ThinkProgress Logo

Immigration

Special Coverage: Immigration

How The Highly Skilled Visa Program Is Cutting Women Out

The latest word out of the Senate gang of eight is that an immigration deal may adopt a Republican proposal to shift the focus away from family-based immigration in favor of employment-based immigration. A new report shows how that approach would particularly hurt women: Data acquired by Contra Costa Times shows that men are much more likely to receive visas for highly skilled labor than women.

There is at least one type of employment visa that favors men over women: H-1B visas, which cover highly skilled workers and are popular in the heavily male tech industry. In 2011, 70 percent of H-1B visas for highly skilled workers were men:

The U.S. Office of Immigration Statistics recorded 347,087 male H-1B visa holders entered the country during the 2011 fiscal year compared to 137,522 women. The data is imperfect because it includes many H-1B immigrants traveling to the United States after visits to their home countries, not just first-time arrivals.

Examples of the gender gap go beyond H-1Bs: “Among professional and management workers, about 67,000 immigrant men and only 39,000 immigrant women earned green cards last year for permanent U.S. residency.” The result is men receive 63 percent of green cards, even though women hold a majority of those jobs.

On Monday, the Senate Judiciary Committee examined immigration reform’s impact on women immigrants. Sen. Mazie Hirono (D-HI), addressing an audience of just three other senators at the hearing, said there should be no “either-or proposition” between family-based and employment-based immigration. In fact, President of Asian American Justice Center Mee Moua shut down Sen Jeff Sessions (R-AL) argument against admitting family members, arguing that Sessions’ proposal would “disadvantage specifically women and their opportunity to come into this country.”

UPDATE: Tea Party Senator Rand Paul Embraces Legal Status For Undocumented Immigrants

In the latest sign that comprehensive immigration reform has unprecedented popular and political support, Sen. Rand Paul (R-KY) endorsed on Tuesday a pathway to citizenship for 11 million undocumented immigrants.

The Tea Party favorite is presenting his own plan for reform, and departs from the Senate gang of eight’s plan by opposing the expansion of E-Verify — an error-prone system used by employers to check the legal status of workers. That would be “forcing businesses to become policemen,” Paul said.

His emphasis instead is on making citizenship contingent on meeting certain benchmarks for border security. Since 2007, the security on the border has greatly improved as border crossings are at a 40-year low and the vast majority of the border meets one of Homeland Security’s highest standards of security.

Paul’s plan creates an even longer road to citizenship, beyond the decade proposed by the Senate gang of eight. In year two, immigrants would receive temporary work visas, though Border Patrol, an inspector general and Congress would need to sign off on an improved border situation before other reforms move forward.

“If you wish to live and work in America, then we will find a place for you,” Paul said, according to the Associated Press.

Four months ago, Mitt Romney’s immigration policy was to suggest “self-deportation.” The conversation is at a different point now — Paul acknowledged “we aren’t going to deport” the millions here — showing how fringe the anti-immigrant Republican wing has become.

Update

Rand Paul’s advisers claim the Associated Press report is false, and the senator does not back a path to citizenship. His office said in a statement, “He does not mention ‘path to citizenship’ in his speech at all.” An adviser told the Washington Post, “What his plan is extending to them is a quicker path to normalization, not citizenship, and being able to stay, work and pay taxes legally.”

The headline has been updated.

Update

This afternoon CNN’s Wolf Blitzer asked Paul to clarify his position, and the senator admitted he in fact supports an eventual path to citizenship: “It gets you in the line to enter the country legally to become a citizen like everybody else who wants to come from around the world to be a citizen.”

BLITZER: In other words you are not ruling out but supporting eventually after several steps are taken that these 11 or 12 million illegal immigrants will eventually if they do all the right things be allowed to become United States citizens.

PAUL: Interestingly yes, but at the same time not proposing something new.

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up