not warn the U.S. if it decided to attack Iran’s nuclear facilities.

– Ninety percent of Syrians reportedly approved a new Constitution. Western leaders and opposition figures called the referendum a farce.

– A Syrian opposition group reported finding a mass grave with 64 bodies on the outskirts of the embattled city of Homs as the top U.N. rights official reiterated calls for a ceasefire and eventual international tribunals ahead of a vote at the Human Rights Council.

– Qatar’s prime minister Sheikh Hamad bin Jassim Al-Thani said yesterday that he supports arming the Syrian opposition movement. “We should do whatever necessary to help them, including giving them weapons to defend themselves,” he said.

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up