ThinkProgress Logo

Security

Russian Human Rights Official Calls Pussy Riot Sentence ‘Excessive’

Pussy Riot's Nadezhda Tolokonnikova (photo: Natalia Kolesnikova/AFP/Getty Images)

Reuters reports that Russia’s human rights “ombudsman,” Vladimir Lukin, said that prison sentences a Russian court handed down to three women from the punk band Pussy Riot were “excessive” and warned that the whole fiasco surrounding the trial is damaging Russian society.

The women, Nadezhda Tolokonnikova, Maria Alyokhina and Yekaterina Samutsevich, were convicted of hooliganism after performing an anti-President Vladimir Putin song on the altar of Moscow’s main cathedral and sentenced to two years in a prison colony. Lukin isn’t happy with the result:

“It is a misdemeanour that in a normal, civilised European state is handled in administrative rather than criminal proceedings. That’s why I think the ruling on those women is excessive,” he told a news conference when asked about the case. [...]

He said he hoped an appeals court would “more carefully consider all the aspects of this case” and that as ombudsman he had the right to challenge the verdict once it entered into force if he believed human rights had been violated.

“If the sentence remains the same … I will analyse this thoroughly,” he said.

Lukin said the situation is indicative of what is happening throughout Russia:

“It is regrettable that a poisonous substance of intolerance and brutality is spreading in our society. Recently it has become typical and even fashionable not to discuss problems but to lash about at one another,” Lukin said.

The instinct for dialogue is fading and the fighting instinct is coming into the foreground. This is very dangerous.”

Putin has cracked down hard on dissent, approving new laws restricting public assembly and approving raids on anti-Putin activists’ homes. Russian Wikipedia recently went dark to protest increasing censorship and indeed, the Pussy Riot affair is by no means an isolated one.

NEWS FLASH

Poll: Republicans Strongly Dislike Muslims | 57 percent of Republicans hold strongly negative views of Muslims, according to a poll released today by the Arab American Institute. Just 26 percent hold favorable views of Muslims, while Arabs are equally unpopular among Republicans — 53 percent negative versus 27 positive. The numbers improved slightly when asked about “Muslim Americans” and “Arab Americans.” Democrats, on the other hand, viewed Muslims and Arab Americans favorably by margins of at least 20 to 35 percent in all four cases, though Democrats and Republicans alike had less positive feelings toward Muslims than any other religious group.

NEWS FLASH

Paul Ryan Holds Event Criticizing The Military Spending Sequester He Voted For | At a round table discussion in North Carolina Thursday, vice presidential candidate Paul Ryan tried to pin the blame for the budget sequester squarely on the shoulders of President Obama, despite the fact that Ryan himself voted in favor of the sequester. The bill triggers automatic spending cuts to a variety of government programs including military spending if Congress cannot pass a budget by January first. Ryan has tried to distance himself from those military spending cuts, and today claimed that he and other Republicans “disagreed with [the sequester] then, we disagree with it now.” In fact, 174 Republicans voted in favor of the sequester, including Ryan. Watch him claim the opposite at his event:

Fox News Publishes Name Of SEAL Who Led Bin Laden Raid

Fox News today published the name of a U.S. Navy SEAL who led the raid on Osama bin Laden’s compound in Pakistan last year that ended up in the al-Qaeda leader’s death. The SEAL under the pseudonym Mark Owen is the author of a book set to be released on Sept. 11 detailing the events of the raid. The book’s publisher says Owen “was one of the first men through the door on the third floor of the terrorist leader’s hideout and was present at his death.”

Fox News said that “multiple sources” told the news outlet Owen’s real name but Fox did not provide any details about its decision to publish it. The book seemingly provides some clues as to the SEAL’s real identity as, according to the New York Times, Owen “recalls his childhood in Alaska.”

Defense Department, CIA and White House officials said they have not reviewed the content of Owen’s book and that they first heard of its existence from media reports. And as the Fox report publishing Owen’s name notes, he “could be exposing himself to legal trouble, as the Pentagon has not vetted the account“:

Lt. Cmdr. Chris Servello, a Navy spokesman, said it’s possible [Owen] or any former service member could be punished for revealing national security secrets. “Any service member who discloses classified or sensitive information could be subject to prosecution — this doesn’t end when you leave the service,” Servello said. “There is nothing unique to the special warfare community in this regard.”

Current and former SEALs criticized Owen for speaking out. “How do we tell our guys to stay quiet when this guy won’t?” one SEAL told Fox while others reportedly called Owen a “traitor.”

Mother Jones’s Adam Weinstein notes that Justin Fishel, the Fox News reporter who revealed Owen’s name, also reported last year that the SEALs who participated in the bin Laden raid wanted to protect their identities out of concern for their safety. “There has been a consistent and effective effort to protect the identity of those that participated in the raid and I think that that has to continue,” Fishel reported then-Defense Secretary Robert Gates saying at the time.

Update

Business Insider has now published photos of Owen

NEWS FLASH

U.N. Nuclear Watchdog Creates Special Iran Team | The International Atomic Energy Agency, the U.N.’s nuclear watchdog, announced today that it has set up a special unit that deals specifically with Iran and its nuclear program. Diplomats told the Associated Press that the team will bring together “sleuths in weapons technology, intelligence analysis, radiation and other fields of expertise.” The AP reports that “creating a unit focused on only one country is an unusual move” for the IAEA and that it reflects “the priority it attaches to Iran amid fears it is moving closer to the ability to make nuclear weapons.”

U.S. Officials Unaware Of Navy SEAL’s Book Recounting Bin Laden Raid

The New York Times reported yesterday that a U.S. Navy SEAL who led the special operations team that raided Osama bin Laden’s compound in Pakistan last year has written a book describing the events in detail. The existence of the book, which is titled “No Easy Day: The Firsthand Account of the Mission That Killed Osama bin Laden,” has been a “closely held secret” within Penguin, the publishing house that is planning to release it next month on Sept. 11, and the SEAL is writing anonymously under the pseudonym Mark Owen.

But neither the author, nor Penguin, submitted the book to U.S. government officials for review, a normal process for publications divulging such highly classified information:

“As far as we can determine, this book was not submitted for pre-publication review,” said CIA spokesman Preston Golson.

Pentagon spokesman George Little said he was “unaware that anyone in the department has reviewed it.”

White House officials said they knew nothing of the book.

We learned about this book today from press reports,” said Tommy Vietor, spokesman for the National Security Council. “We haven’t reviewed it and don’t know what it says.”

The book’s publication could reignite the controversy surrounding national security leaks and the Washington Post notes that it’s unclear at this point “whether the CIA or Pentagon would take legal steps against the author or attempt to stop publication.”

However, Penguin is expecting the book to be a top seller and retailers agree. “This sort of book is too often what I call a F.I.P., flash in the pan, with good sales for a week or so after the initial publicity,” a book seller in Denver told the Times. “But this one may have legs into the holidays.”

National Security Brief: First Lady Announces Jobs For Vets


– First lady Michelle Obama announced yesterday that 2,000 businesses around the country have hired or trained more than 125,000 military veterans and spouses in the past year, exceeding a White House goal of 100,000 by the end of next year.

– The Afghan government has blamed foreign spy agencies for the so-called “green on blue” attacks, putting President Hamid Karzai’s position directly at odds with NATO’s assessment of the crisis.

– The Wall Street Journal reports: The U.S. is planning a major expansion of missile defenses in Asia, a move American officials say is designed to contain threats from North Korea, but one that could also be used to counter China’s military.

– According to the United Nations, nearly 200,000 Syrians have fled the country to escape the increasing violence there while an estimated 2.5 million have been affected by the fighting, including 1.2 internally displaced persons.

– South Africa’s government has adopted a regulation to prevent the labeling of goods from the West Bank as being produced in Israel. The government said goods should now be labeled as originating from the “Israeli Occupied Territories.”

– U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon’s decision to attend the Nonaligned Movement summit in Tehran is being seen as a setback in efforts to isolate Iran. Meanwhile, a State Department spokesperson said yesterday that there is still time for diplomacy to work with the Islamic Republic over its nuclear program.

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up