ThinkProgress Logo

Security

Kerry Condemns Turkish Prime Minister’s ‘Objectionable’ Zionism Comments

(Photo: AFP)

Secretary of State John Kerry on Friday said Turkish Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan’s comment that Zionism is “a crime against humanity” is “objectionable,” echoing the White House’s reaction today, saying his remarks are “offensive and wrong.”

Erdogan made the comments on Wednesday, speaking at a United Nations-sponored event meant to try to bridge the gap between Islam and the West. Instead, Erdogan managed to widen the divide:

“We should be striving to better understand the culture and beliefs of others, but instead we see that people act based on prejudice and exclude others and despise them,” Erdogan said, according to a simultaneous translation provided by the UN. “And that is why it is necessary that we must consider — just like Zionism or anti-Semitism or fascism — Islamophobia as a crime against humanity.”

“We not only disagree with it, we found it objectionable,” Kerry said during a press conference in Ankara with Turkish foreign minister Ahmet Davutoglu. According to Reuters, Kerry said he personally raised the issue with Davutaglu and will do so with Erdogan.

“That said, Turkey and Israel are both vital allies of the United States and we want to see them work together in order to be able to go beyond the rhetoric and begin to take concrete steps to change this relationship,” Kerry added.

United Nations Secretary General Ban Ki-moon’s office said it’s “unfortunate that such hurtful and divisive comments were uttered at a meeting being held under the theme of responsible leadership.”

CAP’s Matt Duss and Michael Werz also condemned Erdogan’s comments on Thursday. “While Prime Minister Erdogan’s outrageous comments seem intended to isolate Israel, they also threaten to further isolate Turkey,” they wrote, adding that his comments ” seemed like an attitude from a bygone era. Casting Zionism together with anti-Semitism, fascism, and Islamophobia in this way is not only deeply offensive but also quite historically inaccurate and has the potential to promote or justify violence.”

Foreign Policy Heavyweights Discuss Climate Change’s Effects On Arab Spring

Former State Department Director of Policy Planning Anne-Marie Slaughter and New York Times columnist Tom Friedman engaged in an hour and a half discussion with CAP moderator Michael Werz on Thursday, heralding the release of a new series of essays related to the link between climate change and insecurity titled “The Arab Spring and Climate Change.”

A product of CAP, the Stimson Center, and the Center for Climate and Security, the report collects five essays that show how what were once local issues have become global, showing for example how a drought in China led to increased food prices in Egypt. In the preface to the report, Slaughter borrowed the concept of a “stressor” — a “sudden change in circumstances or environment” that interacts with various other factors that leads to sudden change — from criminal science to show how climate change acts to “ignite a volatile mix of underlying causes to erupt into revolution.” Those stressors include the way weather patterns effect the migration of peoples and shifting climates’ contribution to food insecurity, which serve as a multiplier of other factors blocking sustainable security.

Speaking before a packed house at CAP, Friedman implored the audience to think of the Middle East not by the current national borders, but instead envisioning as overlaid maps of culture and climate to understand the region. Slaughter took the concept a step further, adding in maps of political networks — government, corporate, NGOs, and others — and seeing where the larger “nodes” in those networks exist. Tracing where those nodes intersect, Slaughter said, shows where policy can be made.

Climate change overlaps with both a decentralization of foreign policy making and an increase in the technology that may be able to fix it, according to Slaughter and Friedman. Decision-making is spreading away from solely being governments interacting with each other and into a more dispersed framework, Slaughter said, citing the reporting of air quality by the U.S. Embassy in Beijing, China, which is then picked up by Chinese nationals. Referring to the interconnected networks that the Internet facilitates, Slaughter said she wants to “see the world like the Millennials see it.”

As the population of people in the world having the same standard of living as the United States increases, Friedman said, so too will the dangers associated with climate change. Modern technology is showing the ability to help fight that, Friedman said. He provided the example of how the combination of a new ID law, advancing IT infrastructure, and emerging energy technology can allow villagers in India to refrain from moving into larger cities, lowering carbon emissions in the process.

Speaking to ThinkProgress after the event, Slaughter advised those seeking to help prevent further climate change, and the insecurity it brings, to “consider where they are in the network they’re trying to influence.” Global cities and states topped the list of those networks whose combined influence would be able to affect change on the global stage. “Then think, ‘Where am I placed?’ and my point is, you want to be in or be able to influence the central node,” Slaughter continued. That might mean cooperation between individual actors or linking between networks, through reaching out to corporations or local governments.

Watch the full event HERE.

National Security Brief: EU Says Israeli Settlements Are ‘Biggest Single Threat’ To Two-State Solution


Los Angeles Times reports on a new internal European Report that is highly critical of Israel’s settlement enterprise in the West Bank and East Jerusalem. The Times says the EU report calls the Israeli government’s settlement policies “the biggest single threat to the two-state solution.” And as the Financial Times reported on Thursday, that the same EU report recommends “curbing trade, investment and tourism in Jewish settlements in the West Bank and east Jerusalem.”

“Israel is actively perpetuating its illegal annexation of east Jerusalem by systematically undermining the Palestinian presence through restrictive zoning and planning,” the report says.

It’s unlikely the EU will officially boycott any settlement products however, as the Financial Times notes, “A UK official said there were no plans to introduce EU or domestic legislation to ban Israeli settlement products.”

According to the L.A. Times, the new EU report said that settlements and their expansion are “part of a political strategy aimed at making it impossible for Jerusalem to become the capital of two states.”

“We are disappointed by this report because rather than building bridges between parties, as diplomats should, the European Union consuls once again have issued a one-sided report that only serves to inflame the situation,” said David Siegel, Israeli consul general in Los Angeles.

But, the L.A. Times adds that Alon Ben-Meir, a professor of Middle East studies and conflict resolution at New York University, said that Israel is “building a garrison state,” referring to the settlement project and military forces deployed to protect them, adding that it “is isolating by its very nature.” “Israel needs to think how long this can be sustained. Can Israelis live another 50 years behind barbed wire and walls?” he asked.

In other news:

  • Secretary of State John Kerry upon his visit to Turkey plans to admonish Turkish Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan for his comments calling Zionism “a crime against humanity.” “It is in both Turkey’s and the United States’ interest to heal tensions between Israel and Turkey,” CAP’s Matt Duss and Michael Werz wrote on Thursday, “Prime Minister Erdogan’s incendiary remarks make that more difficult and act against Turkey’s long-term national interest.”
  • Wired’s Danger Room reports: Wearing his Army dress uniform, a composed, intense and articulate Pfc. Bradley Manning took “full responsibility” Thursday for providing the anti-secrecy organization WikiLeaks with a trove of classified and sensitive military, diplomatic and intelligence cables, videos and documents.
  • The New York Times reports: At some point on Friday (no one will say precisely when), President Obama will formally notify government agencies that an obscure process known as sequestration is in effect, triggering deep, across-the-board budget cuts that will force federal spending to shrink.
  • Switch to Mobile
    ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

    Sign Up