ThinkProgress Logo

Stories tagged with “George Zimmerman

Media

George Zimmerman’s Father Says The ‘True Racists’ Are African-American

As the murder trial for George Zimmerman begins, his father has released an emotional and highly unusual e-book, publicly opining on all aspects of the case. The book by Robert Zimmerman Sr., called “Florida v. Zimmerman: Uncovering the Malicious Prosecution of my Son, George” was released today on Amazon for $3.99.

The most striking chapter is called “Who Are The True Racists,” an apparent effort to rebut claims that his son’s actions were racially motivated.

Previously, Zimmerman Sr. “believed generally racism was a thing of the past.” He says that, personally, he hadn’t encountered much racism, even though his wife is Hispanic. But after his son shot and killed Trayvon Martin, however, Zimmerman learned that racism is “flourishing at the insistence of some in the African American Community.” He then goes on to list various black leaders and organizations that he believes are racist:

Congressional Black Caucus. “[A] pathetic, self-serving group of racists… advancing their purely racist agenda.” He later adds that “all members of Congress should be ashamed of the Congressional Black Caucus, as should be their constituents.” And finally: “They are truly a disgrace to all Americans.”

The NAACP. “[S]imply promotes racism and hatred for their own, primarily finical, interests” and “without prejudice and racial divide, the NAACP would simply cease to exist.”

NAACP President Benjamin Jealous. “[W]hat I would expect of a racist.”

Trayvon Martin’s funeral director. A “racial activist and former head of the local NAACP.”

Benjamin Crump, Natialie Jackson and Darrly Parks, attorneys for Travyon Martin’s family. “The scheme team.”

The National Basketball Players Association.

Black Chamber of Commerce.

National Association of Black Law Enforcement Officers.

National Black United Fund.

United Negro College Fund.

While stopping short of explicitly calling President Obama a racist, Zimmerman Sr. does say that Obama and Attorney General Eric Holder have “shamelessly” sought to exploit his son’s case “to obtain great advantage in the African-American community.”

Zimmerman Sr. says that because of Holder’s decision to investigate whether Trayvon Martin’s death violated federal civil rights laws, the FBI did not have “adequate resources to investigate clearly identified potential terrorist [sic] in the Boston area.” Now, “tragically, we have suffered the consequences of Mr. Holder’s politically motivated decisions.”

Media

Fox News Speculates Trayvon Martin Could Have Killed Someone With Skittles And Iced Tea

Credit: Getty Images

On the first day of George Zimmmerman’s murder trial, a Fox News guest suggested that the defense may be able to establish that Zimmerman acted in self-defense when he fatally shot Trayvon Martin, because “you could probably kill somebody” with a bag of Skittles and a can of iced tea.

To earn an acquittal, Zimmerman’s defense team must establish that he used reasonable force when he shot the unarmed teen. “There’s certainly a very good argument to be made that the force used was out of proportion to what was going on, and the kid was unarmed,” Fox guest Doug Burns, a former federal prosecutor, told the Fox host in an online interview. But then he ventured that in a “totally different case, let’s say the kid had a gun.”

Martin, of course, did not have a gun. He was found with only Skittles and an Arizona Iced Tea can.

“I know everybody keeps sarcastically saying about he Skittles,” Burns said. “You could probably kill somebody with Skittles.”

Fox host Jamie Colby replied, “But he didn’t take that iced tea and bang Zimmerman over the head with the bottle.”

“The thing is, yeah, you’re spinning a lot of hypotheticals,” Burns said. “And you could break a bottle of iced tea, right, with the jagged edge, and you could kill somebody with it.”

Watch it: (HT: Crooks And Liars)


Last year, Fox host Geraldo Rivera sympathized with Zimmerman and prompted widespread protest over his remark that “I think the hoodie is as much responsible for Trayvon Martin’s death as George Zimmerman was.” As the case gained national attention, many used Skittles and iced tea to protest how Florida police handled the case.

Before the trial began, Zimmerman’s attorney also went on Fox to discuss “new evidence” about Martin’s life, which experts say was an attempt to pollute the jury.

Update

Former NYPD detective Harry Houck told FoxNews.com Tuesday that “Trayvon Martin would be alive today” if he didn’t have “street attitude.” When criminal defense attorney Tamara Holder pointed out that his comment “can be used as something racist,” Houck laughed it off. “Personally, I think people who use the word ‘thug’ or believe that the word ‘thug’ is a racist [word] is racist themselves,” Houck said. “You know, because I call somebody a thug, I’m a racist? No. I don’t think so. I mean, that’s crazy.” Raw Story has the full video.

Justice

How George Zimmerman Could Be Convicted Of Murder

[See also: How George Zimmerman Could Be Acquitted Of Murder]

On June 10, the murder trial of George Zimmerman will begin, 470 days after he shot and killed Trayvon Martin on a rainy evening in Sanford, Florida.

Since that night, Martin’s death has already had a profound impact on Sanford and the nation. But outcome of the trial, which is expected to last between four to eight weeks, is still uncertain. Since Zimmerman does not dispute that he killed Martin, the defense must establish that Zimmerman acted in self defense.

Here is the key evidence that could support a murder conviction.

1. Expert audio analysis. An audio expert says Trayvon Martin screamed “stop” and “I’m begging you” just before shot was fired. Alan Reich, an audio expert retained by the prosecution, says his analysis of 911 calls that night revealed that it was Martin, not Zimmerman, who was crying out for help prior to the shooting. Another expert, Thomas Owens, said he ruled out Zimmerman as the source of the screams. The defense has retained an expert from the United Kingdom who says the kind of analysis performed by the prosecution experts is not reliable.

If Reich’s testimony is admitted at trial and the jury finds it to be reliable, it would seem to undermine Zimmerman’s claim of self-defense. Its unclear if the testimony will ever reach the jury, however. The judge held a hearing on the admissibility of Reich’s analysis over three days but was unable to conclude it prior to the start of jury selection. The prosecution must show Reich’s “conclusions are based on methods ‘commonly accepted within their particular scientific or expert community‘ as reliable.” It will be completed next week.

2. Witness 8. A woman talking to Martin on the phone just before his death says Martin told her about a man following him and that he was scared. The woman, known as Witness 8, says “she heard Trayvon ask, ‘What are you following me for?’ and heard the man reply, ‘What are you doing around here?’” before the phone went dead. You can listen to a portion of her interviews with the prosecutor here.

The testimony signifiantly bolsters the prosecution’s contention that it was Zimmerman, not Martin, who was the aggressor. The defense is aggressively seeking to undermine her credibility, noting that she lied to prosecutors when she said “she was in the hospital on the day of Martin’s funeral.”

3. George Zimmerman’s credibility. During the bail hearing for George Zimmerman, his wife Shellie testified via phone about their finances. She testified that she had not assets when, in fact, they had transferred $74,000 raised online to an account controlled by her. She coordinated the transfers via jailhouse conversations she had with George, apparently in code. Shelly has been charged with perjury. Although George did not testify, he knew his wife was not telling the truth and allowed her to testify without alerting his attorney.

The prosecution has made a motion to compel Shellie to testify at a deposition and may seek to introduce evidence of the deception during the trial. The case rests in no small part on George Zimmerman’s credibility, as he was the only eyewitness to the entire incident.

To support the charge of 2nd Degree Murder the prosecution also must prove that Zimmerman acted with a “depraved mind” when he shot Martin. If the prosecution fails to prove that, the jury can consider a lesser charge of manslaughter.

Justice

How George Zimmerman Could Be Acquitted Of Murder

[See also: How George Zimmerman Could Be Convicted Of Murder]

On June 10, the murder trial of George Zimmerman will begin, 470 days after he shot and killed Trayvon Martin on a rainy evening in Sanford, Florida.

Since that night, Martin’s death has already had a profound impact on Sanford and the nation. But the outcome of the trial, which is expected to last between four to eight weeks, is still uncertain. Since Zimmerman does not dispute that he killed Martin, the defense must establish that Zimmerman acted in self defense.

Here is the key evidence that could support an aquittal.

1. No true eyewitness other than Zimmerman. The most significant evidence supporting the defense’s case is that the only living eyewitness to the entire incident is George Zimmerman. Ultimately, the burden of proof is on the prosecution to prove that Zimmerman was not acting in self-defense. Zimmerman, of course, says that his head was being pounded on the concrete and he had to shoot Trayvon Martin to save his own life. The prosecution will have to completely discredit Zimmerman’s version of the events without any eyewitness testimony supporting their petition.

Zimmerman may not testify during the trial. He has given several statements to the police which could be admitted as evidence.

2. A bloody nose. Photos of Zimmerman taken immediately after the shooting show he was injured — primarily a bloody nose and other lacerations to the head — during his altercation with Martin. Although this does not establish who was the aggressor, it is consistent with Zimmerman’s version of the events.

Police “challenged him about the injuries, saying they were not severe and nowhere near life-threatening.”

3. Witness 6. A neighbor of Zimmerman says that, at one point, “he saw Trayvon on top, beating or pushing down on Zimmerman ‘MMA-style.’

Witness 6′s account of the event, however, is far from definitive. He initially claimed that Zimmerman was screaming prior to the gun shot, but later recanted.

To support the charge of 2nd Degree Murder the prosecution also must prove that Zimmerman acted with a “depraved mind” when he shot Martin. If the prosecution fails to prove that, the jury can consider a lesser charge of manslaughter.

Politics

Experts: George Zimmerman’s Lawyers Are Trying To Pollute The Jury Pool

George Zimmerman

On June 10, George Zimmerman will begin trial for the death of 17-year-old Trayvon Martin, who he shot unarmed on the street of a Florida gated community last year. But before the trial begins, Zimmerman’s defense team has aimed to portray Martin as a pot-smoking, violent teen — information the judge ruled inadmissible at the outset of the trial.

ThinkProgress spoke to three law experts in Florida on the issue, and they saw no reason that this information any indicator of Zimmerman’s guilt. By appearing on Fox News before the judge ruled on it, O’Mara saw the likelihood it would be barred and attempted to reach the jury through other channels. For instance, he broadcast a photo on Fox of a black hand holding a gun, allegedly from Martin’s phone.

“I think they are trying to poison the jury,” University of Miami Associate Professor of law Tamara Lave, a practicing attorney of 10 years, said. “I think he’s been trying to do this all along to win in the court of public opinion so he can win in the courtroom to get prosecutor to dismiss.” Unable to imagine “in good faith” he’d believe the evidence would be admitted, Lave also questioned why he would discuss it on national television when he knew the outcome.

At the pretrial, Zimmerman’s attorneys claimed a video recording on Martin’s phone was of his friends “beating up a homeless guy.” It turns out it wasn’t: it was two homeless men fighting over a bicycle. Zimmerman’s attorneys apologized for the mischaracterization on Sunday, a full five days after the pretrial.

Still, these details can prejudice potential jurors before a fair trial.

“It could have been a strategic maneuver to put things out there about the victim,” Florida attorney Spencer Charif said of one of the reasons this may have happened. “Sometimes the retraction in the newspaper is much smaller than the headline. 10 people think the video is harmless and 100 people think Trayvon had something.”

Charif, who has been a state attorney for three years and in private practice for seven, said that he “never had a video of another fight come in the defense case. I don’t know how that would have been relevant.”

According to Suzanne Villano, a Florida public defender of six years, this type of evidence is typically not probative — meaning, it does not prove the point of the case, but relies instead on its shock value.

A poll conducted last year showed a stark racial divide among people who think Zimmerman unjustly killed Martin; 91 percent and 59 percent of African-Americans and Hispanic Americans believe it was unjust, compared to 35 percent of white Americans. So the scrutiny of Martin’s records — which are promoted on sites like Drudge — are “terms that mean something,” Lave said. “Saying things to people about the value of Trayvon‘s life, that it’s worth less. ”

What the jury will try to determine is whether Zimmerman was reasonable or not to use deadly force. The possible outcomes that O’Mara is aiming for is an acquittal, or a hung verdict. And Villano said from her experience as a public defender juries “are very much moved by physical evidence and didn’t like to evaluate a testimony of a witness.”

In this case, the lawyers representing Martin’s family said the so-called evidence O’Mara fought to include was intentionally fabricated.

Justice

Zimmerman Lawyer Goes On National TV To Smear Trayvon Martin With Inadmissible Evidence

A Florida judge ruled Tuesday that George Zimmerman will not able to use 17-year-old Trayvon Martin’s school records, texts, and prior marijuana use in court for the second-degree murder trial for killing the teen last year, which begins June 10.

The case became notorious for Zimmerman’s claim he was protected from trial under Florida’s ALEC-modeled Stand Your Ground law. Since then, Zimmerman has dropped his Stand Your Ground defense, but he will still argue he acted in self defense when he shot the unarmed teen on the street of a gated community. The two sides appeared in court Tuesday to present a number of motions, including what evidence is admissible in court and a failed motion to delay the trial.

But before the hearing today, Zimmerman’s lawyer released images and texts that attempt to cloud Martin’s public image.

On air last week, Mike O’Mara touted the new images he said portray a more “three-dimensional picture of Trayvon.” According to Mediaite, Fox broadcast images from Martin’s phone that showed a hand holding a gun and a photograph of marijuana, which O’Mara argues is central to his client’s argument that he acted in self-defense because it shows Martin was “street-wise.

The judge has decided that none of this information will be permitted in court. However, Zimmerman’s defense may still hope the campaign has implications for the trial and for potential jurors.

Benjamin Crump, the attorney for Martin’s family, explained in a statement Thursday:

Is the defense trying to prove Trayvon deserved to be killed by George Zimmerman because (of) the way he looked? If so, this stereotypical and closed-minded thinking is the same mindset that caused George Zimmerman to get out of his car and pursue Trayvon, an unarmed kid who he didn’t know. The pretrial release of these irrelevant red herrings is a desperate and pathetic attempt by the defense to pollute and sway the jury pool.

In the Orlando Sentinel, state prosecutors said the information is “irrelevant… and would serve only to prejudice the jury.”

Media

8 Inspiring Things That Happened Since Trayvon Martin Was Tragically Killed One Year Ago Today

One year ago today, Trayvon Martin — an unarmed 17-year-old boy on his way home from 7-11 — was shot and killed by George Zimmerman. The murder trial is scheduled to begin this June. A separate hearing may be held in April to determine whether Florida’s controversial “Stand Your Ground” law gives Zimmerman immunity.

While nothing can make up for the events of February 26, 2012, many people have responded to the tragedy with compassion, courage and strength. Here are some of the most inspiring things that have happened over the last year.

1. 192 colleagues of Trayvon Martin’s mother donated 1,362 hours of their vacation time so she could grieve.

“Sybrina Fulton, who has worked at the Miami-Dade County housing authority for 23 years, collected $40,825 worth of donated vacation time, county records show… the Miami-Dade County Commission passed a resolution sponsored by Bruno Barreiro, Barbara Jordan and Jose “Pepe” Diaz to allow county employees to donate vacation time to Fulton…Records show 192 county employees gave Fulton some of their hours” [Miami Herald, 5/12/2012]

2. Sanford, Florida has a new police chief who has pledged to finally address “long-standing racial tensions between the police department and the African-American community.”

The police chief who decided not to charge George Zimmerman was fired. [ABC7, 2/18/2013]

3. Dozens of major companies ended their support for ALEC, the right-wing group who championed “Stand Your Ground” laws.

The companies that ended their support for the American Legislative Exchange Council include “Coca-Cola, Pepsi, Kraft, McDonalds, Wendy’s, Blue Cross Blue Shield, Procter & Gamble, Amazon.com, Wal-Mart, Johnson & Johnson, Dell Computers, Best Buy, General Motors and Walgreens.” ALEC was also forced to end it’s “Public Safety and Election Task Force,” which advocated for “Stand Your Ground” laws around the country. At least 39 lawmakers have also ended their association with ALEC.[ThinkProgress, 4/17/2012; ThinkProgress, 8/7/2012; ThinkProgress, 5/18/2012]

4. Thousands of people peacefully gathered in Sanford, Florida to demand justice for Trayvon Martin.

[News 10, 3/22/2012]

5. A United States Congressman went on the floor of the House of Representatives in a hoodie to show solidarity with Trayvon.

Illionis Rep. Bobby Rush said, “Racial profiling has to stop Mr. Speaker. Just because someone wears a hoodie does not make them a hoodlum.” After delivering a rousing speech, he was escorted from the floor for violating decorum. [NBC News, 3/28/2012]

6. Legislation to repeal “Stand Your Ground” laws was introduced in four states.

The law was cited by the police as the reason Zimmerman was not arrested for weeks after Martin was killed. [Yahoo, 1/26/2013]

7. Students at Howard University produced this video to highlight the racial profiling of young black men.

“All young black men are not suspicious. We don’t deserve to be harassed, murdered, prosecuted or denied the protections of the justice system all because America believes that we are suspicious… Some of us have already and will eventually change the world. All are not suspicious.”

8. President Obama spoke out about Trayvon Martin in the Rose Garden.

“My main message is to the parents: If I had a son he’d look like Trayvon. I think they are right to expect that all of us as Americans are going to take this with the seriousness it deserves.” [3/23/2012]

Check out more examples on ColorLines.

Justice

What’s Happened In The Trayvon Martin Case Since You Stopped Paying Attention

It’s been nearly a year since George Zimmerman shot and killed Trayvon Martin, an unarmed 17-year-old on his way back to his father’s townhouse. In the weeks following the shooting, the story captured the nation’s attention, culminating with Zimmerman being charged with second-degree murder last April.

But as the story has receded from the headlines, the legal case has plodded along and the trial is likely to be completed this summer. Here’s what you may have missed:

1. Zimmerman has spent over $300,000 in donations over the last year and is desperate for more funds to finance his defense. Zimmerman has “spent more than $125,000″ on living expenses — not including security — over the last year. His lawyer acknowledged that “Zimmerman’s personal spending may seem exorbitant.” Zimmerman is considering asking the court to declare him “indigent, meaning the public would have to pay for Zimmerman’s defense.” Zimmerman was also sued by a security company for unpaid bills. [Orlando Sentinel, 1/20/2013; Miami Herald, 12/27/12]

2. The trial has been set for June 10. Zimmerman recently asked for a delay of the trial until November but a judge denied his request. Zimmerman’s lawyer says it is “physically impossible for us to be prepared” for trial at that time. A separate proceeding, essentially a mini-trial, to determine whether Zimmerman is immune from prosecution due to Florida’s “Stand Your Ground” law, is scheduled for April 22. [Orlando Sentinel, 2/5/13; Headline News, 2/13/13]

3. New forensic analysis “casts doubt on Zimmerman’s timeline on the night he shot and killed the unarmed teen.” The analysis was done by “Michael Knox, a retired Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office detective and crime scene investigator.” According to Knox, “based on the times and distances Zimmerman said he covered, Zimmerman would have still been on the phone with Sanford police when he claims he was attacked by Martin.” Knox says that other aspects of Zimmerman’s story, like the claim Martin was leaning over him at the time the shot was fired, are supported by forensic evidence. [News 4 Jacksonville, 2/10/13]

4. Zimmerman has gained 105 pounds. [Orlando Sentinel, 1/20/2013]

Zimmerman in February 2013. AP Images.

5. The defense team acquired Trayvon Martin’s school records. According to Zimmerman’s lawyers “some information in Trayvon Martin’s file could be relevant in the defense of George Zimmerman.” State prosecutors and the Martin family attorney opposed Zimmerman’s efforts to acquire the records arguing “because Zimmerman did not know Trayvon before the Feb. 26 shooting, the teen’s past was not a factor in the case.” [Orlando Sentinel, 1/16/13]

6. Zimmerman is suing NBC News. In the suit, Zimmerman claims NBC unfairly portrayed him as a “racist and predatory villain.” [ABC News, 12/6/12]

7. The judged denied Zimmerman’s request to be removed from GPS tracking. [Fox Orlando, 12/11/12]

8. Trayvon Martin would have turned 18 on February 5. [Huffington Post, 2/5/13]

NEWS FLASH

Judge Denies Zimmerman’s Request For Unmonitored Travel, Lower Bond In Trayvon Martin Murder Trial | At a pre-trial hearing Tuesday morning, a Florida judge denied motions to reduce George Zimmerman’s $1 million bond, and end his out-of-county travel restrictions and GPS monitoring. Zimmerman is accused of second-degree murder in the death of 17-year-old Trayvon Martin. Defense attorneys unsuccessfully asked Judge Debra Nelson to reduce the restrictions placed on Zimmerman by a previous judge, who has since been removed from the case. The trial is scheduled to begin in June.

NEWS FLASH

George Zimmerman Suing NBC Universal For ‘Deceptive And Exploitative Manipulations’ Of Audio Tapes | George Zimmerman, the man who was arrested and charged with second degree murder in the death of Florida teenager Trayvon Martin earlier this year, announced through his attorneys today that he is suing NBC Universal and three current and former employees of NBC News. In a suit filed with the Seminole County circuit court, Zimmerman’s lawyers recount a number of instances in which NBC News personnel edited audio tape of 911 calls in what they argue was a deliberate and malicious attempt to portray Zimmerman in a negative light. Of the three reporters named in the suit, two of them were subsequently fired by NBC News for their roles in the stories. The network issued a statement several days after the segments aired apologizing for the mistakes, and denied the edits were anything but accidental. News of the suit — along with a link to the court document — was first posted on a website set up by the Zimmerman defense team.

Older

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up