ThinkProgress Logo

Stories tagged with “Financial Transaction Tax

NEWS FLASH

French President To Introduce Financial Transactions Tax | According to the BBC, French President Nicolas Sarkozy intends to introduce a 0.1 percent financial transactions tax in August, regardless of whether or not other countries do the same. “What we want to do is create a shockwave and set an example that there is absolutely no reason why those who helped bring about the crisis shouldn’t pay to restore the finances,” Sarkozy said, estimating that the tax will raise about $1 billion Euros. According to the Center for Economic and Policy Research, a transactions tax in the U.S. could raise tens of billions of dollars per year, while reducing dangerous market speculation and increasing productive investments.

Special Topic

GOP Rep. Mike Simpson Can’t Recall If He Supports A Financial Transaction Tax: ‘You’ll Have To Look It Up’

Why won't Rep. Mike Simpson (R-ID) come clean on his position on an FTT?

One way for the 99 Percent to reclaim some of the wealth that the nation’s biggest banks destroyed is with a Financial Transactions Tax. This tax would be placed on the trading of certain financial products and even a small tax would amass as much as $350 billion in revenues annually.

Yesterday morning, journalist Sam Husseini asked Reps. Heath Shuler (D-NC) and Mike Simpson (R-ID) about why many in Congress are focusing on cuts for the poor and middle class but not taxing the super-wealthy. After Shuler and Simpson refused to commit to an answer on this broader question, Husseini asked Simpson about the FTT. Holding up a carton of band-aids, Husseini asked, “Let me ask you this: yesterday I went to a pharmacy and there’s a tax on Band-Aids. Why isn’t there a tax on financial transactions? I had to pay a 6 percent tax on Band-Aids that people need?” Simpson kept dodging the question and finally told Husseini to go look up his position as he walked away:

HUSSEINI: Let me ask you this: yesterday I went to a pharmacy and there’s a tax on Band-Aids. Why isn’t there a tax on financial transactions? I had to pay a 6 percent tax on Band-Aids that people need.

SIMPSON: Probably a state sales tax, right?

HUSSEINI: What’s your position on financial transaction tax?

SIMPSON: You’d have to look it up.

HUSSEINI: Why can’t JP Morgan pay its transaction tax on their dealings?

Watch it:

It’s bizarre that Simpson can’t seem to remember his position on an issue as important as the FTT. Or maybe the congressman was simply feigning ignorance to avoid commenting on an idea that may offend the banks that have been donating to his 2012 re-election campaign. (HT: @jeremyscahill)

Economy

Bill Gates Champions A Financial Transactions Tax: ‘This Money Could Be Well Spent And Make A Difference’

While Republicans resist any attempt to address growing income inequality, more and more of America’s wealthy are asking to pay their fair share. Joining billionaire Warren Buffet, Microsoft founder Bill Gates recently issued his support for “millionaires and billionaires” paying more in taxes.

Now, Gates is taking it a step further and traveling to the G-20 meeting in Cannes, France today to champion the “Robin Hood tax” — a small financial transaction tax on each stock and bond trade — in order to help financially strapped developed nations meet their global aid pledges to the poor. Aware that countries like the U.S. are not currently receptive to this or any taxes, Gates told the Guardian that hopes his “credibility” lends credence to the idea that such taxes work:

Speaking to the Guardian on the eve of the summit, Gates said: “It is very plausible that certain kinds of FTTs could work. I am lending some credibility to that. This money could be well spent and make a difference. An FTT is more possible now than it was a year ago, but it won’t be at rates that magically raise gigantic sums of money.” [...]

[His] report identifies an FTT as one of three ways of raising money. Gates will tell the G20 that it could garner almost $11bn for health aid projects if all members levied tobacco excise taxes of at least 70% of the pack price and earmarked a slice of the revenue for development. Small taxes on shipping and aviation fuel could raise $37bn and $27bn respectively, the report says.

Gates is not alone in his effort. Yesterday, Sen. Tom Harkin (D-IA) and Rep. Peter DeFazio (D-OR) introduced legislation that proposes a 0.03 percent tax on financial transactions that could raise $150 billion to “invest in our future, our infrastructure and our middle class.” As TP Economy editor Pat Garofalo notes, the tax — which has been embraced by the Occupy Wall Street protests, the governments of France and Germany, and even the Archbishop of Canterbury — could raise serious revenue while slowing down some of the high frequency trading that “mega-banks like Goldman Sachs employ to churn up quick profits.”

DeFazio told ThinkProgress that while Gates’ stated purpose for the tax may be different, he welcomes Gates’ support for an idea already proven to work. He noted that the United Kingdom already imposes a 0.25 percent transaction tax on the sale or purchase of stocks which, as Center For Economic Policy and Research notes, “has very little impact on people who buy stock with the intent of holding it for a long period of time” but will deter those who high frequency trades that exacerbate or lead to market crashes. The policy helps return Wall Street to its days as a place “where people with good ideas go to raise capital” for production rather than a place for “gambling” schemes, said DeFazio.

NEWS FLASH

Democratic Lawmakers To Introduce Financial Transactions Tax | Sen. Tom Harkin (D-IA) and Rep. Peter DeFazio (D-OR) today plan to introduce a bill that would impose a tiny tax on financial transactions. The 0.03 percent tax on financial trades is meant to “give the United States an increased role in the international debate over a transaction tax, which is likely to be discussed at the Group of 20 summit this week in Cannes, France.” The call for a financial transactions tax has been embraced by the Occupy Wall Street protesters, the nation’s largest nurses’ union, the governments of France and Germany, and even the Archbishop of Canterbury. A small tax on transactions would hardly be felt by ordinary investors, but could raise significant revenue and slow down some of the high frequency trading that mega-banks like Goldman Sachs employ to churn up quick profits.

Economy

Calling Wall Street A ‘Gambling Casino,’ Democratic Rep. DeFazio Proposes Financial Transactions Tax

Rep. Peter DeFazio (D-OR)

Echoing the demands of the Occupy Wall Street protesters, Rep. Peter DeFazio (D-OR) is proposing to tax the trading of stocks, bonds, and derivatives. DeFazio, along with his Senate co-sponsor Sen. Tom Harkin (D-IA), has proposed the tax several times in the past. But this time around, the idea is getting a boost of momentum from the popularity of a similar measure in Europe, as well as renewed national media focus on Wall Street profiteering as a result of the 99 Percent Movement:

Declaring Wall Street a “gambling casino,” DeFazio said the new tax would “both raise needed revenue for the Treasury and rein in speculation on Wall Street.”

Already, the business community is mounting a counteroffensive. With the congressional supercommittee looking to trim at least $1.2 trillion in projected debt over 10 years, the tax could look tantalizing, despite public opposition from many Republicans and Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner. [...]

The tax could help shrink the deficit — its previous iteration was estimated to add $150 billion a year to federal coffers — and spare Social Security, Medicare and other programs from jarring cuts.

Even representatives from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce admit that this proposal is going to receive serious consideration this session, as congressional Democrats look to trim the deficit in a way that doesn’t overburden the middle and lower classes that are already stretched to the breaking point. “In reality, a proposal like this is going to be on the table in some regard,” said Tom Quaadman, executive director for financial reporting policy and investor opportunity at the U.S. Chamber of Commerce.

France and Germany have embraced taxing financial trades, and proponents say it’s only a matter of time before the common-sense solution is finally adopted in the U.S. While American bankers are predicting dire consequences if the tax goes into effect, Dean Baker, a co-director at the Center for Economic and Policy Research, says that’s nonsense. “The reality is all you’re doing is raising transaction costs back to where they were 15 or 20 years ago,” he says, noting that the tax has not prevented countries like the United Kingdom from developing vibrant economies.

Top economists and analysts like Reuters’ Felix Salmon have long advocated for a transaction tax as an important moderating influence on Wall Street excess. As Pat Garofolo has explained, “It will help temper trading for trading’s sake and excessive speculation, particularly in the form of high-frequency trading, which only major Wall Street players have the infrastructure to engage in and which will become far more expensive.”

Economy

Nation’s Largest Nurses Union Says Tax Wall Street To Heal America

ThinkProgress filed this report from the Occupy Wall Street demonstration in New York City.

While at the Occupy Wall Street protests, ThinkProgress spoke to Ken Zinn, a staffer with the National Nurses Union — the nation’s largest nurses union, with nearly 160,000 members. Zinn’s group is pushing for a financial transactions tax (FTT), which would enact a small tax on financial trading that could generate hundreds of billions of dollars every year.

Zinn says his group was motivated to join the protests and demand the tax because their patients all over the country are hurting, and it’s “time that Wall Street gave back to this country”:

ZINN: We’ve been calling for a tax on Wall Street for several months now because our nurses are seeing on the job, each and every day in hospitals across the country patients who are suffering, patients who are in great need because they’re without a job and having to make a decision whether or not to buy food or pay for medicine, buy food or pay their rent. [...] We’re here because it’s time that Wall Street gave back to this country. And it’s a small tax that we’re proposing on the buying and selling of stocks and bonds and derivatives that would bring in, by our estimation, $350 billion every year into the economy.

Watch ThinkProgress’s interview with Zinn:

While the United States continues to watch the profits of bailed out banks soar, the European Union is expected to move forward on a push for a global financial transactions tax.

Yglesias

Time For A Tobin Tax

John Quiggin says that with the 99 percent out in the streets demanding justice, it’s time for a Tobin Tax — a tax on financial transactions.

I agree and want to add one consideration to the ones he offers. When you talk to people in the corridors of power about this idea, you get a peculiar kind of runaround. They don’t raise any objections of moral principle or fundamental logic. Instead they tell you that it’s more logistically complicated than it sounds, and requires difficult international coordination. Then instead of pivoting to a story about rolling up sleeves and getting to work on the logistics, you tend to get derisive remarks about the shallowness, naiveté, or opportunism of the people calling for the tax.

Nothing in that analysis is wrong, but to me that’s exactly the kind of situation where a little mass protest politics is exactly what you need. It’s not a question of better policy analysis or doing better persuasive work. It’s simply the fact that the people with the authority to make it happen prefer not to do the work that would be involved and don’t want to be hassled about it. Which I take to mean that if enough people are persistent enough in hassling them, they may ultimately decide that doing the work is the most expedient route to getting the hasslers to shut up. So hassle away. An FTT is not a panacea for the ills of the financial system, but it raises some money in a good way and it makes the right enemies.

Newer

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up