ThinkProgress Home
ThinkProgress
ThinkProgress Logo

Stories tagged with “Evolution

NEWS FLASH

Petition Urges Veto Of Tennessee ‘Monkey Bill’ | More than 3,000 people signed a petition urging Tennessee Gov. Bill Haslam (R) to veto legislation which would require public schools to teach the “controversy” surrounding topics like evolution and global warming. Opponents of the bill delivered the petition to Haslam’s office yesterday, where a spokesman said he would make sure the Governor received it. The bill passed the House last year and was approved by the Senate last month. Critics have called the legislation a “monkey bill” in reference to the Scopes “monkey trial” held in Tennessee in 1925, when a biology teacher was convicted for teaching evolution. The bill is also opposed by several newspapers and scientific organizations. Haslam has previously said he would “probably” sign the bill.

Zachary Bernstein

Justice

Anti-Evolution ‘Monkey Bill’ Poised To Become Law In Tennessee

Tennessee Gov. Bill Haslam (R) announced yesterday that he will “probably” sign a bill that attacks the teaching of “biological evolution, the chemical origins of life, global warming, and human cloning” by giving broad new legal immunities to teachers who question evolution and other widely accepted scientific theories. Under the bill, which passed the state legislature last month:

Neither the state board of education, nor any public elementary or secondary school governing authority, director of schools, school system administrator, or any public elementary or secondary school principal or administrator shall prohibit any teacher in a public school system of this state from helping students understand, analyze, critique, and review in an objective manner the scientific strengths and scientific weaknesses of existing scientific theories covered in the course being taught.

Although the bill is written to seem benign, as it neither specifically authorizes the teaching of creationism nor permits teachers to do more than criticize scientific theories “in an objective matter,” the practical impact of this bill will be to intimidate all but the heartiest of school administrators against disciplining teachers who preach the most outlandish junk science in their classrooms. Because the bill provides little guidance as to what constitutes an “objective” criticism of a scientific theory, any principal who reigns in teachers who force creationism or Pastafarianism upon their students risks finding themselves on the wrong side of the law.

In reality, of course, there are few, if any, “objectively” valid objections to the theory of evolution (or, for that matter, to global warming). Rather, as Travis Waldron explained when this bill passed a legislative committee nearly a year ago, “Scientists have reached a consensus that evolution is ‘one of the most robust and widely accepted principles of modern science,’ and as such, it is ‘a core element in science education.’”

Alyssa

Louis C.K. Comes To Washington — As A Dinner Speaker

Business Insider has pretty much the best headline announcing this news: “Some People Who Don’t Know Louis CK’s Material Very Well Just Booked Him for the Congressional Correspondents Dinner.” I like C.K. in part because his jokes are psychological, and often oriented towards making people recognize their common experiences and values. But it’s true that they aren’t the kind of zippy political one-liners that someone like Stephen Colbert can toss off all day. So here are five things that C.K. should do when he comes to Washington:

1. Get at the audience’s failure to ask the important questions of the day, like whether Donald Rumsfeld is a lizard from outer space who eats human flesh:

2. Washington is ridiculously full of powerful white people. Remind them how awesome their lives are — and that they aren’t necessarily responsible for that awesomeness:

3. Point out a fundamental an uncomfortable truth: no matter how tough reporters are, and no matter what their political leanings are, people get star-struck by proximity to the president (starts at 3:15):

4. If you take one policy position, go hard on evolution and its deniers. Please:

5. Remember: your Sarah Palin jokes are not your funniest (or best) work of the past couple of years:

Politics

Bachmann: Teaching Only Evolution Is ‘Censorship’

At an education forum at the University of Northern Iowa this afternoon, GOP presidential hopeful Rep. Michele Bachmann (R-MN) said she favored the teaching of intelligent design and creationism in schools, saying that just teaching the science of evolution would be “censorship by government.” Asked by a Catholic student why it’s not a violation of the separation of church and state for a public school to teach the religiously-tinged theories, Bachmann said evolution is just a “theory” that even “evolutionists” are not sure of:

BACHMANN: I think what you’re advocating for is censorship on the part of government. So the government would prohibit intelligent design from even the possibility of being taught in questioning the issueof evolution. And if you look at scientists there is not a unanimity of agreement on the origins of life. … Why would we forstall any particular theory? Becuase I don’t think that even evolutionists, by and large, would say that this is proven fact. They say that this is a theory, as well as intelligent design. So I think the best thing to do is to let all scientific facts on the table, and let students decide.

Watch it:

Bachmann joins Texas Gov. Rick Perry (R-TX), who said evolution was merely “a theory that’s out there.”

Of course, the difference here is that evolution is science — creationism and intelligent design are not. All of the world’s leading scientific organizations have affirmed evolution and dismissed intelligent design, noting that teaching it alongside evolution is counterproductive, as it would give the pseudo-science credibility. As the American Association for the Advancement of Science has repeatedly stated, “evolution is one of the most robust and widely accepted principles of modern science;” teaching intelligent design “would undermine” the teaching of science, just as teaching false mathematics or alternative history would.

NEWS FLASH

Huntsman: Rick Perry Is ‘Outside Of The Mainstream’ On Science | “If you’re going to run from climate science, if you’re going to run from other mainstream scientific principles, evolution among them, I think you’re suggesting to a whole lot of people out there that you’re out of the mainstream,” Huntsman told Bloomberg’s “Political Capital With Al Hunt.” “Rick has been outspoken in that regard,” Huntsman said. “I think on science he’s out of the mainstream.”

Climate Progress

Huntsman Slams Perry on Climate and Evolution: We Are “On the Wrong Side of Science and Therefore in a Losing Position.”

Last week, Jon Huntsman began to call out Governor Rick “4 Pinocchios” Perry and others in his party for being anti-science.  He started with the tweet above that went viral.

On ABC’s This Week, Huntsman went even further, explaining that being anti-science would harm his party — and America’s future:

TAPPER: These comments from Governor Perry prompted you to Tweet, quote:  “To be clear, I believe in evolution and trust scientists on global warming.  Call me crazy.” Were you just being cheeky or do you think there’s a serious problem with what Governor Perry said?

HUNTSMAN:  I think there’s a serious problem.  The minute that the Republican Party becomes the party – the anti-science party, we have a huge problem.  We lose a whole lot of people who would otherwise allow us to win the election in 2012.  When we take a position that isn’t willing to embrace evolution, when we take a position that basically runs counter to what 98 of 100 climate scientists have said, what the National Academy of Science – Sciences has said about what is causing climate change and man’s contribution to it, I think we find ourselves on the wrong side of science, and, therefore, in a losing position.

The Republican Party has to remember that we’re drawing from traditions that go back as far as Abraham Lincoln, Theodore Roosevelt, President Eisenhower, Nixon, Reagan and Bush.  And we’ve got a lot of traditions to draw upon.  But I can’t remember a time in our history where we actually were willing to shun science and become a – a party that – that was antithetical to science. I’m not sure that’s good for our future and it’s not a winning formula.

Whether it’s bad for the Republican party remains to be seen — that would require President Obama and his team (and other progressive politicians) to push back in the general election the way Huntsman has in the GOP race.

But there’s no question that having one of the two major political parties in the most powerful country in the world being anti-science is a disaster for the nation and the world (see WashPost stunner: “The GOP’s climate-change denial may be its most harmful delusion”).  I’ll be expanding on that position in the coming weeks, but what is interesting is that in the full online interview with ABC (video below), Huntsman himself starts to explain just how counterproductive and self-destructive it is for the party:

Read more

Politics

Rick Perry: ‘I Don’t Have Any Idea’ How Old The Earth Is; Evolution’s A ‘Theory’ That’s ‘Got Some Gaps In It’

During a campaign stop in New Hampshire today, a young child asked Texas Gov. Rick Perry how old he thinks the Earth is. The question stems from the fact that many science-deniers promote a ludicrous theory called Young Earth Creationism, which contends that the Earth is less than 10,000 years old. It is not known if Perry himself subscribes to this theory, but many of his appointees do, including Don McLeroy, a devoted Young Earth Creationist who was tapped to chair the State Board of Education.

Yet Perry’s response to the child did little to assuage fears that the Texas governor lacks a firm grip on science. Said Perry, “How old do I think the Earth is? I don’t have any idea. I think it’s pretty old.” Perry then brought up the issue of evolution. After dismissing it as just “a theory that’s out there” with “some gaps in it,” Perry went on to tout the fact that Texas teaches “both creationism and evolution in our programs.”

KID: How old do you think the Earth is?

PERRY: How old do I think the Earth is? I don’t have any idea. I think it’s pretty old. It goes back a long long ways. I’m not sure anybody actually knows completely and absolutely how long ago the Earth is. I hear your mom was asking about evolution. It’s a theory that’s out there and it’s got some gaps in it. In Texas, we teach both creationism and evolution in our programs.

Despite Perry’s claim that “[nobody] knows completely and absolutely how long ago the Earth is,” in fact, scientists have a precise answer: 4.54 billion years old.

His admission that he doesn’t “have any idea” how old the Earth is underscores a recurring charge against his candidacy: not unlike the last Texan to win the presidency, Perry is not a firm believer in scientific evidence, no matter how overwhelming. Indeed, just yesterday, Perry argued that climate scientists are a “secular carbon cult” who had “manipulated data” for money. Perry is a climate science-denier who dismissed the threat of global warming to Texas, even as the state suffers through a massive heat wave and drought. The Texas Governor has even called for a moratorium on “all regulations,” including those from the Environmental Protection Agency.

Given Perry’s denial of evolution and ignorance of approximately how old the Earth is, it’s no surprise that his scientific daftness led a spokesman for former Utah Gov. Jon Huntsman (R) to argue, “science clearly was not a mandatory course for Governor Perry.”

NEWS FLASH

VIDEO: Rick Perry Says Evolution Is ‘A Theory That’s Out There’ Like Creationism | Asked about evolution at a campaign stop in Portsmouth, NH, Gov. Rick Perry (R-TX) said that the scientific understanding of natural selection is on par with a literalist interpretation of the Bible. “It’s a theory that’s out there. It’s got some gaps in it. In Texas, we teach both creation and evolution our public schools because I figure you’re smart enough to figure which one is right,” he told a young child, after explaining “I don’t have any idea” how old the earth is.

Update

Fact check: Despite Perry’s efforts, Texas schools teach evolutionary science, not creationism, although the teaching standards are biased against facts.

Update

Climate Progress

‘Huge Science Geek’ Wins Miss USA — One Of Only a Few Contestants Who Appear to Understand the Evolution Issue!

Miss California earned her way into the semifinals in preliminary judging including interviews in which she was one of only two among 51 contestants to unequivocally support teaching evolution.

The newly crowned Miss USA, Alyssa Campanella, 21, of LA, said:

I was taught evolution in high school. I do believe in it. I’m a huge science geek…. I like to believe in the big bang theory and, you know, the evolution of humans throughout time.

Here’s the video (followed by a head-exploding video of some of the answers by other contestants):

Read more

NEWS FLASH

Bachmann Doubts Evolution, Wants Schools To Teach Intelligent Design | Speaking to reporters outside the Republican Leadership Conference in New Orleans, LA today, Rep. Michele Bachmann (R-MN) said she wants schools to teach students the creationist theory of intelligent design, because, she said, “What I support is putting all science on the table and then letting students decide.” Of course, intelligent design is not science. Saying, “I support intelligent design,” Bachmann called for using taxpayer dollars to teach the religious theory to students though federal block grants to the states.

Older

Switch to Mobile