ThinkProgress Logo

Stories tagged with “Tax Loopholes

Alyssa

Amazon Will Start Collecting Sales Tax In California

Amazon has apparently reached a deal with the state of California where the company will drop a proposed ballot initiative that would protect it from collecting sales tax on its transactions and in return, won’t start having to collect those taxes until next September.

I wrote in July that I thought Amazon had shifted the market enough that charging sales tax wouldn’t actually put it at a disadvantage with competing retailers, online or off—it has better stock than brick and mortar stores, and volume and corresponding price advantages over other online stores. And I wonder if the largely positive news that’s greeted reports of Amazon’s planned tablet launch, whether it’s TechCrunch’s declaration that it’ll be “huge, potentially,” or Tim Carmody’s explanation of how Amazon is fulfilling Steve Jobs’ vision in a way even Apple can’t, has made the company feel more confident.

Either way, collecting sales tax is the right thing for Amazon to do, no matter how secure the company feels about its market position. We’ll see where Amazon is as a company in 14 months when it starts collecting sales tax on that large market.

NEWS FLASH

Gov. Jerry Brown Slaps Down Amazon’s Attempt To Maintain Its Massive Tax Loophole | Jon Ortiz at the Sacramento Bee reports that Gov. Jerry Brown (D-CA) dealt a swift blow to Amazon’s proposal to keep its massive sales tax loophole open. Earlier this week, Amazon.com proposed to hire more workers and open new distribution centers in the Golden State in return for a promise from legislators to keep open a sales tax loophole that allows the company to dodge $200 million in yearly taxes. “I’m concerned about anything that will reduce revenue going forward because we have a very uncertain economy,” the governor said today, throwing cold water on the plan pitched by Amazon’s lobbyists.

NEWS FLASH

Paul Ryan Tried To Carve Out Tax Loopholes For Biggest Campaign Donors | House Budget Chairman Paul Ryan (R-WI) has tried to “create an array of special loopholes for his top contributors,” the Huffington Post’s Jennifer Bendery reports. For instance, household cleaner giant S.C. Johnson & Son is one of Ryan’s biggest donors, giving him more than $41,000 over his career, and Ryan crafted two bills that would have given the company special exemptions from trade tariffs. The bills, which did not pass, specially mentioned the company, with one exempting “unique air freshener products…assembled by S.C. Johnson in the United States.” Likewise, Ryan created bills that would have carved out tax exemptions for the beer industry after the National Wholesalers Association, his second biggest contributor, gave him more than $72,000. Another bill would have created tax loopholes for fraternity and sororities after Fraternity & Sorority PAC gave Ryan over $24,500.

Climate Progress

Koch Sen. Scott Brown Threatens Social Security And Medicare Cuts, Refuses To Close Big Oil Tax Loopholes

Sen. Scott Brown (R-MA) thanks petrochemical billionaire David Koch for contributions, March 2011.

Sen. Scott Brown (R-MA) continues to defend oil subsidies and tax cuts for millionaires, while now threatening to cut Social Security and Medicare. Because “we’re in a financial emergency,” Brown told senior citizens at the Jewish Community Housing for the Elderly in Brighton on Monday, existing programs for seniors are under the axe:

If anybody’s telling you that ‘Everything’s OK, and don’t worry about it, and you’re going to get all your benefits, and everything’s fine,’ then they’re not really telling you the truth.

This comes only a few months after Brown attacked Democrats for “scare tactics” over the debt ceiling fight. At the meeting, Brown was asked if he was willing to fight the “financial emergency” by asking oil companies and millionaires to make any financial sacrifice, instead of seniors. Brown said that would be “an absolute job killer“:

Would you be willing to support closing tax loopholes on big oil? …Would you be willing to raise revenue on the wealthiest 1 percent?

Brown said he had voted to close some loopholes, such as a tax subsidy for ethanol. But he said he was not inclined to support any more taxes.

“We’re in a 2 1/2- to 3-year recession right now, and raising taxes is an absolute job killer,” he said.

That’s right: asked about eliminating subsidies that benefit Big Oil, Brown touted his vote to end an ethanol subsidy. His vote helped Big Oil keep its stranglehold on the U.S. economy.

Brown’s economic math isn’t any better. The recession began in December 2007, over three years ago, and formally ended in June 2009, over two years ago. Even though the private sector has been adding jobs at a steady clip this year, unemployment remains high because of mass layoffs in the public sector. And those are the jobs paid for by taxes.

While senior citizens suffer, the super-wealthy and the corporations are paying record low taxes while making record high profits, thanks to tax cuts for the rich under Reagan, Bush, Clinton, Bush, and Obama. Brown is subsidizing his donor base, like the Tea Party billionaire Koch brothers, on the backs of America’s hard-working middle class and vulnerable senior citizens. Maybe Brown is worried that it would be an “absolute job killer” or a “financial emergency” if he were to work for his constituents instead of his paymasters.

Economy

GOP Gov. Kasich Tells GOP To ‘Be A Leader’ And Close Tax Loopholes

The GOP’s stubborn refusal to close frivolous tax loopholes is receiving flak from an unexpected corner. This morning on MSNBC’s Morning Joe, Ohio Gov. John Kasich scoffed at the GOP’s unwillingess to “be a leader” in the debt ceiling negotiations.

Aghast that the GOP would push “caps and gimmicks” to address the debt, he demanded to know whether the GOP would “put [its] head in the sand” and “let America default?” “You gotta be kidding me,” he exclaimed, pushing Republicans to get a debt deal “in the middle.” When asked by columnist Mike Barnicle whether he’d consider closing loopholes in order to avoid tax increases, Kasich said “Yeah! There’s enough in that [federal tax] code” to seriously address the deficit:

BARNICLE: Closing loopholes..

KASICH: Great!

BARNICLE: Closing loopholes would provide you with enough revenue, widen the revenue stream, that you wouldn’t have to go to tax increases.

KASICH: Yeah I think there’s enough in that code.

BARNICLE: If you really go after it.

KASICH: If you really do it. And here’s the thing, when you do that, that ought to come a little later. Because I’ll tell you what Congress will do. Republicans blew the big surplus, Joe! They went on a spending binge we couldn’t believe it, after 2000!

Watch it:

In this instance, Kasich is correct. As Center for American Progress’s Seth Hanlon and Michael Ettlinger note, there’s more than $1 trillion of wasteful spending hidden in the federal tax code to go after. These include billions in subsidies to highly profitable oil and gas industry, a tax loophole or hedge fund managers, and tax breaks for horse breeders, for corporate meals and entertainment, for vacation homes and yachts, and for corporate jets. Those tax breaks alone would save taxpayers more than $75 billion over the next ten years.

Incidentally, Kasich’s new found sense of national leadership doesn’t seem to apply to Ohio. Since taking office in January, he has slashed and burned vital public programs in his budget while cutting taxes for corporations and the wealthy. If Kasich preaches a rational approach on the national stage, perhaps he should practice it in his state.

Update

Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-NY) offered his compliments to Kasich’s new found common sense, tweeting this morning “Glad to see @JohnKasich supports closing wasteful tax loopholes in debt deal- DC Rs should too.”

Economy

If Gov. Brown Approves End Of ‘Amazon Tax Loophole,’ It Would Raise Enough Revenue To Reverse Child Welfare Cuts

Will Brown defend the welfare of his state's children by closing the "Amazon Tax Loophole"?

Earlier this month, the California Legislature approved the final version of a bill that would effectively end tax-dodging by online retailers like Amazon.com and Overstock.com, requiring them to collect sales taxes just like any other retailer.

Now, the provision is sitting on the desk of California Gov. Jerry Brown (D), who has to decide whether he will approve it or veto it. As of Friday, the San Francisco Chronicle reported that lawmakers who are pushing for ending the tax loophole currently are unsure of what Brown will do.

As the Associated Press reports today, ending the online sales tax loophole nationwide could bring in $23 billion of revenue annually. In California, ending this loophole for just one retailer — Amazon.com — would bring in enough revenue to reverse the state’s cuts to child welfare services:

State governments across the country are laying off teachers, closing public libraries and parks, and reducing health care services, but there is one place they could get $23 billion a year if they could only agree how to do it: Internet retailers such as Amazon.com. That’s enough to pay for the salaries of more than 46,000 teachers, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. In California, the amount of uncollected taxes from Amazon sales alone is roughly the same amount cut from child welfare services in the current state budget.

Amazon has previously responded to legislative efforts to close the tax loophole by threatening to cut ties to affiliates in the state of California. Some estimates say that California could collect as much as $1.1 billion annually from online retailers if it closed the online sales tax loophole.

NEWS FLASH

California Legislators Send Budget Closing ‘Amazon Tax Loophole’ To Governor | “For only the second time in 25 years a California spending plan was passed” on time yesterday. Included in the budget sent by legislators to Gov. Jerry Brown (D-CA) was a provision closing the “Amazon tax loophole,” which allows online retailers to escape the collection of sales taxes. “We’re finally on the way to creating a level playing field for California companies,” said State Sen. Loni Hancock in response to the bill’s passage.

NEWS FLASH

Louisiana House Passes Bill To Close ‘Amazon Tax Loophole’ | The Louisiana Legislature voted 78-14 to pass a bill that would move to close a special loophole in the tax code that allows online retailers like Amazon and Overstock to escape collecting sales taxes. “We can’t afford to give away revenues by not collecting sales taxes,” said Rep. Rosalind Jones (D). “The hardware store down the street from your house must collect and pay Louisiana taxes. It’s only fair for these huge out-of-state companies to play by the same rules.”

Economy

Republican-Led TX House Smacks Down Gov. Rick Perry, Forces Through Legislation To End Internet Sales Tax Dodging

Large online retailers like Overstock.com and Amazon.com have exploited a loophole in state tax codes to avoid paying sales taxes. As ThinkProgress has reported, this brazen tax dodging has cost states across the country hundreds of millions of dollars in desperately needed revenue. Last month in Texas, Gov. Rick Perry (R-TX) vetoed legislation, passed by a bipartisan majority in the state Legislature, to end the loophole.

However, Republicans in the Legislature have struck back at Amazon.com lobbyists and are circumventing Perry’s veto. State Rep. John Otto (R) added an amendment to a “must-pass” spending bill restoring language to the tax code that would end the Internet sales tax loophole. Perry’s allies in the legislature moved to table the Otto amendment, only to be rebuked by a landside vote:

Rep. Bill Zedler, R-Arlington, filed an amendment to strip the language from SB 1, but his provision did not survive a spirited debate in the House, where members voted 106-34 to table it. [...] The fiscal matters bill still has to pass the House, and then likely would have to go back to the Senate for approval. If the online sales tax-related language from Otto survives that process, Perry would have to veto the entire fiscal matters bill to remove it.

The success of the Otto amendment to close the loophole shows the growing bipartisan support for ending corporate welfare and other tax giveaways. As Otto explained during the debate over his amendment, the effort has less to do with “raising taxes” and is actually about creating a “level playing field” with other “retailers who are competing against these companies.” Tax fairness creates a better business environment, and it strengthens the state’s finances.

Earlier this year, Texas Comptroller Susan Combs filed a report showing that Amazon.com’s exploitation of the loophole has cost the state $269 million in sales taxes it failed to collect from 2005 to 2009. As Texas struggles with a large deficit, Perry has moved to slash education, health, and other vital services.

Newer

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up