ThinkProgress Logo

Security

Alyssa

How Chinese Censorship Is Changing American Movies

I’ve written in the past about the challenges American film and television studios face in attempting to get their products into the Chinese market, and the Los Angeles Times has a blockbuster piece out about the compromises movie studios are making to win Chinese approval:

In “Salmon Fishing in the Yemen,”a romantic comedy about building a dam in the Mideast, Chinese hydroelectric engineers showed off their know-how; the original book included no such characters. In Columbia Pictures’ disaster movie”2012,” the White House chief of staff extolled the Chinese as visionaries after an ark built by the country’s scientists saves civilization.

In fact, references to the Middle Kingdom are popping up with remarkable frequency in movies these days. Some are conspicuously flattering or gratuitous additions designed to satisfy Chinese business partners and court audiences in the largest moviegoing market outside the U.S. Others, filmmakers say, are simply organic reflections of the fact that China is a rising political, economic and cultural power.

Meanwhile, Chinese bad guys are vanishing — literally. Western studios are increasingly inclined to excise potentially negative references to China in the hope that the films can pass muster with Chinese censors and land one of several dozen coveted annual revenue-sharing import quota slots in Chinese cinemas.

Now, I have no complaint with certain things that can result from Hollywood being held accountable to non-American markets. If Chinese audiences want to see more Chinese characters—something the Times piece said happened with a college comedy called 21 and Over—and want to see them treated like actual people rather than stand-ins for stereotypes—Men In Black III apparently went through reshoots to avoid portrayals that were considered objectionable—that’s progress. Hollywood economics so rarely end up incentivizing progress.

But as the Times points out, it doesn’t stop there. Characters are supposed to speak Mandarin rather than Cantonese, because the Chinese government is trying to make Mandarin the uniform national tongue. Studios aren’t supposed to shoot in cities and give revenue to areas that have pockets of dissidents. They’re not supposed to promote obscenity, gambling, violence, supernaturalism, horrors, ghosts, demons, general supernaturalism, or disturbances of social order, all of which are pretty fantastic story drivers. That’s a lot of creative integrity to hand over. At some point, big talents are going to get frustrated by these restrictions. Even from a business perspective, there’s got to be a point at which it becomes difficult to satisfy both American audiences and Chinese censors. And while the Chinese government and Hollywood studios may believe that Chinese audiences will pay to see anything as long as it’s on a big screen, that is not necessarily a condition that will last forever.

Panetta: Borrowing To Finance Iraq War Was A ‘Mistake’

The last U.S. military vehicle out of Iraq

Testifying on Capitol Hill today, U.S. Defense Secretary Leon Panetta said that financing the Iraq war with borrowed cash — and thereby raising the national deficit — was a “mistake.” The war came at a huge cost to the U.S. “We ran that war on a credit card,” said Sen. Patrick Leahy (D-VT), who asked Panetta about using borrowed money to finance wars. Panetta responded:

If we repeated the mistake of not paying for the war that we decide to engage in, the result would be that you would simply add more to the deficit and the debt of this country for the future. You just put the burden on our kids for the future…

It’s important that we recognize the costs that are involved, and that frankly all of us bear the responsibility to bear those costs if we’re willing to engage in war.

Watch the video:

According to U.S. News and World Report, the Congressional Budget office put the cost of war at $800 billion (that’s what the Center for American Progress’s Iraq War Ledger said, too). But President Obama has said the war, which he opposed and finally ended, costed $1 trillion. Those costs are likely to rise yet — by 2014, the post-9/11 combat veteran cohort will be bigger than the Vietnam veteran cohort, and a recent report said maintaining veterans benefits will soon cost more than maintaining active duty military forces.

NEWS FLASH

House Republicans Likely Will Block Amendment To Remove Military Abortion Ban | A Senate committee already has passed Sen. Jeanne Shaheen’s (D-NH) amendment to ensure that military insurance plans cover abortion services in cases of rape and incest, giving military women the same access to abortion care as civilians. Currently, military insurance plans only offer abortion coverage if the mother’s life is in danger. But even though Republican senators like John McCain (AZ) and Scott Brown (MA) support the Shaheen Amendment, a GOP staffer told Army Times that House Republicans will likely remove the amendment from the National Defense Authorization Bill because “social provisions that are not reflected in both bills heading into conference don’t survive.” Without the amendment, the roughly 200,000 women serving on active duty would not “have the same rights to affordable reproductive health services as all of the civilians who they protect,” Shaheen said.

Ben Sherman

In 2001, China-Basher Romney Said ‘We Should Not Build Walls’ Because Of Beijing’s Rights Abuses

Mitt Romney has threatened to declare China a currency manipulator and, in a February Wall Street Journal oped on China, stated, “A nation that represses its own people cannot ultimately be a trusted partner in an international system based on economic and political freedom.” But while his campaign has had no shortage of tough talk towards China, Romney’s history at Bain Capital and his ongoing investments in its funds suggest the former Massachusetts Governor has looked favorably on companies that benefit from China’s low labor costs and controlled currency.

Even more strikingly, Reuters’ Rachelle Younglai reports today: “As chairman of the 2002 Winter Olympics, he also said Beijing should not be punished for human rights abuses.” According to Younglai, Romney was quoted in the Chicago Tribune saying:

They have practices, as reported in the media, that violate my sense of human rights, but we should not build walls even if we vehemently disagree with many of their practices. Building bridges increases the possibility for spreading the ideas of civil societies.

Romney’s inconsistent positions on China have already been cited by fellow Republicans and Washington policy analysts as a casualty of campaign season rhetoric. Last February, Romney supporter Jon Huntsman called Romney’s China policy “wrongheaded,” and dismissed his bluster on China as “typical campaign rhetoric.”

That rhetoric also stands at odds with Romney’s business record. His history at Bain Capital, the private equity firm he founded in 1984 and ran through 1999, may pose some difficult questions for a candidate who now claims he would declare China a currency manipulator if elected president. His presidential campaign promotes how three of the companies that Bain invested in during this time — Staples, Sports Authority and Dominos Pizza — created more than 100,000 jobs combined. But when Reuters conducted an examination of products at Staples and Sports Authority stores, they found that Chinese manufactured products formed the backbone of the companies’ business. 40 percent of Staples products in the sample and two-thirds of Sports Authority products were manufactured in China. Dominos has, since Romney left Bain, announced plans to franchise their restaurant in China.

Bain’s heavy investments in companies that outsource manufacturing to China means that Romney, and the company he helped found, directly benefited from Beijing’s undervaluation of its currency and inexpensive labor.

While talking tough on China, Romney toed a very different line while CEO of Bain and chairman of the 2002 Winter Olympics. Indeed, Bain’s investments in China and Romney’s ongoing investments — including, via a Bain fund, in a controversial Chinese company which provides surveillance tools to the Chinese government — underscores the disconnect between Romney’s business career and positions taken in his campaign.

NEWS FLASH

Interactive Map Of Children Used In Wars | A U.N. report details what the international body calls a “list of shame” — the 52 countries and militias that use children in wars, according to the L.A. Times. The way militants — either governments or non-state actors — use the kids varies. In Syria, children reportedly get used as human shields; the Taliban recruits young Afghans to fight its insurgency; and Somalia’s Al Shabab milita reportedly uses more than 900 child soldiers. By plugging data from the U.N. report into a website called Zeemap, the Times produced this interactive map:

Justice

NRA Offers ‘Stand Your Ground’ Insurance To Cover Legal Costs Of Shooting People In Self-Defense

In a rare “scoop” for an editorial cartoonist today, Matt Bors skewered a little-known National Rifle Association (NRA) program that offers insurance to cover policy holders’ costs should they become embroiled in a legal battle after shooting someone in self-defense.

The insurance — technically endorsed by the NRA and administered by Lockton Affinity exclusively for NRA members — is available as a rider to the “excess personal liability” plan. Here’s how the website advertises the added coverage for self-defense (emphasis in the original):

What’s Covered:

• Provides coverage up to the limit selected for criminal and civil defense costs.

Cost of civil suit defense is provided in addition to the limit of liability for bodily injury and property damage.

Criminal Defense Reimbursement is provided for alleged criminal actions involving self-defense when you are acquitted of such criminal charges or the charges are dropped.

The basic liability plan costs either $47 or $67 annually, for coverage up to $100,000 or $250,000, respectively. Though the coverage amounts stay the same, a policy holder can add the self-defense insurance by paying $118 or $165 for the lesser coverage, or between $187 and $254 for the larger plan. (The discrepancies are due to the different prices for coverage on two different webpages from the insurer.)

The NRA pushed its members in 2005 to support Florida’s controversial “stand your ground” law — an exemption from arrest or prosecution in shootings where the police think the act was in self defense. When the law got bad press after police let the man who shot and killed Florida teenager Trayvon Martin go free, the NRA refused to back down, continuing to support the law’s passage in other states (amid other acts of insensitivity around Martin’s shooting death).

Here’s Matt Bors’ cartoon skewering the insurance program:

Global Approval Levels For U.S. Decline But Support For Obama Reelection Remains High

Global approval levels of President Barack Obama’s foreign policy have declined significantly since he first took office. But a new public opinion poll on Obama’s approval ratings abroad reflect that despite widespread opposition to the administration’s drone strike policy and a widespread perception that the U.S. acts unilaterally, attitudes toward the U.S. are generally more positive than in 2008, the final year of the George W. Bush administration.

The Pew Global Attitudes Project, conducted by the Pew Research Center, finds that key American allies remains largely confident. 80 percent of Europeans expressed “confidence in Obama,” a six percent reduction from 2009, and 74 percent of of Japanese expressed confidence, an eleven percent reduction. However, the U.S. remains unpopular in strategically important country’s in the Muslim world, including: Egypt; Jordan; Turkey and Pakistan.

Perceptions of the U.S. role in the world have also shifted during the past three years. Majorities in Germany (62 percent), Britain (58 percent), France (57 percent), and Spain (57 percent) now name China as the world’s top economic power.

The administration’s drone strike policy, which the White House has found challenging to explain to a domestic audience disconcerted by the president’s “kill list” of drone strike targets, face widespread opposition abroad. In 17 of the 20 countries polled, more than half of poll respondents disapproved of U.S. drone strikes targeting extremists in Pakistan, Yemen and Somalia. The U.S. was the only country in which a majority — 62 percent — approved of drone strikes.

Despite the opposition to the administration’s drone policy, there is considerable support for Obama’s reelection, particularly in Europe. 92 percent of French and 89 percent of German respondents support his bid.

Perhaps most importantly, majorities or pluralities in 12 of the countries polled expressed a favorable opinion of the U.S. while the prevailing view is negative in only five nations. In France, Spain and Germany the percentage of people with a positive view of the U.S. is at least 20 percentage points higher than in 2008, the final year of the George W. Bush administration. “While confidence in Obama has slipped, in many of the countries surveyed, people continue to express confidence in President Obama’s foreign policy leadership,” says the report.

While often overlooked, American “soft power” remains highly regarded. The “American way” of doing business is especially popular in the Arab world – more than half in Lebanon (63 percent), Tunisia (59 percent), Jordan (59 percent) and Egypt (52 percent) say they like this aspect of American. Majorities or pluralities in 18 of 20 countries view the U.S.’s contributions to science, technology, music and television positively.

National Security Brief: Weapons To Syria Rebels


- A day after the U.S. accused Russia of supplying helicopters to Syrian government forces and the U.N. declared the conflict a “civil war”, the New York Times reports that the U.S. was consulted on arms deals funded by Saudia Arabia and Qatar that sent Turkish Army anti-tank missiles to Syrian rebels.

- Israeli President Shimon Peres today, in Washington to receive the top U.S. government distinction for civilians, the Presidential Medal of Freedom, will ask the administration to release Israeli spy Jonathan Pollard. In 1995, almost ten years after his conviction and sentencing to life in prison, Israel granted Pollard citizenship and campaigned for his release, which is opposed by many top American security officials but supported by some Members of Congress.

- Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov visits Tehran today ahead of talks between Western powers and Iran next week in Moscow over its nuclear program. The U.S. has long courted Russia to press Iran to cut a deal. The Moscow talks appeared to be on shaky footing until a recent call between the E.U. foreign office and Tehran’s chief negotiator, who now says all nuclear issues will be on the table.

- The food crisis that has long wracked North Korea, a result of the international community’s isolation of the eccentric Communist dictatorship, affects millions of children, according to a new U.N. report. Almost a third of children there suffer from stunted growth as the government funds military build-ups, though it’s recently acknowledged a crisis.

- Just four days before a runoff vote for the presidency, Egypt’s parliament appointed a 100-member assembly to hash out a new constitution for the country. The panel was said to represent greater diversity than normally found in post-revolutionary elected bodies, which have been dominated by Islamists, particularly the Muslim Brotherhood.

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up