Obama and Post-Cold War Latin America

I have a new column up at The Daily Beast about the handshake of doom and the need for a shift to a post-Cold War policy toward Latin America:

Nowadays, the Soviets are long gone. And with them, all rationale for looking at the region through this lens. There’s just no way to imagine a military threat to the United States emerging from Latin America. For all the rhetorical heat generated by Chavez’s clashes with the American right, all he really wants from America is for Citgo to sell us oil and gas. And guess what? All we want from Venezuela is the ability to buy oil and gas. Latin America is close by, and, over a century, American meddling in its affairs has generated a lot of ill will. That ill will generates a certain number of movements powered by America-bashing rhetoric. The absolute worst thing we can do is respond by entering into a downward spiral of recriminations and cold shoulders that only builds more ill will. The best approach is to recognize that our interests in Latin America are limited in scope, so we should just do our best to be polite—cooperate with those governments who want to cooperate with us, and shake hands with the rest while perhaps making some small talk.

Instead, conservatives would have us double-down on decades of failed Cuba policy by extending the same treatment to Chavez and perhaps others such as Bolivia’s Evo Morales, Ecuador’s Rafael Correa, and Nicaragua’s Daniel Ortega. Realistically, all such a policy can achieve is antagonizing other Latin American leaders who don’t have the luxury of imperiously “isolating” their neighbors to create a self-fulfilling prophesy of an anti-American bloc. Look around at reviews of Obama’s performance at the summit, and outside the fever swamps of the American right the only criticism you hear is that the administration isn’t going far enough toward improving relations with Cuba. And that’s about right. After all, what was achieved by excluding Cuba from the meeting of hemispheric leaders? Citizens of all the countries of Americas should hope that the Obama-Chavez greeting won’t be the new president’s last controversial handshake.

A related angle on this, as per Daniel Drezner, is that Obama’s approach to foreign policy is about setting priorities and not wasting national energy and credibility on third-tier things like a spat with Venezuela.