ThinkProgress Logo

Security

Obama Says Defense Bill Interferes With Executive Powers On Detainees

The newly signed funding bill for the U.S. national security budget has a message for the White House: take more time before letting suspected terror detainees out of your sight.

As part of the Fiscal Year 2013 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), Congress has approved provisions that hinder the Executive Branch’s ability to release and transfer detainees from the Parwan Base in Afghanistan. Specifically, Sec. 1025 of the legislation mandates that the Secretary of Defense conduct assessments and provide notification to Congress before transfer or release of third-party nationals captured in Afghanistan.

These assessments — required for each individual leaving U.S. custody — include an examination of a government’s ability to properly try or monitor the released captive, even if the detainee is being remanded to Afghan custody. Meanwhile, Sections 1027 and 1028 ban the use of funds to transfer detainees from Guantanamo Bay prison to the United States for trial and places similar restrictions on the transfer and release of detainees to other countries.

Despite threats to veto the bill, President Obama signed the FY13 NDAA on Wednesday night. In doing so, however, he also issued a “signing statement” delcaring that the Executive Branch believes portions of legislation to be void should it interfere with Constitutional prerogatives of the Executive. In particular, Obama’s signing statement focused on the detainee restrictions of the Act:

Decisions regarding the disposition of detainees captured on foreign battlefields have traditionally been based upon the judgment of experienced military commanders and national security professionals without unwarranted interference by Members of Congress. Section 1025 threatens to upend that tradition, and could interfere with my ability as Commander in Chief to make time-sensitive determinations about the appropriate disposition of detainees in an active area of hostilities. Under certain circumstances, the section could violate constitutional separation of powers principles. If Section 1025 operates in a manner that violates constitutional separation of powers principles, my Administration will implement it to avoid the constitutional conflict.

While an aide to a senior Senator said the FY2013 NDAA adds no additional requirements on the transfer or release of detainees, Hina Shamsi, Director of the American Civil Liberties Union’s National Security Project agreed that Congress has further tied the Executive’s hands. “It makes it much harder to transfer people out who should be. It is the same problem as with Congress putting restrictions in the way of closing Guantanamo Bay, in that unlawful detention has weakened us from a national security perspective,” she said of the NDAA’s language. Shamsi went on to call the President’s signing statement “anemic,” noting that he should follow-through under whatever discretion he has under the law to “put teeth” into his declaration. The ACLU has long been outspoken against the detention polices of both the Bush and Obama administrations.

Detention policy is returning to the spotlight amid reports that rendition — or the holding of suspected terrorists in third-countries — continues under the Obama administration. Likewise, attempts from the ACLU and New York Times to obtain memos laying out the criteria behind the so-called “kill list” were denied by a District Court judge on Wednesday, drawing renewed attention to the debate between killing and capturing suspected terrorists.

LGBT

Obama Condemns Military ‘Conscience Clause’ As He Signs Defense Budget

President Obama has signed the National Defense Authorization Act, but he issued several signing statements qualifying his measured support of its various provisions. In particular, he condemned the “conscience clause” included in the conference version of the bill, a watered-down version of the “license to discriminate” proposed by Rep. Todd Akin (R-MO) last year. President Obama made it clear he will not tolerate any attempt to promote anti-gay views in the military:

Section 533 is an unnecessary and ill-advised provision, as the military already appropriately protects the freedom of conscience of chaplains and service members. The Secretary of Defense will ensure that the implementing regulations do not permit or condone discriminatory actions that compromise good order and discipline or otherwise violate military codes of conduct. My Administration remains fully committed to continuing the successful implementation of the repeal of Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell, and to protecting the rights of gay and lesbian service members; Section 533 will not alter that.

The final version of the language was so softened from its original proposal so as to simply be a redundant iteration of protections that already exist ensuring servicemembers cannot be penalized for their beliefs. Still, its inclusion represents conservatives’ latest attempt to protect anti-gay discrimination and stigma under the shroud of “religious freedom.”

National Security Brief: Senate Panel To Investigate ‘Zero Dark Thirty’


Reuters reports that the Senate Intelligence Committee will investigate contacts between CIA officials and the makers of the film “Zero Dark Thirty” after Sen. Diane Feinstein (D-CA) and other senators expressed concern that the movie — which depicts the events leading up to and including the death of Osama bin Laden — implies that torture helped locate the al-Qaeda leader. Sources told Reuters that investigators “will examine whether the spy agency gave the filmmakers ‘inappropriate’ access to secret material” and “whether CIA personnel are responsible for the portrayal of harsh interrogation practices, and in particular the suggestion that they were effective.”

In other news:

  • President Obama signed the $633 billion defense bill that he had previously threatened to veto because of limits on his authority to transfer prisoners from Guantanamo Bay. The bill includes more sanctions on Iran and increased funding for diplomatic security abroad.
  • The New York Times reports: Gen. John R. Allen, the senior American commander in Afghanistan, has submitted military options to the Pentagon that would keep 6,000 to 20,000 American troops in Afghanistan after 2014. … General Allen offered Defense Secretary Leon E. Panetta three plans with different troop levels: 6,000, 10,000 and 20,000, each with a risk factor probably attached to it.
  • The U.N. reported yesterday that as many as 60,000 Syrians have died during the country’s two-year long civil war. But the U.N.-Arab League Syria peace envoy Lakhdar Brahimi warned that 100,000 more could be killed in the next year.
  • (Photo: Sony Pictures)

    Switch to Mobile
    ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

    Sign Up