ThinkProgress Logo

Stories tagged with “Thaddeus McCotter

Economy

Romney Endorser Thad McCotter: ‘There Was No Choice’ But To Rescue The Auto Industry

Former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney (R) narrowly won the Michigan primary last night despite his rampant opposition to the auto industry rescue that saved the state’s largest industry, likely because his main competition for the primary victory also wanted to let Detroit go bankrupt. But in the two weeks before the primary, Romney’s position was criticized by Michigan Republicans, auto industry insiders, and reporters who covered the rescue, many of whom said Romney’s plan would have killed the American automotive industry.

Rep. Thaddeus McCotter (R-MI), a former candidate for president who endorsed Romney after leaving the race, piled onto that criticism last night during MSNBC’s election coverage, telling the network’s panel that not rescuing the auto industry would have hastened the “deindustrialization of America.” McCotter also criticized Republicans who, like Romney, supported the Wall Street bailout while opposing the auto rescue:

MCCOTTER: But it’s not simply the auto industry. It’s about blue collar jobs, white collar jobs, non-unionized jobs, unionized jobs, and the deindustrialization of America that would have even hastened had those companies been allowed to seize up, go into bankruptcy and put hard-working men and women…high and dry. [...]

Now when you also look at what happened with the bridge loan, as we talked about at the time, President Bush authorized that money to come out of the already-appropriated funds that were targeted to the Wall Street people that caused the problems in the first place. So to my fellow Republicans I’ll simply remind them, if you were in Congress at the point in time or if you were President Bush, you could leave all $700 billion of taxpayers hard-earned money with the Wall Street people, or you could take some back to Main Street to keep America a balanced, vibrant economy. To me there was no choice.

Watch it:

Romney’s position on Wall Street bailout has varied, but most recently, he offered support for it in a way that resembled the support many of his fellow Republicans had for the auto rescue. “The TARP program, while not transparent and not having been used as wisely it should have been, was nevertheless necessary to keep banks from collapsing in a cascade of failures,” Romney told Reuters. “You cannot have a free economy and free market if there is not a financial system.”

Unfortunately, Romney never felt the same way about the failure of the auto industry, which, according to one estimate, would have lost 1.3 million jobs without the rescue.

Alyssa

Battle of the Bands: 2012 Republican Field Edition

The 2012 Republican presidential field may not have a lot of advocates of public support for the arts or arts education. But it does have a lot of folks who harbor rock-star dreams. So it seems appropriate to evaluate how hard they rock out. We may not know who our next president is for another fourteen months and change, but we can crown a new Republican Idol today.

Candidate: Rep. Thaddeus McCotter
Band: Two, the Second Amendments, composed of members of Congress, and the Screaming Lemurs, which
Instrument: Guitar
Period Active: Present
Rebel Factor: Low. Playing the New Hampshire Young Republican Lobster Bake and Straw Poll’s good work if you can get it, but it’s not the Cavern Club. This is establishment rock at its finest.

Candidate: Former U.S. Ambassador to China Jon Huntsman
Band: Wizard
Instrument: Keyboard
Period Active: Late 1970s
Rebel Factor: Moderate. Huntsman did drop out of high school in his senior year to pursue his dreams of rock superstardom. But the risk factor for that kind of thing’s a lot lower when your father is a billionaire.

Candidate: Texas Gov. Rick Perry
Band: ZZ Top, with whom Perry once played
Instrument: Drums
Period Active: 2003, a single concert where Perry sat in on “La Grange,” a song about what the band apparently believes to be the best little whorehouse in Texas.

Rebel Factor: Low-moderate. Perry reportedly wore a kind of strange jumpsuit on stage, though photographic evidence suggets a kind of dorky button-down. Either way, Billy Gibbons is domesticated enough to have a recurring role on Bones, so taking the stage with him is not much of a risk.

Winner: Jon Huntsman. We would totally listen to Captain Beefheart with him in his “ugliest green Ford Econoline van you could ever imagine.” And if anyone has an actual Wizard recording (or video of Perry with ZZ Top), we’ll pay you in ice cold beer for it.

Alyssa

The 2012 Candidates On The Arts: Thaddeus McCotter

With arts and public broadcast issues percolating on the edge of the race for the 2012 presidential race, I thought it made sense to look at where the declared and prospective candidates for president have stood on arts issues throughout their careers. Their views on everything from arts education to intellectual property rights to support for local artistic traditions say a lot about how they value culture — but also about how they think about the role of government.

Michigan Rep. Thaddeus McCotter may rock a star-spangled Telecaster and play it for American troops in Iraq and Afghanistan. But as an elected official, he’s got a somewhat sparse record on the arts, where he mostly parrots conventional Republican positions (though he doesn’t demagogue as aggressively on arts funding as some of his rivals do):

2000: While a Michigan state senator, McCotter introduced a bill pushing for Michigan to appoint a poet laureate. At the time, the state was one of 13 that didn’t have a poet acting as ambassador for the arts. “We’re a hardworking Midwestern state, but we’re smart, too,” he said, suggesting Bob Seger be the initial laureate.

2004: McCotter got on the broadcast decency bandwagon after Justin Timberlake exposed Janet Jackson’s breast at the Super Bowl, supporting the Broadcast Decency Act of 2004, which would have increased FCC fines to as much as $500,000 per incident. That bill didn’t pass, though similar legislation was enacted in 2009. At the time, McCotter said, “We have to have a safe haven so parents don’t get any surprises…we don’t really know what’s safe for our kids to watch.”

2005: As isn’t particularly surprising for a Michigan lawmaker, McCotter’s been skeptical about the American trade relationship with China. As he wrote to President Bush that year, “As you know, China, despite strong action taken by Congress, continues to pirate intellectual property; produce counterfeit goods; dump these and other products into our markets; and engage in currency manipulation.”

2007: While in Congress, he co-sponsored a resolution that supported music education on the grounds that it helps boost test scores and develop students socially.

2009: McCotter was one of the Republican leaders who held a joint press conference opposing President Obama’s budget, objecting to items ranging from dog park funding to the National Endowment for the Arts. Their reaction was, he said, “the result of the American people across this country finding out what is in that bill and in their infinite common sense they understand that there is no relationship between billions in this bill and their chance of keeping their job or finding a new one.”

McCotter’s challenge on the arts and intellectual property issues is the same on many others — he’s a relatively undefined candidate, and in a crowded field, he may not be able to show off much in the way of meaningful differences.

NEWS FLASH

McCotter: Both Obamacare and Romneycare are ‘inhumane’ | The most recent GOP presidential entrant to the race, Rep. Thaddeus McCotter (MI), joined Gretchen Carlson on Fox and Friends this morning for a lightning round of question-and-answers on the issues. When asked whether he likes “Obamacare” or “Massachusetts care” in terms of a federal versus state approach to reform, McCotter declared, “I don’t like either one” because both plans were based on “comparative effectiveness research,” which he said allows government bureaucrats to determine whether a patient gets treatment. Thus, McCotter argued, they are both “very inhumane.” Watch it:

Politics

‘Michigan Message To Mitt’: GOP Rep. McCotter Slams Romney For Not Supporting Auto Rescue

GOP presidential candidate Mitt Romney is in the state of his birth this week — and receiving an icy reception. Michigan is home to General Motors and Chrysler, two U.S. companies for which the 2009 auto rescue “was seen as a matter of life or death by both parties.” Romney, however, opted for death when the Motor City native penned a op-ed entitled “Let Detroit Go Bankrupt” and slammed the rescue as “tragic.” This supposed tragedy, however, allowed Chrysler and GM to restructure and repay over $60 billion in taxpayer loans and add about 50,000 jobs nationwide.

As is his nature, Romney quickly switched positions in light of the rescue’s success and actually claimed last month that he “had the idea first.” However, Michiganders are not buying it. Rep. John Dingell (D) said yesterday that he hopes Romney “has answers for Michigan’s working families he abandoned two years ago” and “threw them under the bus.” Former Democratic Gov. Jennifer Granholm offered a pithier take in her own op-ed titled, “Let Mitt Romney Go Bankrupt.” Now, even Michigan Republican Rep. Thaddeus McCotter is wiping his hands of Romney. McCotter, who “supported the government intervention for General Motors and Chrysler,” sent “a Michigan message to Mitt” on his auto failure:

“Motor City hospitality dictates a Michigan message to Mitt that our struggling families, entrepreneurs and workers think Mr. Romney and Mr. Obama are not rivals, they’re running mates,” McCotter, who is considering his own run for the White House, said in a statement.

Watch video of his remarks:

Of course, President Obama actually delivered the auto rescue McCotter asked for. Conversely, auto industry officials say Romney’s rejection of that rescue “would have led to liquidation and the loss of more than one million jobs nationwide.” McCotter’s argument that Obama and Romney are similar when it comes to their health care plans and beliefs that global warming is a real problem, however, is much more accurate.

Whatever his current positions may be, it’s clear that Romney’s failure to back the auto rescue when it was most needed and his general “anti-auto sentiments” may prompt Michiganders to kick him to the curb. As Michigan Democratic Party Chairman Mark Brewer noted, “I don’t think we’ve seen a less inviting homecoming since LeBron (James) went back to Cleveland.”

Politics

Calling For An ‘Innovation Economy,’ Rep. McCotter Makes The Case For 19th-Century Technology

During his State of the Union Address, President Obama focused on how the United States can “win the future.” The “first step,” he declared, “is encouraging American innovation.”

One of the leading Republicans in Congress, Rep. Thaddeus McCotter (R-MI), appeared on the G. Gordon Liddy Show yesterday and discussed this notion of an “innovation economy.” After Liddy peddled the ludicrous claim that House Energy and Commerce Chairman Fred Upton (R-MI) had implemented a ban on incandescent light bulbs in the United States, McCotter used the opportunity to scoff at liberal efforts to improve the incandescent light bulb, a product that was first invented over 200 years ago. He called the irony “striking” that liberals would “prais[e] the end of the incandescent bulb at the very time they’re talking about an innovation economy”:

LIDDY: Is there any chance that you fellas can talk to [House Energy and Commerce Chairman Fred] Upton and get our light bulbs back, for heaven’s sake?

McCOTTER: Yes, yes. I saw that some on the left were praising the end of the incandescent bulb, at the very time they’re talking about an innovation economy. The irony is striking. One of the greatest innovations in American history was the incandescent bulb and I think we got to put it back where people can use them again.

Listen here:

The smaller point here is that, as Brad Johnson of ThinkProgress writes, “there was, in fact, no bill to ban incandescent light bulbs,” despite Liddy’s insistence to the contrary.

The larger point, however, is that McCotter’s idea of “innovation” in the 21st century is holding on to a 19th-century product with an iron grip. McCotter is undoubtedly correct that the incandescent bulb was “one of the greatest innovations in American history.” But the entire premise of innovation is that we keep improving instead of resting on our laurels. That’s precisely what is happening with modern upgrades to the incandescent light bulb. The New York Times reported last year that “the incandescent bulb is turning into a case study of the way government mandates can spur innovation.”

McCotter’s insistence that America’s best light bulb innovations came in the 19th century is troubling enough. It’s unclear if McCotter would also prefer the country revert back to typewriters and telegraphs.

Politics

Rep. McCotter Slams Cantor For Refusing To Cut Needless Program: He’s Got ‘YouCut,’ It Should Be ‘WeCut First’

Rep. Thaddeus McCotter (R-MI) essentially accused his own party leadership of hypocrisy yesterday for resisting the elimination of a federally-funded group that McCotter leads, but believes is superfluous. McCotter chairs the House Republican Policy Committee, but argues that its purpose has been absorbed by other Republican leadership offices. He wants to disband the committee and use its $360,000 a year budget to pay down the debt. But Minority Whip Eric Cantor (R-VA) and others in the GOP leadership have objected.

In a rare “public reflection of a behind-the-scenes battle,” McCotter slammed Cantor on Fox News yesterday, saying he is “absolutely mistaken” and that his position is an example of “the status quo in Washington”:

MCCOTTER: Well I hope it would happen, I think it’s the first step to showing we’re about deeds not words. … How can anybody in the Congressional Republican Caucus in the House come around and talk about making difficult choices in spending for real people if they’re aren’t willing to start with themselves? [...]

HOST: Well not all Republicans on board either. [...]

MCCOTTER: Well, I think Eric’s absolutely mistaken in that assumption. This is all we’ve ever heard out of the status quo in Washington. The reality is all of this can be done through the existing House standing committees. … We spend over a million on the whip’s office; we spend millions on the leader’s office. We can make a small, significant step to return it.

And as for the whip, I would encourage him, especially when he’s got his ‘YouCut’ program up there, to turn it into ‘WeCut’ first.

Watch it:

McCotter denied that the battle reflects a larger rift in the House GOP, but added, “I think it’s an opportunity to just show the people who are relying on us to have learned our lesson to see that we actually have started to prove it.”

Politics

Rep. McCotter complains that Obama ‘demonizes’ Wall Street and insurance companies.

thad-mccotter Last week on the House floor, Rep. Thaddeus McCotter (R-MI) attacked President Obama the day he signed the Affordable Care Act into law. “So this is what change looks like?” McCotter asked. “President Obama’s campaign mantra of hope and change has degenerated into tax and hate.” In a new interview with Real Clear Politics, McCotter explains that he made the claim because he’s upset that the President is taking on Wall Street and the insurance companies:

RCP: On Tuesday you said some things on the House floor that I want to ask you to defend. The first is your statement that “Obama’s campaign mantra of hope and change has degenerated into tax and hate.”

McCOTTER: Yeah. Look at how he demonizes oppositions, look what he’s done to insurance companies, look what he does to Wall Street, look at the end result. It’s to impose a tax, it’s to get his agenda passed. That’s things that Bush was accused of and I think it’s quite manifest in what he’s been doing to try to get his agenda through.

At least McCotter is staying consistent with the GOP line in siding with big business. House Minority Leader John Boehner (R-OH) urged bankers to stand up against “little punk staffers” on Capitol Hill trying to implement new Wall Street regulations. And Sen. Richard Shelby (R-AL) recently railed against new regulation, saying banks’ profits “trump[] the consumer finance whatever” — a reference to the proposed Consumer Financial Protection Agency. However, it seems that the GOP is out of step with Americans on these issues, as large majorities said in recent polls that they have an unfavorable view of Wall Street and “believe Congress and the President need to reform our financial system now.”

Climate Progress

Congressman ‘Caveman’ McCotter Cites The Experience Of Cavemen To Deny Manmade Global Warming

Last night on Fox News’ Red Eye, Rep. Thaddeus McCotter (R-MI) explained to host Greg Gutfeld why he does not believe that human activity is causing global warming. McCotter, who is the chairman of the Republican House Policy Committee, a GOP group charged with helping Republican lawmakers come up with legislative ideas, has used his global warming denials as a pretense for fighting to block cap-and-trade proposals.

Environmental groups have declared that McCotter is a “Caveman Congressman.” The satirical Caveman Energy Caucus website notes that lawmakers like McCotter have “chosen OLD energy when they voted no” on Waxman-Markey clean energy legislation. Ironically, as he explained his backwards denial of settled climate change science, McCotter cited the experience of his cavemen namesake to note that the melting of glaciers had a positive effect:

MCCOTTER: Remember, the people who talk about the melting of the glaciers and others, imagine if you were in a peninsula around 1,000 BC or so or earlier and your name was Tor and you’re out huntin’ mastodon. And you didn’t notice that the glaciers were melting and leaving the devastating flooding in its wake that became the Great Lakes in the state of Michigan.

So I think what we have to do is go back in history and look at this and realize that the Earth has been here a long time and they’ve selected periods of time and say somehow this proves there’s a manmade global warming occurring is absolutely wrong. We have to look at the different periods of history, we have to look at the different effects, and then we have to have direct empirical data to correlate between man’s activity and the effect on the planet, and that is yet to be proven and highly doubt that it’s going to be any time soon.

Watch it:

McCotter is wrong on several fronts. First, the glacial melt which formed the Great Lakes occurred between a period of 15,000 and 10,000 BC, not 1,000 BC, as McCotter claims. But we do not have to look to the past to see shrinking glaciers. Global warming is currently melting 18,000 Himalayan glaciers — the largest concentration of glaciers outside the great polar ice sheets. The global trend of melting glaciers has only accelerated, with 2009 marked as the 18th consecutive year glaciers around the world have decreased in size.

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has conclusively shown that carbon emissions, caused chiefly by the burning of fossil fuels, are the largest contributor to global warming. If McCotter is interested in what sets this “period in history” apart, he should know that every single year of this century (2001-2008) has been among the top ten warmest years since instrumental records began.

Cross-posted on ThinkProgress.

Politics

Congressman ‘Caveman’ McCotter Cites The Experience Of Cavemen To Deny Manmade Global Warming

Last night on Fox News’ Red Eye, Rep. Thaddeus McCotter (R-MI) explained to host Greg Gutfeld why he does not believe that human activity is causing global warming. McCotter, who is the chairman of the Republican House Policy Committee, a GOP group charged with helping Republican lawmakers come up with legislative ideas, has used his global warming denials as a pretense for fighting to block cap-and-trade proposals.

Environmental groups have declared that McCotter is a “Caveman Congressman.” The satirical Caveman Energy Caucus website notes that lawmakers like McCotter have “chosen OLD energy when they voted no” on Waxman-Markey clean energy legislation. Ironically, as he explained his backwards denial of settled climate change science, McCotter cited the experience of his cavemen namesake to note that the melting of glaciers had a positive effect:

MCCOTTER: Remember, the people who talk about the melting of the glaciers and others, imagine if you were in a peninsula around 1,000 BC or so or earlier and your name was Tor and you’re out huntin’ mastodon. And you didn’t notice that the glaciers were melting and leaving the devastating flooding in its wake that became the Great Lakes in the state of Michigan.

So I think what we have to do is go back in history and look at this and realize that the Earth has been here a long time and they’ve selected periods of time and say somehow this proves there’s a manmade global warming occurring is absolutely wrong. We have to look at the different periods of history, we have to look at the different effects, and then we have to have direct empirical data to correlate between man’s activity and the effect on the planet, and that is yet to be proven and highly doubt that it’s going to be any time soon.

Watch it:

McCotter is wrong on several fronts. First, the glacial melt which formed the Great Lakes occurred between a period of 15,000 and 10,000 BC, not 1,000 BC, as McCotter claims. But we do not have to look to the past to see shrinking glaciers. Global warming is currently melting 18,000 Himalayan glaciers — the largest concentration of glaciers outside the great polar ice sheets. The global trend of melting glaciers has only accelerated, with 2009 marked as the 18th consecutive year glaciers around the world have decreased in size.

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has conclusively shown that carbon emissions, caused chiefly by the burning of fossil fuels, are the largest contributor to global warming. If McCotter is interested in what sets this “period in history” apart, he should know that every single year of this century (2001-2008) has been among the top ten warmest years since instrumental records began.

Older

Switch to Mobile
ThinkProgress Signup Overlay Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress Skip and Continue to ThinkProgress

Sign Up